The hall door banged open on a gust of sea air, and Fenn's first thought was that the wind had done it, because nobody knocked like that on Orasay.
Then she saw Callum's face.
He was standing at the trestle table with a mug halfway to his mouth, and the mug stopped where it was. Not lowered, not set down — just stopped, as if the arm had forgotten its instructions. Fenn turned in her chair.
A woman stood in the doorway with a canvas bag over one shoulder and the low sun behind her, so that for a second she was only a shape, coat hem snapping, hair pulled back hard off her face. Then she stepped in and pulled the door shut and the shape became Kirsty MacLeod, thirty-eight years old now, ten years gone, and there was nothing in her expression that anyone could have called a homecoming.
Nobody spoke. Moira had a teacup suspended over the tray. Sorcha's pen had stopped on the minutes. Tam sat back very slowly, the way a man sits back when he wants his hands free.
Up on the platform at the far end of the hall, where Ewan had been threading a new cord through the brass bell's bracket, the boy looked up.
He rang it twice.
The sound went through the room like something breaking. Two clean strokes, close together, brass on cold air, and then the ring thinned out into the rafters and left a silence that was worse than before. Ewan had the cord in his fist and he was staring at the door, and on his face was a look Fenn had never seen there — not surprise. Recognition. As if he had been waiting for exactly this and had only been wrong about the day.
"Kirsty," Moira said, because Moira was the only one of them who could. "There's tea in the pot."
"I'm not stopping long." Kirsty set the bag down by the door, not by the table. She looked at her brother for the first time. "Callum."
"Kirsty."
That was all of it. Two names in a room full of people, and Fenn felt the temperature drop the way it does in a house when someone opens the wrong door.
Fenn should have said something. She was the outsider, the director, the one who had spent six weeks being told she was somebody's fiancée and had stopped correcting it in small ways and had started correcting it in large ones, and here was the woman whose actual name had been written on a form by a registrar who died before he could say it aloud. Fenn stayed quiet. She had learned on this island that some silences were load-bearing.
"I heard you were making a film," Kirsty said, to Fenn now, flat and level. "I heard a lot of things. I heard you've got Rennie's papers. I heard Trask came out here and made an offer in the bar."
"Hall," Tam said.
"Hall, then." Kirsty didn't look at him. "Word gets to Oban faster than the ferry. You want to know how fast? Faster than the ferry."
Callum set the mug down. It took him two tries to get it flat on the trestle. "You could have called."
"I could have." Kirsty's jaw moved. "I rang the manse three times in June. Do you know what I got? A care package reference number and a woman called Ishbel who was very polite about not knowing who I was."
"That's not Ishbel's fault, she—"
"I'm not here about Ishbel."
The stove ticked. Somewhere out in the harbour a halyard slapped a mast, regular as a metronome, and Fenn found herself counting it. One. Two. Three. She stopped.
"I came to give evidence," Kirsty said. "That's all. That's the whole of it. I don't know what you've been told about why I left and I don't much care to correct it, but I know what I signed in 2011 and I know it wasn't true, and I've been carrying that around for fourteen years like a stone in my coat. There's a surveyor's report. My name's on the second page. Vincent Rennie filled it in and I signed it because Vincent asked me to and because I was twenty-four and I wanted to keep my job." She stopped. Started again, quieter. "That's my evidence. I'll say it in front of whoever. The council, a reporter, the sheriff, your camera if that's what it takes."
Fenn's hand had gone to her pocket before she knew it. Her phone was there, beside the memory card, the two backup drives stacked like flat stones. Eleven days of evidence chain in one coat pocket. She made herself take the hand out.
"And I want it said plainly in this room," Kirsty went on, "so nobody can pretend they misheard. I did not come here to forgive anybody. I didn't come to be forgiven. Anyone in this hall who thinks that's the trade being offered can take it off the table right now."
Tam exhaled, long. Sorcha's pen went back to the paper and made a small mark. Moira's teacup finally, quietly, went down onto the tray.
"You'd get a fair hearing," Callum said. His voice came out with a crack in it and he cleared it. "I'm not asking you to forgive me, Kirsty. I never asked you for that."
"I know you didn't."
"You asked me to sign, if you remember. The log. You came down to the harbour and you asked me—"
"I remember exactly what I asked you." Kirsty's hands were steady; her voice wasn't quite. "And you said no, and you were the only one who said no, and I would like that on the record too, since we're doing records. You said no and you lost your job for it and you went and did the same thing again in June, from what I hear, for the same reason, for the price of an old man's nine hundred pounds a month. So you don't get to stand there looking like a drowned dog on my account. I didn't come for that."
Fenn looked at Callum, and Callum was looking at the floorboards as if he had never seen them properly. There it was, then. She had spent two weeks trying to get the whole of the ballast-log story out of him and here it was, in the open, delivered by the one person on earth entitled to deliver it. He had said no in 2011. It was why he had been so ready to say yes in his own way in June — borrowing from Trask's subsidiary like the money was a rope, not a hook.
She thought of the falsified log, unsigned, sitting in a drawer somewhere in the manse. Thursday morning. The care-package call.
"Is this the part where you tell me about the film," Kirsty said, turning to Fenn at last, and there was something almost like humour in it, worn thin. "Because if I'm giving evidence to a documentary I'd rather be told to my face and before it starts, not after."
"You're not giving it to a documentary yet," Fenn said. "You're giving it to five people in a hall."
She said it before she'd decided to. She felt Callum's head come up.
"There's a screening," Fenn said. "Small hall, festival, Saturday. One night only, and the sponsor has to be held off it, and Ishbel's carrying that risk herself. After that the whole thing goes wider, or it doesn't, depending on this room. The recording Trask made me is still under wraps by a four-to-one vote, and the vote's up on Thursday." She paused. "You've walked in at the tight end of it. I'm sorry. That's the truth and it's a poor welcome."
Kirsty looked at her for a long moment. Then she picked the bag back up off the floor — and carried it, four steps, to the trestle table, and set it down among the mugs and the minutes. She unzipped it. Inside were two cardboard folders and a small plastic wallet holding a strip of negatives.
"Copies," she said. "I kept copies of everything before I walked. Fourteen years, Fenn. You'll not out-wait me on patience. Where do you want me?"
Nobody answered, because nobody had expected the question to have an answer yet, and the halyard outside kept slapping time over the harbour and Fenn suddenly could not stop hearing it.
Then Tam stood up and said, "You'll want a chair and you'll want it facing the door, in case you change your mind," and Sorcha laughed once, short, into her minutes, and the room came back to itself like water closing over a stone.
Fenn looked at the bell on its platform, cord swinging gently where Ewan had let it go. Twice for trouble. She didn't know yet what three times meant, but the boy was watching his aunt the way you watch weather coming in from the west — not frightened, exactly. Waiting.
"First thing tomorrow," Fenn said, "before the boat comes in. I've got a film to re-edit and there's an hour in it I'd been planning to fill with something else." She looked at Kirsty. "You've just saved me an hour."