The House on Saint Claude

Chapter 61: The Music Box

The recording was still playing when Viola understood she had been wrong about the music box.

She had thought the second message was the whole of it — Camille's voice, thin and fast, telling her about the courthouse and the tapes and the man with the clean suit. But the tape hadn't stopped. It had kept running past the first silence, and there was a second silence after that, and then a third, and Viola sat on the floor of the nursery with the box open in front of her and her hands flat on the floorboards because she needed to feel something solid.

Sebastian had a legal pad on his knee. He'd written three lines and stopped. "Play it again," he said.

"No." Her mother's voice was still in the room. "I heard it the first time."

"Viola —"

"I heard it." She pulled her knees up. "He isn't Jules Fontaine."

Sebastian didn't argue. He'd heard the name too; they both had. It had come out clean and flat, the way people used to say it in a courtroom, the way you said a thing that was going into the record.

*Raymond Prejean.*

Viola had spent three months thinking about the Fontaines. Jules Fontaine dead before her mother ever went to the courthouse. His sons fighting over the estate. The violence that had run in that family like a vein through swamp water. She'd built the whole shape of her mother's last morning out of the wrong man.

"He was a state senator," Sebastian said. He wasn't asking.

Camille had said it on the tape. *Senator Raymond Prejean, of the firm Prejean and Liggett, who is not a lawyer's errand boy but the lawyer himself.* Her voice had gone tight there, the way a person's does when they're reading off a document they've memorized. *He handled the Fontaine estate for eleven years. He knows all forty-one women. He knows what the tapes contain. If I do not come back tonight, they cannot go to the district attorney. His office controls the district attorney. They must go to Baton Rouge.*

The third silence on the tape had been Camille breathing. Viola had listened to her mother breathe for eleven seconds, and then the recording had clicked off.

"Raymond Prejean," Sebastian repeated, slower. He was testing the name for the first time in his mouth and finding it fit the shape of the thing they'd been chasing. "Diane's father."

"Yes."

"Who has been enforcing your mother's will."

"Yes."

Sebastian put the pad down. He looked, for a second, like a man who had just discovered his hands were tied, and he didn't like it. "Prejean's firm represented the Fontaine estate in 1994. If the senator was handling it personally, and the senator was suppressing witnesses —"

"Then the firm has been running this since before I was born."

"Then Diane inherited a cover-up," Sebastian said, quietly. "Not a client. A cover-up."

Viola stood. Her knees popped and she didn't care. She went to the window and looked down at the courtyard, where the fountain was off for the night and the brick was black with wet. She'd stood at that window the first week with her hands on the sill and hated the house for keeping her here. Ninety days. That was what Diane Prejean had given her. Ninety days in a house she didn't want, an inheritance she couldn't touch, a mother she couldn't bury.

"You know what I kept thinking," she said. "For three months. Why the clause. Why can't I just sell it. Why can't I walk out of this house and take the ten million and never come back."

"To keep you here. Prejean wanted the house intact."

"Because the house has the tapes in it." She turned around. "She knew. From the very first day, she knew what was behind those photographs. Her father knew, or she knew from the estate files, or the firm kept a memo — whatever it was. She wrote a ninety-day clause that would force me to live here long enough to find them."

Sebastian looked at the stairs through the open door — the stairwell, the treads, the place where they still believed something was hidden, though they hadn't found it yet, not in any newel or riser. "She also wrote it to keep you alive," he said. "You couldn't be reached if you were on Saint Claude. The house was a container."

"It was a cage with a key inside it," Viola said. "Somebody was going to find it eventually. Her father's dead. She's the only one left who —"

"She thinks she's protecting the family."

"She thinks she's protecting the firm."

Sebastian stood up and picked up the tape. He held it between two fingers, careful, as if it were a wound. "If we send this to the district attorney, we hand it straight back to her. Her father built that office's whole spine. If we send it to Baton Rouge —"

"Then Camille told us exactly what to do in 1994, and we should have done it before we ever called a hearing."

Sebastian looked at his phone. "Hearing's at nine," he said. "I've got forty minutes of statement that names Nathaniel Crane as a witness and asks Judge Whitfield to hold the tapes pending resolution."

"And if the judge is one of Prejean's?"

"She isn't. I checked. She's clean."

"Everyone's clean until they're not."

"Viola." He said it flat, the way he said her name when he needed her to stop. She stopped. "This changes the filing. If we walk into that hearing and say the name Raymond Prejean, we're accusing a dead state senator of murder before we've heard Crane's statement. That'll be the only thing anyone remembers. We lose the tapes."

"So we don't say it."

"We file the tapes directly to the Attorney General in Baton Rouge and we let the hearing be about the ninety-day clause," Sebastian said. "Which is all Diane Prejean has ever wanted it to be about. We give her exactly what she wants until we don't have to."

Viola picked up one of the digitized microcassettes from the table. Forty-one of them. Forty-one women who had walked into a courthouse in 1994 to testify against the Fontaine family, and one state senator who had stood between them and the door. Her mother had kept them all these years and never once — *never once* — let them out of this house.

"She was going to be there the next day," Viola said. "March fifteenth. She wrote it in the journal. *I am going to see her tomorrow no matter what it costs.* She was going to come for me."

"She was."

"And her body's never been found."

"No."

"Which means somewhere between the fourteenth and the fifteenth, Raymond Prejean or someone working for him picked her up." Viola set the tape down. "And Diane Prejean sat in a law office for thirty years and managed the estate of a woman her father killed."

Sebastian didn't correct her. He didn't soften it with *allegedly*, and she was grateful, because sometimes a word like that was just a way of keeping your hands clean.

"What else is on there," he said. "The tape. The part she said came before. *His name would be on the next recording.*"

"There is no next recording."

"There has to be. She named Wolfe on this one. She named Prejean. That means she anticipated a third."

Viola looked at the box. It was open, the little tin drum still turning slow, and she thought about the second recording — how it had only played at 12:04, not on the hour, not on the half hour. A date trigger. Her mother had set a date trigger on a music box and hidden it in a house that would fall to her daughter thirty years later. That wasn't luck. That was engineering.

"She set only two," Viola said slowly. "The first one dropped when the box was touched. It's motion, or it's proximity — something physical. The second one only played on March fourteenth. She designed both, and she left the box on the shelf in my mother's old room, where I would find it. She didn't leave it for anyone. She left it for me."

"For you, thirty years later," Sebastian said. "Which means she expected the house to hold for thirty years."

"Which means she expected someone to keep the house." Viola looked up. "Prejean's firm kept the house. Prejean's firm preserved it. Every year, the estate paid for the shell, the plumbing, the roof, the locks — Diane told me she was protecting the asset. She was protecting the asset. She was keeping this house exactly as Camille left it, because her father told her to, because there's something in here that Raymond Prejean could not find and could not destroy in 1994 and could not let disappear."

"Something he was still looking for in 2001. When he died."

"Something he never found."

The music box clicked. Once. A dry, mechanical click, like a lock settling, and then again, softer, as if whatever spring had wound down had wound down for good.

Neither of them moved.

"It's not the tapes," Viola said. "The tapes were in the nursery. He could have burned the house around them. What he couldn't destroy was —"

She stopped.

She was looking at the stairs. At the treads, and the risers, and the newel at the bottom where the bannister began, the one she'd run her hands over a hundred times in three months and read nothing but a hundred years of hands. The house had shifted an hour ago, and she'd said it was the pipes. It wasn't the pipes. She'd oiled those stairs herself in her second week here and she knew how they moved and she knew how they didn't.

"He came looking for it," she said, very quietly. "Whatever it is. In 1994. He came looking and he didn't find it, so he left the firm here to keep watch. And Diane thought she was keeping a house."

Sebastian followed her eyes to the stairs. "What's the plan," he said.

"Baton Rouge in the morning. You take the digitized files and the letter from my mother, and you go to the Attorney General's office and you don't come back until they've opened a case number." She walked past him. "I'll go to the hearing. I'll stand there and let Diane Prejean think she's won."

"And tonight?"

Viola knelt at the bottom stair and put both palms flat on the tread.

"Tonight," she said, "I'm going to find out what else my mother set to spring."

Her hands caught it before her eyes did — the smallest tremor in the wood, a seam that had opened maybe a millimeter in thirty years, and behind it, a cavity where no carpenter had ever put one.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 61: The Music Box · The House on Saint Claude · Lumen Reads