Read Chapter 6: The Iceberg Inquiry

The chart room smelled of oiled brass and pencil shavings, and the third officer on duty looked up from his dividers with the weary patience of a man who had answered the same question a hundred times. Evelyn had chosen him deliberately—young enough to be flattered by a first-class lady’s interest in navigation, old enough to know his instruments.

“I confess I find the ice reports terribly romantic,” she said, sliding a gloved hand along the edge of his desk. “All those lonely bergs drifting down from the Arctic. One reads so much about them in the papers.”

The officer—his nameplate read MURDOCH—allowed a thin smile. “Romantic isn’t the word I’d use, miss. They’re more like unfriendly neighbors.”

Julian lingered near the door, arms crossed, playing the bored companion. He had insisted on coming, though he contributed little to the performance. His eyes kept drifting to the wireless alcove beyond the glass partition, where a junior operator hunched over his receiver.

“I understand you’ve received several warnings,” Evelyn pressed, leaning in with conspiratorial warmth. “My father was a commodore, you see. He always said the Atlantic in April was a treacherous old goat.”

Murdoch’s fingers paused on the dividers. Something flickered behind his eyes—not suspicion, but the tired recognition of a truth he was not paid to examine. “We’ve had a handful of messages, yes. The *Mesaba* reported a field of pack ice. The *Caronia* sighted bergs off the Grand Banks.”

“And yet we maintain our speed.” Evelyn made it a statement, not a question.

“Captain’s orders, miss. The *Olympic*’s been through worse. They say she’s a sturdy girl, this ship.”

“They say” is doing a great deal of work in that sentence, Evelyn thought. She smiled anyway. “Might I see the latest telegram? Just to satisfy my morbid curiosity.”

Murdoch hesitated. The chart room was not a public gallery, and the regulations were clear enough. But Evelyn had chosen him because he was young and because her father truly had been a commodore—a fact that seemed to carry weight in his weary calculation. He pulled a slip from the stack beside him and held it out.

The telegram was short, the language clipped and functional. *Mesaba to Titanic, April 14. Icebergs, growlers, and field ice. Latitude 42° N, longitude 49° W.*

Evelyn’s stomach turned cold. She had seen coordinates before—had traced them on her father’s maps as a girl, learning the shapes of oceans and the routes of great liners. She did not need a compass to understand what she was reading.

“That’s directly ahead,” she said quietly.

Murdoch glanced at the slip, then back at her. “It is.”

“And we haven’t changed course.”

“The captain has determined it isn’t necessary. The bergs are well south of our track.” He said it with the flat certainty of a man repeating doctrine, not conviction.

Evelyn handed the telegram back carefully, as though it might burn her gloves. “I see. Thank you, Mr. Murdoch. You’ve been most instructive.”

She turned toward the door, but Julian had already stepped forward, his easy posture suddenly charged. “You mentioned a *Mesaba* sighting. Were there other messages? Earlier ones, perhaps, from different ships?”

Murdoch’s brow furrowed. “Several. The *Amerika*, the *Californian*.” He gestured vaguely toward the wireless room. “They come in all afternoon. It’s not unusual.”

“Of course.” Julian’s voice was smooth, but Evelyn caught the tension in his jaw. “One last thing—are any of the warnings shared with the passengers?”

“Only if they ask.” Murdoch returned to his dividers, already dismissing them. “And most don’t.”

---

Out on the boat deck, the wind had picked up. The sea stretched endlessly, gray-green and slicked with a cold sheen that seemed to swallow light. Evelyn gripped the rail and stared at the horizon, where the water and sky blurred into a single unbroken line.

“They know,” she said. “They know exactly where it is, and they’re sailing straight into it.”

Julian stood beside her, silent for a long moment. When he spoke, his voice was low, almost reverent. “Every loop, I assumed the ship was a victim of fate. That the iceberg was an accident, a blind spot in the night watch. But it’s not an accident, Evelyn. It’s a decision.”

“The captain’s decision.”

“The company’s decision. Smith’s decision. A hundred small decisions made by men who believed the ship was unsinkable and the ice was a nuisance.” He turned to face her, and she saw something raw beneath the surface of his calm—something she had only glimpsed in the smoking room, when the specter of what he was losing had threatened to crack him open. “We can’t save Margaret if the ship goes down before midnight. No lifeboat drill, no slip of paper, no last-minute confession will matter.”

Evelyn pulled her coat tighter. The cold was beginning to seep through the wool, and she hated the way it reminded her of death—of the water closing over her head, the darkness and the screaming. She had died three times. She did not wish to die a fourth.

“So we alter history,” she said slowly, testing the weight of the words. “We convince the captain to slow down. To turn.”

“Do you know how many men it would take to do that? The captain of the *Titanic* doesn’t take counsel from a second-class passenger and a debutante who claims to fear icebergs.” Julian’s laugh was bitter. “We’d have better luck steering the berg ourselves.”

“Then what do we do?”

He didn’t answer. Below them, a team of stokers emerged from a hatch and crossed the deck toward the crew quarters, their faces gray with coal dust. Julian watched them go, and Evelyn saw the calculation behind his eyes—the same look he’d worn in the purser’s office when he’d palmed that blank passenger list.

“We need proof,” he said at last. “Not a warning—we have those. We need something so undeniable that even Captain Smith can’t ignore it. A defect. A fault in the ship itself. Something that makes continuing at full speed an act of criminal negligence.”

“And then?”

“And then we force a change.” He turned to face her fully, and for a moment he looked older than the years he wore—older and more tired, as if a hundred dawns had leached the color from him. “But I don’t know if that’s the point.”

“Of the loop?”

“Of any of this.” He spread his hands, encompassing the ship, the sea, the entire impossible predicament. “I’ve tried warning them before. In my early loops, I ran to the bridge screaming about icebergs. I was locked in the brig and died in the bowels of the ship. I tried writing anonymous notes to the captain—they were dismissed as a prank. I even tried starting a fire in the boiler room, hoping we’d stop for repairs.” A muscle twitched in his jaw. “It worked. We stopped. But the ship sank anyway, on the reef we fetched up against, and I drowned in the engine room while Margaret watched from a lifeboat that never launched.”

Evelyn felt the cold settle deeper. “So we can’t change the ending.”

“I don’t know if we can.” His voice was barely audible above the wind. “Maybe the loop is not about stopping the ship from sinking. Maybe it’s about making sure Margaret leaves it before she does.”

“Then we find her,” Evelyn said firmly. “We find her and we get her into a lifeboat with a first-class ticket and a story so plausible that no one questions it.”

“And if that’s not enough?”

“Then we try again.” She reached out and took his hand, her fingers cold against his. “We have tomorrow. We have the next tomorrow, and the one after that. We have as many tomorrows as it takes, Julian.”

He looked down at their joined hands, and for a moment the tension in his shoulders eased. “You sound like you mean that.”

“I do.” She squeezed his fingers. “Now come. Margaret O’Leary isn’t going to save herself.”