The portrait hung in the parlor's north corner, where the damp had gotten in through a hairline crack in the plaster and worked its way down the canvas like a slow stain. Water damage didn't forgive much, but Viola had brought worse back from the dead — a Duval portrait she'd spent six weeks on, a Creole marriage fan with mold blooming across the silk. She laid the painting facedown across two sawhorses she'd dragged in from the carriage house, worked a scalpel under the frame's lip, and felt the whole thing sigh loose.
Sebastian stood in the doorway with his coffee. He hadn't offered to help. He'd been keeping to the kitchen side of the house since the third floor, and she'd let him, because every time their eyes met at the nursery door she could see the lie sitting behind his face like a coin behind a curtain.
"You don't have to watch," she said.
"I do, actually." He came in and set the cup on the marble mantel, far from the canvas. "The codicil says the estate inventory has to be preserved in condition found. Any restoration's arguably a violation."
"Any restoration's also the only reason this house is still standing. Your inventory's going to preserve a pile of rot." She dabbed at the corner with a swab, and the varnish came up yellow-brown, the color of old cigarette smoke. Beneath it, the underpainting bloomed out of the dark.
Sebastian watched her hands work. "You do that like you've done it a thousand times."
"Fourteen hundred, give or take." She didn't look up. "Antique restoration. My mother had two rules. Never sand anything, and never trust a finish that looks too even."
He was quiet a moment. "She was in the trade?"
"She bought estates. The ones that didn't make it to auction. She had a nose for what families wanted buried." Viola's swab moved in small circles. "Someone re-varnished this. Poorly. It's still tacky near the edge — damp keeps it that way." She worked the swab along the woman's shoulder, the flat green of her collar.
The face came out of the varnish by degrees. A woman, seated, hands folded in her lap. The painter hadn't been good — too much shadow under the nose, the left eye sitting slightly wrong in the face. And yet the color was right. The skin was right, warm and olive and tired.
"There," Viola murmured. She angled the lamp closer and felt the little cool shiver the way she always did when a piece told her something she hadn't asked. The woman's cheek was swollen. Above it, the eye was a bruised plum smear — deliberate, worked in twice, darkened so you couldn't miss it. She held a child against her shoulder. A small hand gripped her collar.
Viola leaned in so close her breath fogged the varnish.
The underpainting wasn't the same painting.
Under the seated woman, ghosted through the thinning pigment at the shoulder and jaw, was another face. Older. Heavier. A man's face, or a woman's gone slack and sour, scowling out of the same rectangle. Someone had painted over it, laid the young woman down on top like a bedspread. And the young woman's collar — flat, white, wide-pointed — wasn't from any portrait frame Viola had ever restored.
She stepped back. "That collar is 1980s."
Sebastian had stopped sipping. "What?"
"Look at it. Wide-pointed collar. Shoulder pads cut into the line. That's not a period piece. That's a photograph somebody made into a painting, or a portrait from the eighties." She wiped her hands on the rag at her belt. "But the composition — the seated pose, hands in the lap, the child — you know that format."
"Family portrait," he said. "Eighteen-eighties. Every parlor in the Garden District had one. The photographer or the painter would pose the whole household, quarter profile, nobody smiling." He stopped, because his own mouth had gone flat and he'd seen where she was going.
"So why does an 1880s composition have a woman in 1980s clothes holding a child who shouldn't be there?"
He picked the coffee back up and drank it like he was stalling. "Somebody copied a family portrait and updated it. People do that."
"People don't hide a face under the one they painted. Somebody covered that first face up on purpose." She turned the canvas toward the lamp so the light raked it. The bruised eye caught the shine. "And this one's got a black eye. Somebody painted her with a black eye. Who does that?"
"Someone telling the truth," Sebastian said, and then his face closed the way it had at the nursery door, only faster.
Viola set the lamp down. The canvas lay between them, the woman with the child, the man's sour ghost beneath her. Outside, a streetcar clanged down Saint Claude and the sound came in through the cracked parlor window like it belonged to another house entirely.
"Tell me what you know."
"I know what's in the file. Quarterly inventory, four rooms on the record, three off it." He set the cup down. His thumb had started on the edge of his folder again, rubbing the fold until it shone.
"That's not what I asked."
Sebastian looked at the painting, not at her. "The composition's a common one. Household portrait, eighties photography with the old staging. You see it in estate sales. People wanted to look like they'd always been here."
"And the underpainting?"
"Restorers work down through layers. You know that better than I do. Somebody painted wrong, painted over, left it." He picked the cup up again and this time his hand wasn't quite steady. "It's a bad painting. Bad paintings hide bad decisions."
"Why does this house hide its own history?" She said it quietly, the way you speak to a dog you'd rather not spook. "The wall behind the mantel. The deadbolt on the nursery. A silver case in the joists that was still cold. Now this. Your client's will's got a sealed heir clause and a trust with my mother's initials on it, and my lawyer can't find the estate in any parish file."
Sebastian's jaw worked. For a second she thought he'd answer.
"Some history is too expensive to show," he said.
"That's not an answer."
"It's the answer." He set the cup down hard enough that coffee jumped the rim. "Miss Marchand — Viola — I'm bound by the terms of the instrument. I can tell you what the instrument says. I can't tell you what it doesn't. Whatever you find, you find."
"That's a convenient line for a man who keeps finding things first."
He didn't deny it. That was new.
She turned back to the painting. Under the varnish, in the corner beneath the woman's hand, a maker's mark. She'd missed it. Small, rectangular, worked into the paint itself — not a stamp. A signature, scrawled and varnished over.
Viola got the loupe out of her kit. It took a moment for her breathing to settle enough to hold it steady. The initials in the corner, thin and hurried, almost a doodle.
C.M.
She straightened up slowly.
Sebastian had moved to the parlor doorway. He had his back to her now, watching the front hall, watching the chain on the front door as if he expected it to move. The chain, of course, was still chained.
"Mr. Reyes."
"I need to check the back of the house."
"Who else lived in this house besides my mother?"
He stopped in the hall. His reflection hung in the black glass of the tall parlor mirror, thin and distant, and Viola watched the reflection's hand drift to its own collar, tug it once, let it go.
"Good night, Miss Marchand," he said, and the kitchen door clicked shut behind him, and the little chain on the back door rattled gently against its plate, once, twice, and then was still.
Viola stood in the parlor with the lamp burning low and the painted woman looking up at her with one bruised eye. She got out her phone and photographed the signature in the corner, close as the loupe would let her, and then the reflected image in the tall mirror behind her, and then the room itself, everything, so that whatever happened next would have a record.
Then she carried the painting, damp and heavy, up the stairs to her own bedroom, and leaned it against the wall where she could see it from the bed. She would not leave it in the parlor where anyone could come back for it.
She locked her door. It was the first time since she'd arrived that she'd felt any real need to.