The charter boat was called Briny Girl and she smelled of diesel and old bait, and Fenn had paid four hundred pounds for the morning plus a hundred more not to ask the skipper where exactly they were going.
"North of the point," she said, when he did anyway. "Past the mussel ropes. You'll see the colour change."
She saw it before the diver did. A band across the water the grey of dishwater, a seam that didn't move with the tide, didn't break apart in the wind. From the deck it looked like nothing. From a hundred metres up it had looked like a wound.
Gordon came up the ladder in a bare-faced hood, forty-odd, a Stornoway accent gone soft from years in Oban. He had been a saturation diver on the North Sea platforms until his knees went, and now he did survey work and salvage and whatever else paid, and he had asked Fenn exactly two questions on the phone: what depth, and whether there'd be a camera on him.
"Fifteen metres," he said now, checking his console. "Warm layer sitting on top of the cold. You'll get your murk either way. Grey's a bad sign. Grey means it's been down there long enough to settle."
"How long?"
"I'm a diver, not a chemist." He spat over the side. "Long enough."
He went in backwards, and Fenn followed him with the lens, tracking the burst of bubbles down until the water swallowed the last of them. Then there was only the boat rocking and the gulls and the sound of the outboard ticking as it cooled.
Eleven minutes by the slate. She kept the camera running anyway — there was a shot in the line of the rope, the way it vanished into grey at four metres and came back out of it slicked with a fine silt. At nine minutes a cormorant surfaced twenty feet off the bow with something in its beak that it dropped. Fenn turned the camera on it. The thing sank before she could see it properly.
Gordon came up hard, spitting, and hauled his mask off before he was fully on the ladder.
"Get that camera up," he said. "I'll talk in the cabin."
He talked for four minutes and Fenn did not stop him.
"It's not a plume, it's a berm. That's the word for it. Like a — a shoal of the stuff, grey, clay-coloured, and it isn't moving, that's the thing. It's *sat* there. Ten foot high in the middle of it, three hundred metres along. You could walk on that. You could put a fence on that."
"And the pipe?"
"Two hundred millimetre, flexible, running out from the old pier line — the one they stopped using. It's buried about halfway in the sludge, but the near end's proud of it, maybe two metres. Laid there. Not fallen there, *laid* — it's got a concrete collar on it and the collar's still true." He drank his tea in one go. "There's a tag on it."
"On the pipe."
"On the collar. Stainless, on a wire. Same kind they put on lift gear. It's got a number on it and a logo and I read it underwater, that's how clean it is. Somebody's been out there maintaining that. You don't get a tag that legible on something abandoned twenty years."
Fenn opened her mouth and he held up a hand.
"I know what you want. I'm not saying the name. Not on camera, not off it, not in a statement. I'll tell *you* because you paid me and because I've dived that ground since I was twenty and I know what used to come out of that pier, and I'm angry about it the way you get angry about a thing you've watched get worse." He set the mug down. "But I've got a wife in Oban who works for the council, and I've got a compressor to replace, and I'm not the story. You film what I found. Not me saying what I think about it."
"Can I film your hands? Pointing at the chart? No face, no name. Diver One."
Gordon considered this for the length of a swallowed breath. "Hands is fine. No name."
They did it on the chart table, his blunt wet fingers walking east along the line of the old pier, pausing at a spot he'd marked with a pencil X. He pointed at the X. He pointed at the shore. He did not say a word, and Fenn did not ask him to; the silence of it was better, she knew it was better even while part of her howled for a voice.
She paid him in the cockpit. He shook her hand and then held it a second longer than the handshake needed.
"Two things," he said. "One. Whatever's in that berm is coming out of it slow, but it's coming out. That's why the bay's grey past the point and green this side of it. It'll be grey this side in five years." He glanced back at the water. "Two. That tag. If it's what I think it is, it's got a service date on it. Somebody signed it off. Somebody put their name on a bit of stainless steel and hung it on a pipe under fifteen metres of the sea, and they did that *recently*, because tags don't last, and that's your story. Not the mud. The signature."
She got the tag that afternoon, in a second pass with a pole-cam and two sealed torches, and it took her four goes because the surge kept pushing her off the line and because holding your breath is not a technique, and because the silt came up in a fog the moment she breathed too near the collar and she had to back off, wait, let it settle, go again.
But she got it. Six seconds of clean footage: the wire, the stainless rectangle, the stamped letters and the little chevron of a company mark, and under that a date she could read without help.
She surfaced into the rain and hauled herself over the gunwale and lay on the boards for a moment with the world turning under her like a coin. Then she sat up, unsealed the housing, and played the six seconds back with her hood dripping onto the deck.
April, the tag said. Two years and four months ago.
She had the discharge logs in the same bag. She had the ballast form with its two inks. She had a memo about an intervening member and a keeper's logbook with sections cut out, and now she had a length of pipe laid on purpose, maintained on purpose, signed off in a date a living man could be asked about, and stuck in a sludge bank that had been there long enough to be a landmark.
Not an accident. A system.
Her hands were shaking and it was not the cold.
She called Ishbel's number and got the machine and did not leave a message, because Ishbel did not want a message, Ishbel wanted a named source and a shore witness and six days. Fenn looked at the grey line of the point, and the green water this side of it, and thought about what Gordon had said — five years. She would be forty then. There would be a child in a school in Oban, or not. There would be a bay with a fence on it.
Then she called the number on the Oban charter card and asked whether Briny Girl was free on Thursday morning, early, before the light came up, and whether Gordon could dive without the pole-cam, just the handheld, just to be *seen* doing it — nothing more.
"He'll do it," the skipper said. "He said you'd ring."
Fenn put the phone down and sat in the wet car with the tag on the screen in front of her, six seconds long, playing again, playing again.
Her rough cut was on the floor of Sorcha's front room. The email in her drafts folder still had the complainant's name deleted out of it. Somebody in a press office in Glasgow had been ringing the commissioner about her personal connection to the subject, and she still did not know what that meant, and now there was a dated tag on a pipe and a diver who would stand at a rail in the dark and be somebody else's evidence.
Six days. On Thursday the light was going out at eight past seven and Callum would be walking the shore with her, on the record or not, and after that she would have to choose what she was willing to put a name to.
She drove back toward Orasay with the tag playing on the dash screen, and somewhere past the turnoff the signal dropped, and she did not notice for a mile.