The courtroom was small, paneled in dark wood gone shiny with a century of hands. Viola sat alone at the petitioner's table, her grandmother's pearls at her throat, the evidence box on the floor by her chair like a dog that had been ordered to stay.
Diane Prejean entered at nine-forty and took the respondent's table without looking at her. She wore gray, no jewelry, and she arranged her folders with the unhurried precision of someone who had already read the ending.
The judge came in at nine-fifty-two. *Baker*, the docket said. Silver hair, reading glasses on a chain, and a face that had adjudicated worse things than this and would again.
"We're here on the petitioner's motion to compel release of recorded materials from the decedent's residence," Baker said. "Ms. Prejean, you've filed objections."
"I have, Your Honor." Diane stood. "The forty-one microcassettes Ms. Marchand seeks to remove from the Saint Claude property are estate property. They were, by the decedent's own documented act, removed from the office of Senator Raymond Prejean in March of 1994." She slid a copy of the receipt toward the bench. "That is theft. My client's family has a superior claim. And Ms. Marchand, who is neither executor nor heir of record, is a trespasser with a key."
"A trespasser," Baker repeated. "In her mother's house."
"Occupancy does not confer title, Your Honor."
Viola's hands were flat on the table. She could feel the grain of it under her palms, old oak, sanded and refinished sometime in the sixties, and underneath that the first cut. She thought about how many things she had read with these hands. She thought: *not now. You can't read this room.*
"Ms. Marchand," Baker said. "You're representing yourself."
"I am." She stood. Her voice came out steadier than she expected. "The tapes aren't property. They're testimony. Forty-one women sat down with my mother between 1992 and 1994 and described what was done to them, and what the state did when they asked for help, which was nothing, and what happened to them when they kept asking, which was worse. They were recorded so they could be given to someone with the power to act. Not to be sold, not to be inherited, not to be sealed in a box in my mother's stairwell for thirty years."
"Sit down, Ms. Marchand," Baker said, not unkindly. "Do you have a custodian? A witness who can establish where these tapes have been?"
"Not yet, Your Honor."
"Then I have a problem." He took off his glasses. "What I have in front of me is a documented removal from a private office. I have a chain-of-custody gap of three decades. And I have a petitioner asking me to hand over potentially defamatory recordings of named individuals, several of whom may be living, several of whom —" he glanced at the file "— are represented by the same firm appearing before me today."
"That's the point," Viola said.
"That's the conflict," Baker said. "Which is why the tapes will be sealed. Clerk's custody, no copies released, pending an evidentiary review. We'll reconvene in sixty days." He looked at Diane. "That addresses your objection."
Diane inclined her head. "Thank you, Your Honor."
Viola sat down. The room tilted a degree, the way a room does when you have lost.
Then the door at the back opened.
Sebastian had driven ninety miles overnight and it showed — rumpled jacket, a two-hour-old coffee ring on his cuff, a manila envelope in his hand. But he walked to the petitioner's table like he had been in the room the whole time.
"Your Honor," he said. "Sebastian Cole. I'm counsel of record to the estate and I have evidence relevant to the custody question."
Baker looked at the clock, then at Diane. "Ms. Prejean?"
"No objection," Diane said. She was very still.
Sebastian opened the envelope. "This letter is in Camille Marchand's hand, dated March 12, 1994, and sealed by her before her disappearance. It states that the recordings in question were to be delivered to the Louisiana Attorney General's office, in Baton Rouge, not to the district attorney, not to any local authority, and specifically not to any attorney or firm with ties to the Fontaine estate." He laid it flat. "It names the reason."
"Approach," Baker said.
Diane did not move. She was reading the letter from four feet away, and Viola watched something go out of her face — not fear exactly. Recalculation.
"There's more," Sebastian said. He took the music box from his coat, wrapped in a cloth, and set it on the table. "This belonged to the decedent. On two date-triggered occasions this year, it played recordings she made. The second recording, twelve days ago, is her voice stating that she was intercepted by Senator Raymond Prejean on her way to deliver these materials, and that the materials were intended for the Attorney General of Louisiana."
Baker leaned forward. "Is that recording authenticated?"
"Not yet. But the box itself, and the decedent's voice, can be examined."
"Where did the box come from?"
"From inside the house," Sebastian said. "Which is the house Ms. Marchand is entitled to occupy for ninety days under the will. And which she has, in fact, been occupying while the tapes sat in it, unsealed, in her custodial possession, for six weeks."
Baker was quiet for a moment. Then he took off his glasses again and folded them.
"Let me tell you what I'm going to do," he said. "I'm not going to decide whose tapes these are today. But I am not going to have this court sit on recorded statements about the conduct of state officials in 1994 while a claim of theft is used to bury them." He wrote three quick lines. "The tapes are delivered to the Louisiana Attorney General's office, Baton Rouge, by the clerk, within seven days. No copies retained. The Attorney General's office is directed to review and, if appropriate, investigate. The occupancy clause in the will is extended pending that review — Ms. Marchand stays in the property."
Diane's voice was even. "Your Honor, the estate—"
"Has a conflict of interest this court will not resolve by sealing evidence, Ms. Prejean."
The gavel came down once, flat and final, and the clerk called the next matter, and it was over.
Sebastian sat beside her, breathing hard like he'd run the last block.
"You made it," Viola said.
"I made it."
She looked at the box on the floor. Four days, maybe five, and it would be in Baton Rouge, in the hands of someone with subpoena power and no reason to be afraid. She looked at Diane, gathering her folders with slow careful hands, and understood that the woman was not gathering papers. She was gathering the shape of a different next week.
"We won the tapes," Viola said quietly.
"We won the tapes," Sebastian said. "We didn't win the house."
"Not yet."
Outside, the light was the flat gray of a New Orleans February, and it was starting to rain.