The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 45: Ewan's Question

The chart was still on the table when Fenn came in from the yard, and Ewan was still at it, one hand flat on the paper like he was holding the island down.

He'd been at it two days. That was what Ishbel had said on the phone, before the part about Health and Safety. *He won't come out of the room, Fenn. He's got the chart and he's got a ruler and he keeps asking where you are.*

Now he looked up. His eyes were the same grey as the sea on a bad day, and he looked at her the way he looked at a heading he didn't trust.

"Sit," he said.

She sat.

The chart was the northern half of Orasay, the one Da kept for the fishing, creased at the Sound. Ewan had drawn on it in pencil. Not the outfall — north of it. A line that ran from the old pier out past the lobster grounds and stopped.

"You've been marking the drift," she said.

"Aye."

"Since when?"

"Since the Tuesday." He tapped the pencil line. "The tide takes it nor'-east. If the pipe runs, and the pipe's been running, then it goes where the creels are, and then it goes where the beach is, and then—" He stopped. "You know what I mean."

"I know what you mean."

He put the pencil down. His hands were shaking a little, the way they did since the hospital, and he set them flat on the chart so she wouldn't see it.

"Fenn," he said. "Are you going to stay?"

The kettle hadn't boiled. The window was doing its grey afternoon thing. Somewhere out past the headland a gull was losing an argument.

The honest answer was the one she'd been carrying since the ferry, and she gave it to him, because lying to Ewan had stopped being possible somewhere around the third week.

"I don't know."

He nodded slowly, like she'd confirmed a depth sounding.

"That's a fair answer," he said. "It's an honest answer. I'll take it."

"It's not—"

"I didn't ask for a promise. I asked a question and you answered it." He pulled the chart toward him, turned it, and found the blank margin at the bottom corner, the bit of sea that was only paper. He picked the pencil up again.

She watched him write it.

*Is she staying?*

Small, steady letters, the way a man writes when he's spent forty years writing on charts. Then beneath it he drew a short line, and beside the line he wrote the date.

*14th.*

The pencil made a sound like a small door closing.

Fenn looked at the margin, and then at the rest of the chart, and that was when she saw it. Because the margin wasn't blank. It hadn't been blank for a while.

Up the left edge, in the same small hand, in a neat column: *Grounded trawler, 9th.* Then two lines down, *Lights off, 11th — check bulb.* Then further up, near the compass rose, *F put kettle on — 12th.* And at the top, in the corner where the paper was softest from handling: *F. arrived. 3rd.*

Her own initials. In a dead man's neat column. A dead man's — no. Not yet. In an old man's neat column, on a chart of his island, kept the way everything on Orasay was kept: without saying so.

She'd walked in here thirty-some days ago with a drone case and a permit and a lens cap she'd already lost, and he'd put her on the chart.

"There's a whole column," she said.

Ewan didn't look up. "Aye."

"Ewan. There's a whole column of me."

"You came." He said it like that settled it. "You come, you go on the chart. That's how it works. When I was a boy my father had a chart with every boat he'd ever fished from on it, and the ones that sank, he drew a cross. Nobody thought it was strange."

"I'm not a boat."

"No," he agreed. "You're harder to find."

The kettle finally went. Neither of them moved for it.

Fenn pulled the chart around, careful, and read the column top to bottom. *F. arrived. 3rd.* *F went out to the light, 4th.* *F asked about the pipe, 5th.* Then a gap — the days she'd spent with Ishbel, the days she'd been in the water, the day she'd gone to the mainland and come back with a permit and a lie about it. And then the hand picked up again. *F away, Uist, 12th.* Back already. He'd known she was gone before Callum told him, because he'd written it in pencil on a chart.

"You've been keeping records of me," she said.

"I've been keeping records of the island. You're on the island."

"I wasn't on the island on the twelfth."

He looked at her then, properly, and there was nothing soft in it. "No," he said. "You weren't."

The room got very quiet. Out in the yard a hen said something to nobody.

So this was it. This was where he asked her, and this was where she'd have to decide how much of the truth she could carry into a kitchen that still smelled of his wife's shortbread tin.

"Kirsty MacLeòid," Ewan said. "On Uist."

Fenn didn't answer.

"You went to her because she keeps the true log." He said *true log* the way other men said *the good boat*, like it was a proper noun, like it was a thing everyone knew existed and simply never went looking for. "And you came back with something, or you'd not be sitting there looking like you swallowed a hook."

"How do you know she keeps a true log?"

"Because I kept one." He shifted in the chair. "Twenty-nine years, I kept one. The official log went to the Board. The other one stayed in the drawer under the tea towels, and when Ishbel found it she read the whole thing in one night and then she burned it, because she said there was no sense to leaving a gun in a drawer for the men who come after."

"She burned it?"

"She burned it." He reached over and turned the chart back around, face down, so the column was against the table. "You'll do as you like with that. I'm only telling you they burn them. That's what this island does with the truth. It keeps it exactly long enough to warm itself, and then it puts it in the fire, and then it goes back out to sea and catches fish."

Fenn heard herself say, at a distance, "Kirsty's won't burn. She's kept it since 2011."

"She's a MacLeòid. They keep everything." A pause. "What does she want for it?"

This was the question she'd been walking around for two days like a rock in the road, and there was no way past it now.

"She wants Callum in the frame with her. On camera. Both of them, side by side, or she won't speak."

Ewan was quiet for a long moment, and Fenn understood, watching him, that she had just handed him something worse than any pollution figure. She'd handed him why his eldest had come home after eleven years and gone straight to a ferry.

"He'll not do it," Ewan said.

"I know."

"He'll not do it, because he'd have to say out loud what she did, and if he says it out loud then he has to decide whether it was her fault or his." Ewan picked up the ruler and set it down again. "And he's been keeping that un-decided for eleven years. It's the only thing keeping him upright."

Fenn thought about Callum in the doorway of his own house, asking her to help him tell Ewan the truth, and her answer, *I'm not family*, still hanging in the air like smoke.

"Where is he now?" Ewan asked.

"With Da. He went up to Da's."

"Good," said Ewan, and something in his face loosened a fraction, and then closed again. "Then it'll be soon."

"Ewan." She leaned forward. "I need to ask you something and I need you to answer it straight. Did the Board ever ask you to sign a variation on the outfall consent? After 2011. Anything that moved the discharge point."

His eyes went to the chart, face-down on the table.

"Where'd you hear that?"

"Kirsty. And a coastguard I met on the ferry who pulled a report that was closed as natural die-off."

Ewan breathed out through his nose. Then he turned the chart back over, and reached past her column of initials, and put his thumb on the northern edge of the paper, past the lobster grounds, where the pencilled drift-line ended.

"There's a pipe out there," he said. "That's not on any chart. I put it on mine in 2011, and then the Board wrote to me and said I'd made an error, and I said, aye, likely, and I rubbed it out."

"Did you keep the letter?"

"I kept the letter."

Fenn's heart did something unprofessional.

"Where?"

"In the drawer under the tea towels," Ewan said. "Same as the log. Ishbel missed one."

He pushed the chart across the table at her — the whole island, her initials and all — and stood, slowly, both hands on the chair back.

"Take that to Stornoway with you," he said. "And when they ask who moved the pipe, you'll not have my name on your document. You'll have theirs."

He got as far as the door and stopped with his hand on the frame, back to her.

"Fenn."

"Yes."

"When you don't know whether you're staying," he said, "write it down. Put a date on it. Then one day you'll be able to look at the page and see which way you went."

The door shut behind him. Fenn sat alone with the chart, and the column of her own days, and a date written in pencil that she had not asked for and could not rub out.

Her phone buzzed against the table. Ishbel.

*Hearing's confirmed. Stornoway, Thursday, ten. MacKay's chairing.*

Then, a second later:

*They've listed a witness for the other side. It's Callum's mother.*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 45: Ewan's Question · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads