The Ideal User

Chapter 48: The Gag Order

The courier came at 4:52 p.m., which Harper would later remember because it was the exact minute Devi had predicted the gag order would land.

"Signature here," the man said, shoving a tablet at her. He wore a windbreaker with a process-serving company's logo she'd never heard of. The envelope was thick, legal-sized, and already curled at the corner from its ride through downtown traffic.

Harper signed. He left without a word.

She carried the envelope up to the fourth floor without opening it. Devi was at the whiteboard, marker in hand, rewriting the notification list columns. Sofia sat cross-legged on the floor with her laptop balanced on one knee. They both stopped when Harper walked in.

"That's it?" Sofia asked.

"That's it." Harper set the envelope on the table and slit it with a letter opener. She read the first page standing up, which was a mistake, because by the third paragraph she had to sit down.

*Temporary Restraining Order and Order to Show Cause.* Filed in King County Superior Court, on behalf of Coastal Cloud, Inc., which was the forum's registered corporate entity, which meant the forum had stopped pretending to be a forum. The order barred LumenLoop—and Harper Lin, individually—from "publishing, disseminating, or otherwise disclosing to any third party" the contents of the archived member records, including "any identifying information, user handles, posting histories, or membership rosters." It also barred "contact with any current or former member of the Coastal Cloud platform" pending a hearing.

Harper read that last clause twice.

"They can't do that," Devi said, reading over her shoulder. "That's—that's the whole thing. That's the entire case."

"They can ask for it," Harper said. "Whether they get it is a different question." She was already dialing June Park.

June picked up on the second ring. Harper read her the order in full, slowly, so June could write it down. When she got to the contact prohibition, June said nothing for four seconds, which from June was practically a shout.

"Where are you?" June asked.

"Office."

"Stay there. I'm filing an emergency ex parte in the morning. First appearance is tomorrow at one, Judge Okafor. She does not like overbroad injunctions. She's ruled against Coastal Cloud's outside counsel twice this year—they're at Calloway Brant, and she has a history with them." A keyboard clattered. "The notification clause is the weak point. They wrote it too broad. You can't enjoin a party from talking to witnesses in her own defense. That's a prior restraint problem and they know it. They're hoping you don't push back fast enough."

"They served it at five o'clock on a Tuesday," Harper said. "They're hoping I don't push back at all."

"Correct. I'll have a motion by eight. Don't call anyone tonight. Don't email anyone. Do not—” June paused, and Harper heard her pick up her coffee cup and set it down. “—do not send a single message to any of the 214 members until I tell you the clause is stayed. Understood?"

"Understood."

Harper hung up. The office was very quiet.

She went home at six and did not call anyone for four hours. She sat on her couch with her phone face-down on the coffee table and watched the rain come sideways off Elliott Bay, and at nine-forty, she picked the phone up and put it down eleven times without unlocking it.

At eleven-fifteen, June called back.

"Partial stay," June said, and Harper could hear the exhaustion in it, the good kind. "Judge Okafor heard the ex parte by phone. The disclosure prohibition stands—you cannot publish the roster. But the contact prohibition is stayed pending the Friday hearing. You may notify members directly, one-on-one, that they have been affected and that they may have legal rights. You may not characterize the forum, you may not name Coastal Cloud as the source, you may not quote any post content. You may tell them to get their own counsel. That's it."

"That's enough," Harper said.

"It's not enough for the public statement. That stays blocked. But it's enough for notification." A pause. "Harper. It's five of midnight. You don't have to do this tonight."

"Yes I do," Harper said. "Their lawyers served at five o'clock on a Tuesday to buy themselves a news cycle. Every hour I sit on this, someone on that list finds out from a journalist instead of from me."

June was quiet. "Call me if anyone threatens you."

Harper pulled up the redacted list on her laptop. 214 names, of which Devi's decryption had yielded verified contact information for 61. Devi had sorted them by exposure risk: the three who had quit the industry entirely at the top, then the ones whose employers had active non-disparagement clauses, then everyone else.

Harper started with the top of the list and worked down. She made a script. She read it to herself twice, changed one word, and then she began.

The first call went to voicemail. So did the second. The third, a woman answered at 12:20 a.m., sounding wide awake and frightened before Harper had said more than her name, because nobody calls at 12:20 a.m. with good news. Harper read the script. The woman listened. Then she said, "I knew. I always knew something was wrong. Nobody believed me," and hung up crying, and Harper sat in the dark kitchen and breathed until her hands stopped shaking, and then called the next one.

Some of them yelled at her. One man—a staff engineer at a Bellevue company, handle @mossbank, twenty-nine posts over four years—asked her twice whether she was a reporter, and when she said no, asked whether this was a shakedown, and when she said no to that too, asked whether she was a lawyer, and she said no, and he said, "Then who are you?" and she said, "I'm someone from the list." He was silent a long time. Then he said, "Okay. Okay, I believe you. What do I do now."

"I don't know yet," Harper said. "Get a lawyer. Keep everything. Don't delete anything, no matter how much you want to."

"Believe me," he said, "I want to."

By 3 a.m. she had made twenty-two calls. Fourteen answers, eight voicemails, eleven people who said they wanted to be involved in some way, and one hang-up. Devi had texted twice: once with a timeline of the court filings, once with a short message reading *you should sleep*. Harper ignored both.

The fifty-ninth name on the list was Talia Osei-Fraser.

Harper knew the name before she found it, because Talia Osei-Fraser had been a founder—not a famous one, but a real one, a logistics platform for independent grocers, and Harper had watched her company's quiet shutdown eighteen months ago and assumed, like everyone, that it had been the market.

She called at 3:41 a.m. and Talia answered on the first ring, which meant Talia had been awake, which meant—Harper would learn—Talia had been awake at 3:41 a.m. for two years.

"Yes," Talia said, before Harper finished the script. "I know who you are. I've been reading about the petition. I've been waiting for this call."

"You're on the list. Your account was one of the ones sold."

"I know," Talia said. "I've known since March."

Harper stood up from the kitchen table and walked to the window. "You knew?"

"The company that bought my client roster didn't hide it well. Six of my accounts, gone inside a month, all of them to the same competitor, all of them with pitch decks that quoted things I'd only ever written in the forum. Things I'd written in what I thought was a private space, to people I thought were—” She stopped. "You know what I wrote there?"

"Only that it was in the sold set. Devi redacted the content before I saw it."

"Good," Talia said. "Keep it redacted. But I'll tell you what it was. I wrote a post in February, two years ago, on the day I found out my mother had cancer. I wrote it to get support. It was a thread about how to run a company when you're falling apart. And there was a woman in that thread, a stranger, who wrote back for three weeks, every single night, no matter what time I posted. She kept me alive that month. I never met her. I never will. And then her words—my words, in that thread—ended up in a pitch deck that took my business."

Harper didn't say anything.

"That's the part I can't get over," Talia said. "Not the money. The money was never going to be enough anyway. It's that the one good thing about that place got harvested along with everything else. They sold the thread where I was honest with a stranger."

"I'm sorry," Harper said.

"You keep saying that."

"Because I don't have anything better."

Talia laughed, once, dry. "No. Nobody does." A pause, water running, a glass set down. "What do you need from me."

"A declaration," Harper said. "And—there's a lawyer, June Park. She's assembling the filing. The petitioner is Sofia Reyes, who's public already. The two supporting declarants are Priya Nandakumar, whose credentials were used to sell a loop, and I need a third." She hesitated. "Priya's declaration won't name the buyer. The whole filing leaves the beneficiary unidentified. I've agreed to that."

"Because June can't prove it."

"Because I can't prove it yet."

"Then put me in," Talia said. "I don't need it to be provable. I need it to be said. Six clients. Six. I've got the emails. I've got the dates. I can put their pitch decks next to my posts and it's word for word. If June wants a pattern, I'm the pattern."

Harper sat back down. Her hand was shaking and she put it flat on the table.

"I have to tell you what you're signing up for," she said. "They'll depose you. They'll pull your company's records. Your forum handle becomes public. Every post you ever wrote—"

"Harper," Talia said. "I closed my company on a Tuesday and I have not felt like a founder since. I've been a name on somebody's spreadsheet for nine months. Let me be something on purpose."

The rain had stopped. Harper could see the streetlights on the wet asphalt, doubled, and somewhere below a car went by.

"Can I ask you something," Harper said.

"Yes."

"You said a woman wrote back to you every night. Do you remember her handle?"

"@larkspur_11," Talia said. "I think about her all the time."

Harper closed her eyes.

"I'll email you June's contact in the morning," she said, when she could. "Send the emails to June, not to me. And Talia—thank you. I know what it costs."

"Send me the paper," Talia said, and hung up.

Harper sat at the kitchen table for a while. Then she opened the shared document, found the line that had been sitting there for four days, and typed in the field under *Disproved by*:

*Nothing yet. Ask Talia.*

She looked at it. It wasn't an answer. It was a direction.

She saved the file, closed the laptop, and went to bed.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 48: The Gag Order · The Ideal User · Lumen Reads