The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 35: Two Yeses

The hall smelled of damp wool and yesterday's soup. Twenty-three people, by Fenn's count, arranged on folding chairs in a loose horseshoe that told her exactly who sat with whom and who had come alone. She set the projector case down on the trestle table but didn't open it.

"I'm not filming tonight," she said. "Nobody's in the frame. That's the first thing."

"That's a strange way to start a meeting about a film," said Dougie from the back, the one who ran the plant hire, the one Mrs. MacRae had named without naming.

"It's the only way to start it." Fenn held up a sheet of paper. "Sorcha Low rewrote our release form. Plain English. Four short paragraphs. It says what the film is, where it might be shown, that we won't use your words out of context, that you can withdraw up to the edit lock, and that you get a copy of what we shot of you before anyone else sees it."

"Sorcha wrote it?" Betsy Kirkpatrick leaned forward. "I taught Sorcha Low. She couldn't spell 'necessary' till she was fifteen."

"She spells it now," Sorcha said from the doorway. She hadn't sat down. "I read three legal templates and one of them was in Norwegian by mistake."

Some laughter. Fenn let it move through the room and settle.

"Here's how it works," she said. "If you want to speak on camera, you say yes when I ask you, and then before we roll, you say yes again. Out loud. Two yeses or no camera. If you change your mind the next day, it goes in the bin. No argument, no guilt trip." She looked at Callum, who stood against the wall with his arms crossed. "Callum and I agreed that rule and I'm keeping it even where it costs me."

"Where's it costing you?" Dougie asked.

"Tam's already told me he won't be in a frame. That's a loss. I'm not going to pretend it isn't."

The room shifted at Tam's name. Fenn watched three faces turn toward the door and back. Everyone knew about the seal now; Mrs. MacRae had been right about that.

"Ishbel wants a named source," Fenn said. "She'll ask you. I'd rather you'd heard the terms from me first."

Roy Malcolm stood up with his chair scraping. "Terms. Listen to it. Terms, on our own island."

"Sit down, Roy," said Betsy.

"I'll sit when I want. This is a woman who came out here to make a film about a lamp and now she's got a lawyer's paperwork at us."

"It's not a lawyer's paperwork," said the old crofter in the front row. He'd come in last and taken the chair nearest the stove, a man so weathered the light seemed to go into him rather than across. Fenn had his name from Sorcha's list. Angus Weir, eighty-one, of the township at Ardachaidh, two fields and eight sheep and no telephone.

"It's a lawyer's paperwork, Angus," Dougie said.

"Aye," Angus said. "And I signed a lawyer's paperwork in sixty-one when I bought my own croft off the estate, and I couldn't read that either."

Quiet. Fenn put her pen down on the form and did not pick it up again.

"I'll say yes," Angus said. "The twice."

He started to get up and Betsy was there before Fenn, so Fenn stayed where she was, at the table, hands flat. Angus came forward slowly, holding the edge of the table for the last two steps. He took the pen in his right hand and looked at the line for a long moment.

"My eyes are done," he said. "I can't manage the letters."

"Then don't," Fenn said. "Cross it. That's a signature. I'll write the date and my name as witness and Sorcha will witness too, and if anyone ever asks you, you say you signed with a cross and the woman from the film wrote the rest."

"You'd do that."

"I'd do that."

He made the cross. Two strokes, deliberate, the way you'd set a post. Then he stood a moment holding the pen and said, to the room rather than to her, "My father's brother put a cross on the Culloden list and never got a croft for it. So." He put the pen down. "Two yeses."

Betsy signed, and Mrs. Gillies from the post office, and a young man Fenn hadn't placed until he said he was home from Glasgow for the season and might stay. Five sheets in the folder. Fenn wrote the minutes in her notebook in her own shorthand, the pen moving even while she watched the room, and she wrote down who had signed and where they'd sat and what Angus had said about Culloden and the fact that she had filmed none of it.

Four refused out loud. Dougie first: "Not against you, but anything I say gets twisted by the time it's edited, and I've got the plant hire and a wife in the health centre." Then Roy Malcolm, who said the whole film was a stick for Glasgow to beat the island with. Then a man Fenn knew only as the McPhail, who did contract fencing for MacVane's estate, and who said nothing at all about reasons, just no. And then a woman near the door who said she'd think about it and Fenn wrote her down as refused, which she would understand.

"Cowards," someone muttered.

Fenn closed the folder. "No. They're the honest ones. You've all got a fortnight booking or a school contract or a cousin on the estate, and everyone in this room just counted it up before they spoke, including me." She looked at Callum. "We should stop here. It's dark and it's Thursday."

They cleared the chairs. Fenn stacked them against the wall and Sorcha gathered the cups, and people went out into the wind in twos and threes. Angus Weir went last, and at the door he stopped.

"Did you see it?" he asked. Not quietly.

Fenn's hands paused on the folder. "See what?"

"The dead thing in the shallows."

The room wasn't empty. Betsy was still there with her coat half on. Sorcha was holding the door. Fenn felt the exact shape of the moment, the way she'd felt it before on boats, the instant when you could lie and keep something or tell the truth and spend it.

"I didn't see it," she said. "Tam saw it. He wouldn't let me film it."

"Aye," Angus said. "Tam's got sense."

He went out. The door banged, settled, and Betsy finished her coat and left without saying anything at all.

Sorcha said, "You just told them Tam's the only witness."

"I did."

"That'll be round the island by breakfast."

"Probably." Fenn lifted the folder. Ten o'clock Thursday, Mrs. MacRae at the hotel, and the low water at seven and the burn still untraced. She was running out of week. "Sorcha. Where does the burn above the west beach come from? Physically. Where does it start?"

Sorcha pulled the door to against the wind. "There's a ditch that runs down from the back of the estate yard. The shed they keep the boat trailers in."

"Who owns the shed?"

"You know who owns it." Sorcha pulled her collar up. "You want me to go up there with you tomorrow?"

"No," Fenn said. "I want you to go up there with me at six, before it's light, and I want you to leave before the school run, and I don't want you on any release form if it comes to that."

"Six," Sorcha said. "Wear the boots, not the other boots."

The door shut. Fenn stood in the empty hall with the stove ticking and the folder of five signatures, and the six refusals, and Angus Weir's cross, and she put the folder in her bag on top of the release form Mrs. MacRae would read at ten.

Outside, across the bay, the lighthouse light went round once and was gone and came round again.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 35: Two Yeses · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads