The Ideal User

Chapter 59: The Witness List

The federal courthouse on Fifth Avenue had a smell Harper had learned to associate with consequences: wet wool, floor wax, and coffee that had been on a hot plate since dawn. She'd arrived at seven-forty, twenty minutes early, because June had told her that early was the only kind of on time that mattered in front of Judge Whitlock.

Noah was already there.

He sat on the bench outside Courtroom 9C, in a charcoal suit she'd never seen, a manila folder flat on his knees. He looked up when she came down the corridor. She kept walking. She sat two benches down, opened her own folder, and read the same three pages she'd read four times the night before.

"You're listed friendly," June murmured, sliding in beside her with a paper cup of tea. "It won't stay friendly."

"What does that mean."

"It means Wen's counsel gets to ask you whatever they want, and the plaintiffs get to ask you whatever they need, and somewhere in the middle you'll say something one of them will use." June blew on the tea. "The archive is in. Judge Whitlock is not in a mood to hear motions to quash anything. So we go."

"You don't have to sit through this," Harper said, without looking toward the bench.

"I'm your lawyer. I sit through everything."

That wasn't what Harper had meant. June knew it and let it pass.

The gallery was half full, mostly plaintiffs and their attorneys and two reporters Harper recognized from the press conference. The clerk called the docket. Wen's counsel, a woman named Stroud with a bob that did not move, stood and renewed her objection to the certification on the same grounds as before, and Judge Whitlock denied it in forty seconds, flat, the way you'd close a door.

Then it was the plaintiffs' turn.

June called her at nine-forty. Harper stood, straightened her jacket, and walked to the witness box, and the bailiff swore her in, and she sat down and looked out at the room, and Noah was looking at his folder, not at her.

"Ms. Lin," June said. "You founded LumenLoop. Tell the court what happened to your first product."

"We shipped a postmortem analytics platform in 2023. It aggregated user behavior across school districts to model completion risk. Six months in, we discovered a district had used our risk scores to reallocate staffing, which meant certain students lost their reading intervention hours." Harper kept her voice level. "The model was accurate. It was accurate about the wrong thing."

"And the deck."

"The pitch deck I wrote for the second raise described the same capability. I called it a retention lens. It was the same model with a friendlier noun." She had testified to this before, in a deposition, but saying it aloud in a room with other people in it never got easier. "I pulled the raise. I refunded two checks. The story got out. It was covered, badly, and then people moved on."

"What did you build instead."

"The pilot. A walled pipeline where the district owns every record, every decision, and the model's outputs are auditable by anyone in the building." She paused. "We publish the audit schedule and the clause. It's not a privacy policy. It's a contract."

"And this is the loop you brought to the class."

"It's the thing that would have kept a forum member's data from being resold. In our version, the data doesn't travel. The model travels to the data." Harper glanced at the bench, at the plaintiffs' table, then back at June. "It's slower. It costs more. It's the only version I'm willing to sell."

Stroud stood for cross. She did not come at Harper sideways.

"Ms. Lin. Between 2023 and earlier this year, you were a member of a women's professional forum operating under the name Ember."

A beat. "Yes."

"And in that forum you participated under a username."

"Summerfield."

"And in that forum you spoke anonymously with a user called Forge."

"Yes."

"For how long."

"About two years."

"Two years." Stroud let that sit. "And during that time, you believed Forge to be a woman."

"Everyone on the forum did. Forge didn't correct it, and the forum's founding premise was that members were women."

"So you spoke to a stranger under a false premise, on a forum built on the false premise that its data was private." Stroud turned a page she wasn't reading. "Why should this court credit your judgment about data rights when your own confidant turned out to be a person you'd never vetted."

June shifted to object, but Harper answered first, before she could.

"Because I'm not asking the court to credit my judgment. I'm asking it to credit the contract." She looked Stroud in the eye. "I was wrong about Forge's identity. I was right that the forum was selling us. The filings show the sales. The sales are the point."

"No further questions," Stroud said, and sat down.

Harper thought she was done. Then plaintiffs' counsel, a soft-spoken man named Okafor, stood and said, "One redirect, Ms. Lin, and it's short."

"Go ahead."

"You said you spoke with Forge for two years. Was Forge aware of your first product's failure."

"He knew. He knew before the coverage. He noticed I wasn't sleeping and asked."

"Did Forge ever buy or sell your company's data, or use your conversations to gain an investment advantage."

"Not that I know of, and I've read the archive. There's no message where he asked me anything material about LumenLoop."

"When you learned Forge was also Noah Vance, an investor in a fund that was pitching you, did you feel deceived."

Harper looked at Noah. He was looking at her now. He had the folder closed on his knees and his hands folded on top of it, and he looked like a man waiting for a verdict he'd already assigned himself.

"Yes," she said.

"And now, Ms. Lin, one question about the forum itself." Okafor paused. "You and Forge exchanged messages there for two years. Did you trust @Forge."

The room went quiet in a specific way, like a phone being set face down on a table.

"I did," Harper said.

"Was that trust warranted."

She considered lying. She considered it for the length of one breath, and then she didn't.

"That's the wrong question," she said. "The forum sold my trust. That's what it sold to Wen and the buyers. My half of it, and every other member's half. When you're anonymous on a platform, the trust isn't a feeling. It's an asset the platform holds in escrow and can sell without telling you." She kept her voice even. "I trusted Forge. That trust was the product being sold. Not by him. By the forum, using both of us."

"Thank you," Okafor said quietly, and sat down.

Judge Whitlock asked a few more questions, then thanked her and excused the witness, and Harper stepped down and walked back to her seat past Noah's bench. He didn't turn his head. She didn't either. But as she sat, June leaned in and said, under her breath, "Check your phone when we're out."

They cleared the courtroom at noon. In the corridor, June handed Harper a screenshot on her phone.

Noah's fund — Kilbourn Vance, the firm he'd been a partner at for six years — had filed an entry of appearance for the purpose of opposing his testimony, and it had been denied. And beneath that, a filing Harper hadn't expected: a letter from the firm's general counsel to the court, dated yesterday, stating that Mr. Vance had testified without the firm's consent and that the firm intended to formalize a conflict policy regarding the matter.

"They don't want him on the stand because his name is now the thing being litigated," June said. "The certification's done. The plaintiffs can call him whenever they want. And if he does it anyway, Kilbourn Vance is going to have a problem with its own partner."

Harper read the letter twice. It didn't say Noah had been wrong. It said the firm had reserved the right to say he had been.

"They're going to ask him to choose," she said.

"Probably today." June put her phone away and looked down the corridor, where Noah had just stepped out of the men's room with his jacket over his arm. He saw them. He stopped.

Harper didn't walk toward him. She didn't walk away either.

"He testified for you," June said. "Unofficially. Off the books. Under his own name. Whatever you do with that is your business, but you should know it was a decision, not a slip."

"I know," Harper said. She watched Noah across forty feet of linoleum corridor, holding a folder with the letter in it, maybe, or with nothing at all, and she understood something that made the pit in her chest go colder: he wasn't on her side now. He was on the record, and the record would cost him his job.

Her phone buzzed. A number she didn't recognize, at the top of the screen, with a message that was three lines long and unsigned but wasn't from a stranger.

*Stroud filed a document overnight. Covington Ames account's owner. It's not what you think. Check with June before you say anything.*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 59: The Witness List · The Ideal User · Lumen Reads