The diner was called the Blue Dot and it sat on the far side of Route 9, past the last campus shuttle stop, in a strip mall that also held a nail salon and a vape shop. Rachel got there first and took the corner booth, back to the wall, the coat draped over the seat beside her. Priya's coat. It still smelled faintly of cardamom.
Tessa came in shaking rain off a canvas jacket that wasn't hers either, and slid in across from Rachel without saying hello. Then Priya, hood up, glancing once at the door like she expected someone to follow her through it.
They ordered coffee because you had to. The waitress left three cups and a laminated menu.
"Okay," Tessa said. "What is this."
Rachel had rehearsed it on the walk over and it still came out badly. She started with Nadia's keys. Then the mailbox label, the conference that had never heard of her. She pulled the logging sheets out of the coat — folded twice, soft at the creases — and laid them on the table, her handwriting neat in the grid she'd built: trial number, book, page, what she'd asked the page to confirm, what had changed in the world afterward.
Tessa read them with her finger moving down the columns. She got to the fourth row and stopped moving.
"These are dates," she said. "Nadia lost her keys on a Tuesday. You ran a trial on Monday."
"Yes."
"You did this to her."
"I didn't know they were connected. I didn't know any of it was—"
"You didn't *know*." Tessa sat back. Her voice stayed low, which was worse than if she'd shouted. "You ran seven experiments on books you stole out of a closed collection and it never once occurred to you to wonder what they were doing to the world."
Rachel didn't answer that, because the honest answer was that it had occurred to her on the third one, and she'd kept going.
Priya hadn't touched her coffee. She was staring at the sheets, at one row in particular. "What's this one."
"Which."
"Number five. You wrote 'confirm applicant status.'"
"I wanted to test whether the catalog could resolve a contested fact. Whether the book predicts, or decides."
Priya's jaw worked. "My sister applied to the nursing program in September. She got a rejection letter in October and I never — she was qualified. Everyone said she was qualified." She looked up. "When did you run number five."
Rachel found the date. It was October.
Nobody said anything for a while. The rain picked up against the window. The waitress came back and they all said no thank you in unison.
"Okay," Tessa said finally. "Here's where I am. We have Cass Whitfield's study, which proves the library was erasing people in 2014. We have your sheets, which prove it's still happening and that we're part of the mechanism. We have a dean who wants you to write him a memo blessing the whole thing, and we have a file number that doesn't exist anywhere. And we have a red pen that signs itself W.P."
"Right."
"So the question isn't whether the books are real. It's what we do next, and I want that decided by vote, out loud, so nobody can pretend later they didn't say it." Tessa turned her cup a quarter turn. "I vote we stop. All of us, now, permanently. No more trials. No more requests. We take what we have to someone outside — the state archivist, a reporter, an accreditor who isn't Herrick's friend — and we accept that it might all get buried. We accept we might lose."
"That's a clean answer," Rachel said.
"It's the only one I've got."
Priya was quiet for long enough that Tessa looked at her.
"I don't know," Priya said.
"Priya."
"I said I don't know." She pulled her hood down. Her hair was flat on one side. "If we burn it now we're just people with photocopies of a dead woman's notes and a bunch of numbers in Rachel's handwriting. That's nothing. That's a complaint. And my sister's rejection letter is real either way, so tell me what stopping buys her."
"It buys the next person," Tessa said. "It stops the bleeding."
"It stops us finding out how far it goes." Priya looked at Rachel. "The eleven cases. Cass named them. If we walk away we never learn who they were."
Rachel had been waiting for this, and she hated that she was ready for it. "There's a third option." Both of them looked at her. "We don't use the books. We take them apart on paper. Copy the whole predictive catalog out of the building, page by page, outside the library's control. Everything Cass documented, everything the restricted collection holds. Then nobody has to choose between stopping and proving it, because we'll have the whole apparatus in a form that can't be edited under us."
Tessa squinted. "You want to copy restricted materials out of a research library."
"I want to photograph them."
"With what."
"Priya has a camera."
They both looked at Priya, who blinked. "I have a camera."
"You do documentary work," Rachel said. "You shoot on film and you develop it yourself, which means nothing goes through a server. No cloud, no metadata, no digitization request, no one who can tell us what we're allowed to see."
Priya was already nodding slowly. "If it's on film, it's physical. They'd have to come into my darkroom to touch it."
"That's the vote," Tessa said. "That's the actual vote. Not stop or continue. Continue with photographs."
"Yes," Rachel said.
"I asked for a vote and you're supposed to say—" Tessa stopped. "Fine. I vote no. I vote no on the books and no on the photographs, because I think we're three people who are already losing things and I don't want to find out what's next. If you two do this, I want it in writing that I said no."
Priya looked at her for a second. "I'll write it down."
"That's not — fine. Okay." Tessa dragged a hand through her hair. "Fine. Priya."
"I vote yes with conditions." Priya counted on her fingers. "One: we never ask the books anything. We only look at them. Two: nothing goes back into the library's systems, ever. Three: the moment one of us starts losing something, we stop."
"Agreed," Rachel said.
"Rachel." Tessa's voice went flat. "You don't get to agree. You haven't voted."
Rachel had known this was coming and had known, too, that whatever she said would be a lie of some kind. She thought about the coffee shop she couldn't walk into anymore. She thought about the barista, whose name she could only write. She thought about Herrick's twelve days, ticking.
"I abstain," she said.
Tessa laughed once, no humor in it. "Of course you do."
"Because I'm compromised and I know it. Nadia's losing pieces because of me. If I vote yes I'm voting to keep going and I'll be the reason something else goes missing. If I vote no I'm asking you to burn the only evidence that could get her back." Rachel flattened the logging sheets. "Abstaining means you two decide, and I do what you tell me. That's the most honest thing I've got."
"That's the most lawyerly thing you've got."
"Yeah, well."
The waitress came with the check. Nobody moved to take it, so Priya did, and paid in cash, and put the bills in the little black folder like a woman with a plan.
"So we start tonight," she said. "Not the reading room. Too many eyes and I'd have to sign in with my real card. There's a study carrel on the fourth floor, west range, that opens onto the restricted stacks through a connecting door the catalog doesn't list as an access point."
"How do you know that."
"I dated a preservation tech for two years." Priya stood and pulled her hood back up. "I'll bring the camera tomorrow. The Rolleiflex, not the digital. High contrast film, fine grain. If the pages photograph at all, we'll have the whole collection in a week."
Tessa didn't stand. "I want it on the record that I said no."
"You'll get it in writing," Priya said. "I'll text you a photograph of the note."
"Don't get cute."
They left Tessa in the booth and walked out into the rain, which had settled into a steady gray drizzle. Priya stopped under the awning and dug in her bag.
"Here," she said. "Before we go anywhere. I want to know it works."
She pulled out the Rolleiflex, heavy and old, and held it up toward the strip mall light. Then she swung it toward the street, then toward Rachel.
"Don't," Rachel said.
"I'm not. I'm testing." Priya thumbed the advance, checked the counter, and pointed the lens down at the folded logging sheets in Rachel's hand — the top page, trial number five, the date in neat pencil. She clicked the shutter.
The film advanced with a small mechanical whir.
"There," Priya said. "One page of a living document. If it develops, the rest will." She wound the lever and capped the lens. "Tomorrow night. Fourth floor. Bring the coat."