The shop opened at eight. Fenn was there at half past seven with a stack of paper still warm from the printer in the back room of the manse, where Ishbel's old machine had jammed twice and she'd had to pull the sheets out one at a time.
She did not put it on the counter. She put it on the windowsill next to the box of eggs, where the ferry timetable was, and weighted one corner with a stone.
The sheet was one page. Plain. No crest, no letterhead, no list of names at the bottom, only room at the top for a signature.
*We, the undersigned, residents of Orasay, call upon the Highland Council and the Scottish Environment Protection Agency to (1) investigate the release of ballast and industrial effluent into the Minch from the MacVane fish-processing intake between 2010 and 2012, (2) hold a publicly minuted hearing on Orasay, and (3) suspend any renewal of the intake's discharge consent pending the outcome.*
*Signed.*
That was all.
Ewan came in at nine exactly, the bell over the door still ringing when he reached the sill. He read it twice. Then he took the pen out of the mug, uncapped it with his teeth, and wrote in letters big enough to read from the door:
**EWAN MACLEOD.**
He put the pen back, nodded at Fenn once, and bought a paper he did not need. He was out the door in under three minutes.
By ten there were four names. By noon, nineteen.
—
Fenn went back to the manse and cut the screening footage for forty minutes, not watching the clock, and came down again at half two because she could not concentrate. She walked down to the shop for no reason.
There were forty-one signatures.
Ishbel Cameron was behind the counter, pricing tins with a marker, and did not look up. There was a pen in her apron pocket.
Fenn bought milk she did not need and left.
—
At four, she walked past the pier. Sinclair's hire car was still there, boot closed. The boat for Oban left at six; Fenn did not know whether Sinclair would be on it and found she did not want to know, because knowing would make the waiting worse. Past the pier, on the road where the hall stood, she saw a man in a navy jacket standing with his phone up, filming the empty building. He saw her. He put the phone down and walked off toward the hotel with his hands in his pockets, unhurried, as though he had every right.
She knew his face now. She still did not have a name for it.
—
At six, the shop closed. Fenn went in with the key Ishbel had given her months ago for the water samples, and lifted the stone off the sheet.
Ninety.
She counted twice. Ninety names, in ballpoint and one in green felt-tip, some of them in capital letters and some of them in a shaky hand so small she had to hold it to the window. Families. Two of the names were the same name twice, husband and wife, one above the other with a small dashes between them. A hand she did not know had written *and my son, 14* at the bottom, and the woman at the counter had let it stand.
A hundred and twelve people lived on Orasay. Ninety had signed inside a day.
—
She photographed the sheet on the shop counter under the strip light and sent it to no one, because she had no one to send it to yet. Then she took it down off the wall and folded it small, because leaving it there overnight felt like leaving the door unlocked.
Tam was in the pub, in the corner seat, with the darts board behind him and a half of heavy in front of him.
"Ye got it, then," he said.
"Ninety."
"That's no' an answer, that's arithmetic." He looked at her. "That's about as many as turned out for the lifeboat fund. And that was a boat."
"I need to know what they want done with it," Fenn said. "A hundred and twelve people live here. Ninety of them just put their name to an investigation that names the only employer on the island. I cannot be the one who decides what that becomes."
"Sit down."
She sat down.
"Ye ever hear what happened to Dunmore?" Tam said. "Across the water. They had the same thing, twenty year back. Same company. Signed a letter, the lot. And then nothing happened, because nothing was ever filed, and the men who signed it had to live in the same village as the men who hadnae, and by the spring nobody said the word Dunmore out loud, and by the summer there was a rota of who was allowed to be angry about it, and that rota was empty." He drank. "The names are the thing. Not the paper. The paper's the excuse."
"I know."
"Then ye know ye cannae sit on it for the camera. Ye take it to Oban yerself, or ye send it with somebody who'll be listened to."
"Sinclair leaves tonight."
"Then send it with Sinclair."
"I don't know that he'll—"
"Aye, well." Tam shrugged. "Ye'll no' know till ye ask. And if ye're asking me what I want done with it — I want it walked down that pier in daylight, where the whole village can see it going, so no one can say later they didnae know. That's my price."
—
She went back to the manse and rang the hotel and asked for Mr Sinclair. It took four minutes for him to come to the telephone.
"I've got ninety signatures," she said. "One page. No affiliation. Investigation, hearing, suspension of the consent. Half the island."
A pause on the line, long enough that she heard the fridge behind the bar.
"You understand," Sinclair said, "that I have taken a statement from Mr MacLeod, and I have taken his log to Oban, and that the Crown may decide to charge him. And that if you hand me ninety names, I am obliged to note them."
"Noted."
"That is not a small word."
"No," Fenn said. "It isn't."
Another pause.
"The boat is six fifteen," he said. "I'll be at the pier from six."
—
Ewan was already there when she reached the front, leaning on the rail by the ferry office with the wind pulling at his jacket. Fenn had the page in a stiffened envelope and did not open it.
Sinclair came down the brae at five past six with a holdall and his coat over his arm. He looked at Ewan. Ewan looked at him.
"Mr MacLeod."
"Inspector."
Sinclair took the envelope and put it in the inside pocket, not the holdall. He asked one question: "Does Mr Cameron know how many."
"He does now," Ewan said.
Sinclair nodded, once, and got on the boat.
They watched it go until the stern light was a dot in the dusk and the gulls had given up following it. The whole pier was full. Not a crowd, exactly — a scatter of people, some of whom had signed and some of whom had come down not to sign, and nobody said anything to anyone, and that was a kind of speech too. Ishbel Cameron stood at the very end with her hands in her coat and left before the boat was out of the bay.
"Ninety," Ewan said.
"Ninety."
"Ye'll want the rest." He wasn't asking.
Fenn looked at the water where the boat had been. Somewhere past the point, under the dark, the intake was still running; Trask's man had a room at the hotel and a phone full of footage of the hall where she had shown the island its own water. In the morning, the whole of it would be on Oban's desk, and by the afternoon it would be somebody's problem in an office in Inverness, and by Friday it would be Trask's problem, and Trask had never once in four years behaved like a man who had a problem he couldn't buy off.
"Twenty-two," she said. "That's how many didn't. And one of the ninety is going to call one of the twenty-two tomorrow, and it's going to be like it was at Dunmore."
"Aye," Ewan said. "It's going to be exactly like Dunmore."
He turned for the road up the brae, and Fenn started to follow, and then she saw it: a woman coming down, doubling, hurrying, and it was the one from the shop wall with the green felt-tip, and she had her coat half on and was waving a piece of paper that had been folded so many times it was soft as cloth.
"You'll need this before you go," she said, and pressed it into Fenn's hand. "It's two hundred and forty pound. It's what I have. My man would sign if he could — he's on the rig till the thirty-first — but he says he'll sign when he's back and I want it wrote down that he said it."
Fenn looked at the paper. It was a cheque, made out to nobody, with the name of the bank and the date and, at the bottom, in the same green felt-tip, *For the water. — M. Black, 4 Cnoc.*
"I can't—" Fenn started.
"Aye, ye can." The woman — Black, then, Morag Black, from up the hill — looked past her at the dark water. "Eleven thousand pound is what Callum's in for, I heard. That's no' a debt, that's a rope." She put her hands in her pockets. "Ye'll be wanting that off him before the summer, I'd say. Or the summer'll be wanting something off us."