The chart tube was the first thing in the van because Sorcha had carried it down herself before breakfast, before anyone could offer to help, and it lay along the wheel arch like something patient. Fenn set the camera on the tailgate and framed it: the tube, the two duvets rolled and strapped, the crate of books with the corners softened to felt.
"How much of this is your mother's?" Fenn asked.
"One duvet. She says the good one." Sorcha wedged a laundry basket against the books. "The other I bought in Oban in March with money I wasn't supposed to have yet."
"For the course?"
"For the deposit on the course. The deposit I couldn't pay." Sorcha stood back and looked at the load, doing sums with her eyes. "Two hundred and forty pounds. I'd have got it back if I hadn't moved the money to the boat fund when the engine went. So I paid the deposit late and I was off the list, and I sat on the seawall in Oban for an hour deciding whether to tell anyone."
"And you told Ewan."
"I told Ewan." A gull landed on the tailgate and Sorcha waved it off without looking at it. "He said, put the boat on the card, don't put yourself on the card. Which is very like him, and also terrible advice, because the boat is his."
Fenn moved the camera in on the refuse letter: the pale blue crest, the two sentences, the word *regret*. Sorcha had had it framed at her own expense in a plain black moulding, and the glass was already smudged with fingerprints from everyone in the house having picked it up to read it.
"Don't shoot that like it's sad," Sorcha said.
"I'm not."
"You're shooting it like it's a museum."
"It is a museum. It's the museum of the morning you found out you weren't getting what you wanted."
Sorcha laughed — the short, surprised laugh she gave when anyone undercut her. "Fine. Then get the good light on it. It goes in the window, not the wall."
The marine trust's letter had come to her two days after the regulator's notice went public, on trust letterhead, signed by a woman whose name Sorcha recognised from a paper she'd cited in her application the year before. *The committee read the material submitted by your referees and exercised its discretion regarding the deposit.* Two hundred and forty pounds, waived. Plus fees. Plus the field placement. Plus, Sorcha said, a bus pass she found insulting and would use anyway.
Fenn got her on tape saying the name of the trust, the name of the course, the length of it — eighteen months, mainland, two full years of field time compressed into it because she'd already done the informal half on the shore.
"And they said it wasn't anything to do with the case," Sorcha said. "They said it in writing. I checked twice, because I've had eighteen months of learning what a thing means when it's said in writing, and that one means what it says. It's a scholarship. It's just a scholarship."
"You don't have to keep saying it."
"I do, actually." She pulled the straps tight on the duvets, tested them with her thumb. "Because if I say it enough it stops sounding like something I did to you."
"You didn't do anything to me."
"Half the island thinks the water got clean and a girl got paid. That's a tidy story and I don't want to be standing in it."
Fenn shouldered the camera and followed her into the house. The kitchen had the stripped look of somewhere a person was leaving in stages: shelf paper gone, the blue jug wrapped in newspaper, the kettle sitting in an open box because Sorcha had decided she could live on tea bought at the services. On the table, the letter from MacVane's solicitors, folded once and put under the fruit bowl.
"You kept that."
"I keep everything." Sorcha dropped a mug into the box with the rest. "It says I'd be named as a witness, and it says I should consider my position regarding future employment, and then it says *we trust this clarifies*. It clarifies nothing. That's why I framed the other one and not this one."
"Can I film you leaving the two letters together?"
"No."
"Fair."
"Film me finishing this mug."
So Fenn did: Sorcha drinking tea standing up, the box behind her, the salt on the window so thick the bay came through it as a grey smear. Then the packing, the last hour of it, kept whole in the order it happened — a duvet in the roof box, the chart tube slid behind the passenger seat where it couldn't roll, one pair of boots kept out and the other pair left by the door.
"That's the last thing," Sorcha said. "The boots. They don't come. Tell me that's a good shot."
"It's a good shot."
"Right." She shut the boot and put both palms flat on it, not leaning but fixing it in place. "Now say what you're going to say, because I've got the tide."
Fenn lowered the camera.
"Both of us can't just stand here," she said.
"We can for a minute." Sorcha turned round. The wind had got into her hair and she didn't fix it. "I'll be back. Not at Christmas — the placement's the wrong end of the country — but the year after, when the fieldwork's done. And it'll be different, Fenn. That's the bit nobody's saying. Two hundred and forty pounds was the barrier, and it's gone, and now the next girl in the year above doesn't have to sit on the seawall deciding whether to tell anyone. That's the part you don't film. That's the part—"
She stopped.
"I'm not going to finish that sentence, it sounds like a plaque."
"It does."
"I'll write it in the letter instead."
They stood in the yard with the van between them, and out past the paling the bay was doing what it did — a flat pewter sheet with the light going long across it, the nine sample sites invisible from here and therefore honest. Fenn had shot that bay from six positions and never once got MacVane's plant in the frame except as a smudge. That was a choice. Sorcha had helped her make it and had never asked to be thanked for it.
"Will you be here?" Sorcha said.
"When you come back?"
"I'm not asking you to promise. I'm asking if the maths works." Her voice did something quick at the edges. "Because I've been the one who leaves. Everyone on that side of the water has already left something. And it would be — I'd like to know I'm coming back to one person who isn't a memory."
Fenn put the camera down on the tailgate and thought about the year in the contract and what it had been built on, and Ewan asking twice when the short would exist, and a photograph of a signature she still owed him, and a letter that had not arrived.
"I'll be here," she said. "I don't know in what shape. But I'll be on this island to see it."
"I didn't ask about shape."
"You asked whether the maths works. That's the maths now."
Sorcha nodded, once, briskly, and took the keys. There was no long scene at the driver's door and no waving down the track, because the island did that part inside the first ten yards and there was no point doing it twice. Fenn stood with the camera on her shoulder and let the van go up the track until the tail lights were two pinpricks, then nothing, then the sound of a gear change she couldn't see.
She shot four minutes of an empty road, switched off, and deleted it.
In the cottage, the memo was still on the door, held by the fridge magnet, softening at the corners. Under it on the mat lay a fat envelope with the trust crest and no stamp — hand-delivered, then, and recently, because the paper was still cold. Fenn turned it over without opening it and read the label twice: her own name, in Ishbel's hand.
She took out her phone and typed a message to Sorcha: *you left the good mug.*
The reply came as the kettle boiled. *keep it. it's a keeper's mug now.*
She set it on the shelf, filled it, and went to open the envelope.