The House on Saint Claude

Chapter 8: The Undertow

The gate latch clicked behind her, and Viola heard Sebastian's footsteps stop at the bottom of the walk. When she turned, he was standing with his hands in his pockets, looking at Odette's door as if he could will it back open.

"That was unnecessary," she said.

"Let's go inside."

"She was about to tell me what the book was."

"She was about to tell you a story she's been telling for forty years." He started up the walk, and she didn't follow, so he stopped again, half-turned, jaw working. "Viola. Inside."

She went inside because the alternative was standing on the sidewalk losing an argument to his back, which was the sort of thing she'd done at twenty-two and sworn off. But she didn't go quietly. She got the door shut behind them, and in the dim of the front hall, with the dust and the smell of old plaster coming down off the walls, she said, "You put your hand on her gate."

"I did."

"You reached over an eighty-year-old woman's fence to keep her from talking to me."

"I reached over a fence to stop a stranger from filling your head with neighborhood folklore about a house that is currently the subject of a civil instrument I'm bound by law to administer." He said *law* the way other people said *God*, as if it settled things. "She doesn't know anything. She knows what she's heard through a window for half a century."

"She knew the word for it. *Way station.* Nobody makes that up."

Sebastian took his coat off. He did it slowly, deliberately, folding it over his forearm, and Viola understood that this was what he did instead of answering. She'd seen him do it with the cigarette case. She'd seen him do it with the deadbolt. He was building the pause, brick by brick, and she was tired of standing outside it.

"Look at me," she said.

He looked at her.

"When I asked you about the third floor, you said you were checking the deadbolt. When I found the case, you said you'd never seen it. Now you're standing in a hallway telling me a woman who's lived on this block since before I was born doesn't know what she's talking about." She took a step toward him, and he didn't move back, which she noted. "You keep telling me the truth is protected. Protected by what? From who? *Who are you protecting?*"

He was quiet a moment. Then he said, in a different voice—flatter, more careful, the voice of a man reading off a document—"The estate carries a confidentiality obligation to a living beneficiary."

"An obligation."

"Yes."

"To *whom.*"

"To a beneficiary. Living. That's the term of the instrument." He hung his coat on the newel post, which wasn't where coats went, and left his hand on it. "I'm not at liberty to say who."

The hall was very still. Somewhere behind the wall a pipe ticked as it cooled.

"Is the beneficiary my mother," Viola said.

He didn't answer. He didn't look away, either. His hand stayed on the coat, and the coat was gray, and his knuckles had gone the same color, and she watched him not answer for what felt like a full minute, and the not-answering was the loudest thing that had happened in that house since the lullaby.

"That's not an answer," she said.

"It's the answer I can give."

"Then it's the wrong one." Her voice cracked on the last word and she hated it, hated that he heard it, hated that he was still standing there like a man at a lectern while she came apart at the seams of a hallway she'd been avoiding for twenty-eight years. "You've been in this house a week and every single thing you do is a wall. You cut off Odette. You lied about the lock. You took something out of that wall and put it in your pocket and went to your room and you did *not* go back to sleep, I saw your light. You weren't checking anything. You were checking *me.*"

"I was watching the drive," he said. "That part's true."

"That part," she repeated.

"That part."

"So it *was* you in the east wing that night."

"I didn't say that."

"You didn't have to—" She stopped herself, breathed, and the breath came out wrong, too fast. Down the hall, past the parlor door, the east wall was a black mouth in the dark. She had not looked at it once since she came inside. She realized that now. She'd walked the whole first floor with her eyes trained to the left.

Sebastian followed her gaze. "Don't," he said.

"Don't what."

"Don't go in there tonight."

"I'm not afraid of a parlor."

"You should be," he said, and then he looked like he wished he hadn't, and that was the first true thing he'd given her all day, and it landed like a dropped plate.

The argument went on after that, but it went on in circles, because he would not name the beneficiary and she would not stop asking, and every lap around it took them further from the door and closer to the stairs, until they were both standing at the foot of them, voices rising, and she said, "Then say it. Say she's dead. Say the estate's closed and you're just here to sell me out from under the only thing I have left of her, and I'll pack tonight and I swear to God I'll never ask you another question."

"I can't say that."

"*Can't* or *won't*?"

"Viola—"

"Can't or won't, Sebastian."

He picked up his coat.

She thought, for one bright furious second, that he was going to put it on and leave, walk out into the heat and be gone, and she'd be alone in the house with the wall and the lullaby and whatever came up through the floorboards at 2:14 in the morning, and she found that she wanted that, she wanted him gone, she wanted the silence to be hers again. But he didn't go out the front. He went out the kitchen door, and through the window she watched him cross the drive and open the back of a black sedan parked under the live oak, and lay his coat flat across the driver's seat, and get in.

He slept in the car.

She stood at the window a long time, watching the shape of him behind the glass, one arm folded, the dome light long dead. The mansion creaked behind her, all its old bones settling. She thought about calling the lawyer in the morning, whoever he reported to, thought about the letter in her kit upstairs, thought about Odette's closed door and the plural *they* and a book she'd never heard of until an old woman said it out loud on a sidewalk.

She went to bed at midnight. She did not sleep.

At dawn he was still there, dusty gray shadow behind the windshield, and when she finally pulled the kitchen door open and stood on the step with her arms crossed, he rolled the window down. His eyes were raw. He hadn't shaved. He looked, for the first time since she'd met him, less like an instrument and more like a man who hadn't found a way out of the driveway all night.

"The east parlor," he said, before she could say anything. His voice was scratchy with the cold of the car. "I couldn't go in there. All right? I sat in that hallway last night and I put my hand on the door and I couldn't. So I slept in the car." He looked up at her through the frame of the window. "Ask me anything else in the world. Not that."

She stood there with the morning coming up pink over the roofs, and the house breathing slow behind her, and for the first time she thought: *whatever the wall is holding, he's afraid of it too.*

"Fine," she said. "Then you can help me haul the worktable out to the old kitchen house."

"Why."

"Because I'm setting up a studio." She went back inside, and left him to follow or not. "And because you're going to stand there and watch me put that portrait under the light, and you're not going to say one word about what you see."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 8: The Undertow · The House on Saint Claude · Lumen Reads