The notice went up at nine past eleven, on the harbour board between the ferry timetable and a rain-blurred poster for a ceilidh that had happened in March.
Fenn filmed it happen. That was the thing she kept coming back to. She stood with the camera on her shoulder in the wind coming off the Sound, and she watched a man in a lanyard and a good coat smooth the sheet flat with the side of his hand, and she filmed all of it, and the tape would smell of salt and diesel for the rest of its life.
FORMAL INVESTIGATION — she had it in frame, she could read it from here. SEPA. She read the rest between gusts: *discharges from the MacVane Marine outfall at Ardnahoe, Orasay, between March 2011 and the present date, in respect of which material irregularities in monitoring records have been identified... regulatory action under consideration...* and then the seal, the small embossed thing, pressed into the corner of the paper in a way that meant a woman in Stirling had signed her name to a lie she was calling a finding.
Behind her, someone let a car door go too hard.
She turned. Ian Trask's second-in-command got out — no, not Trask's. The woman from the phone. Alice Nairn, head of operations, MacVane Marine, in a navy coat with the collar up and a folder under her arm that she never opened, and she walked the length of the car park like she owned the tarmac, which, in a way Fenn supposed, she did.
"You're Fenn Adair."
"I am."
"I've been trying your number for three days."
"I know," Fenn said. "I watched it ring."
Nairn stopped about two metres off. The wind moved her hair and she didn't bother with it. She had the flat, patient face of a woman who had never once in her life been shouted at by somebody she considered a peer.
"I'm not going to threaten you," she said. "I want you to know that, because I expect you've been told to expect it. I'm not going to threaten you, and I'm not going to offer you money, because somebody's already tried the money on your neighbours and I can see how that's gone down." A pause. "Nineteen years, Ms Adair. That's what you've put a line through this morning. Nineteen years of a plant that has paid the rateable value of half this island and kept a hundred and twelve people off the boats that are going under in every other harbour from here to Barra. A hundred and twelve livelihoods. You should have that number in your head. You put it there yourself."
Fenn kept the camera down. She had learned, over three months, when the camera helped and when it made her a person with a camera.
"Which hundred and twelve," she said.
Nairn's mouth did something that wasn't a smile. "Don't."
"I'm asking a question."
"You're asking a question to make me sound like a woman with a spreadsheet. It's a good trick. I've used it." Nairn stepped in; the wind wasn't in the gap anymore. "Your footage is nine minutes of a sick man's regrets in a cold room. Your logs are one log, one year, one signature. You've built a formal investigation out of a single defect, and when it collapses — and it will collapse, because there is a procedure for this and the procedure is not a documentary — the number won't be a hundred and twelve any more. It'll be a hundred and twelve families who spent two years being told by their neighbours that they were the ones who were wrong. That's the bill. You won't be here to pay it."
Fenn heard him before she saw him. That was how Tam arrived everywhere — the boots on the gravel, and then the voice, and only then the man.
"Ninety of us signed," he said.
Nairn turned.
Tam Buchan stood behind Fenn with his hands in his coat pockets and his chin tucked low against the wind, the way he stood on the pier when there was weather coming. He didn't raise his voice. Tam never raised his voice; that was the whole of him.
"Ninety of us signed," he said again. "The petition, the trust letter, the statement for the camera. My wife, my daughter, the boy in the shop, the two boats at the far pier that tie up under MacVane's licence. Ninety names, Ms Nairn. I counted them myself, because Kirsty made me, because she said if we were going to do it we'd do it honestly." He looked at her folder. "So say a hundred and twelve again. Say it now that I'm standing here."
Nairn's jaw set. For one second the coat and the collar and the good coat stopped being armour and were just wool, in wind.
"I don't have a conversation to have with you," she said, to Fenn.
"You have one with the regulator," Fenn said. "That's the one that's already started."
Nairn looked past her, at the notice, at the small pressed seal, and something went over her face that Fenn recognised because she had felt it herself, standing in the lantern room at first light with a camera she shouldn't have had. Not fear. Recognition. The moment when the thing you've been managing becomes a thing you're inside of.
She turned and walked back to the car without saying anything else, and the gravel went under her and the door opened and shut, and the car went out past the breakwater, and Fenn kept the camera rolling on the empty tarmac for six seconds after, because six seconds of nothing is where the editor finds the cut.
Then she lifted her eye and looked at the notice.
The regulator's man was still there, in his lanyard and his good coat, and he had a small tin in his hand and was dabbing the seal once more against his thumb — a second one, this time, for the copy that would go in the records, because the law wanted it twice. Fenn crossed the gravel and put the lens on his hands.
He didn't look up. He pressed the seal to the paper, held it, lifted it.
The mark came away clean.