The ferry came in on a flat grey sea with the gulls working the wake, and Fenn was on the pier with her camera bag because she had learned that on Orasay you met the boat whether or not you had a reason.
She had a reason. She wanted to see whether Duncan would come back at all.
He came down the ramp with a rucksack on one shoulder and a holdall in his hand and nothing else, no kit, no cases, and he stopped at the bottom of the ramp and looked at the water for a while before he looked at the island. Fenn stood where she was and let him get his bearings. It was the first time she had seen him off the boat in three weeks, and the weeks had done something to him, hollowed him out at the cheeks and put a set to his mouth she hadn't seen.
He walked up the pier and stopped in front of her.
"No camera," he said.
"It's in the bag."
"Right." He shifted the rucksack. "Can we go somewhere that isn't the hall."
They sat in the cab of his own truck, which had been sitting at the pier for three weeks with a flat battery that Tam had charged for him without being asked, and Duncan put his hands on the wheel like he was going to drive and then didn't.
"I've listened to the numbers," he said. "Every witness statement from the tribunal. Rab read them to me over the phone. I couldn't read them myself, I kept — " He stopped. Started again. "The turbidity figures. The shell bed. Your man's charts. All of it."
"It's in the public record as of last Tuesday."
"I know it is. That's why I'm here." He looked at Fenn. "You're cutting this thing for Inverness."
"Twenty-two minutes of companion material, and the main film's locked. Six days."
"Then you'll be doing credits."
"I'll be doing credits."
"Don't put me in them."
Fenn didn't answer straight away. Out the windscreen, the creel boats sat on their moorings and the light was doing what it did on the bay at this hour, laying a long silver road across the water to the point, and she thought about how many hours of this exact view she had in the drive, unlabelled.
"You're the reason half of it exists," she said. "The harbour recordings. You sat with me on that wall in the rain and you told me what a diesel slick does to a spawning bed. That's the spine of the whole segment."
"Aye, well."
"Duncan."
"I'm not asking to be taken out of the story," he said, and there was an edge on it now, the first sharp thing she'd heard from him. "I'm asking not to have my name on it. I've got a wife whose family have fished this bay four generations. I've got a boy at the school in Oban. The man who said it on camera is a man who took MacVane's money for eleven years and I'll not have that in the same frame as my name for the rest of my life, on some mainland server, for anyone to pull up."
Fenn turned that over. It was, she thought, the first thing he had ever asked her for directly.
"Fine," she said. "No name. 'A local creel fisherman.'"
"Fisherman's fine."
"Is it not going to bother you in a year? When the short's out and there are nine other men with their names up and you're the one voice nobody can place?"
Duncan put the truck in gear and then took it out again without moving. "Ask me in a year," he said.
She drove him home because he still wouldn't start the truck, and on the way he asked her to pull in at the boatyard, and Tam was there on the slip with a sander and a mask pushed up on his forehead.
"Fenn," Tam said. "Duncan. The prodigal."
"I need work," Duncan said. It came out flat and fast, like he'd been holding it since Inverness. "Ashore. I'm done with the trawlers. I'm done being at sea for three weeks with men who'll not look at me."
Tam set the sander down and looked at him for a long moment. Then he jerked his chin at the water.
"You see the blue one, second mooring?"
"The creel boat."
"The Faithful. She's mine and she's honest and she doesn't go further out than I can swim back from." Tam wiped his hands on his trousers. "I'm seventy-one in March and the shell bed's coming back and someone's going to be working it the right way, short strings, marked gear, no dragging. I'll not be doing it forever."
Duncan stood very still.
"I've never fished creels in my life," he said.
"You've fished everything else in this bay for a quarter of a century. You know where the ground is." Tam picked the sander back up and started on the strake again, speaking to the hull instead of the man. "You don't have to be brave to be honest, Duncan. You only have to do the small thing every day and not stop. That's all the boat asks."
There was a long quiet with the water slapping under the slip and the gulls going over.
"Aye," Duncan said, eventually. "Alright."
Fenn recorded it, because she'd had the camera in her hand before she'd decided anything, and because Tam had seen her do it and given a small nod that was as good as a release form. But she did it wide, from the slip, the two men small in the frame and the creel boat on its mooring, and she kept the sound running because the sound was the whole point — the sander, the water, Duncan's voice cracking on the word *alright*.
She knew what it was by the time she got back to the cottage. She cued it up that night against the harbour sequence, the one they'd shot in the rain off the wall with the diesel rainbow on the water, and she put Tam's line under it and let the picture run.
It worked. Not as a fist in the air. As a door opening. The tribunal's evidence was all chart and number and one man's charts that Inverness didn't want to credit. What the film had been missing was a man who had done the wrong thing for eleven years standing in the open saying so, and a man who'd been on the water since before any of them were born saying what the right thing looks like. The bay closing the shell bed and opening it again. Not a verdict. A way back.
She wrote it in as the companion short's final movement and sat back and looked at the clock. Half ten. Six days.
Her phone lit on the table. Priya.
*Main film went out at nine. Three press requests already, one of them from the Herald. Douglas has gone very quiet. That's either good or he's on the phone to Inverness. Call me when you can.*
Fenn looked at the message for a while. Then she looked at the cut, with Duncan's nameless voice in it, and at the harbour water on the screen, and she thought about the audit memo on the cottage door and the name on it that matched the name on the softening email, and she thought — this is the last clean day before the mainland starts talking back.
She went to the wall for the release form. Duncan wouldn't sign it without reading it twice and would probably make her change something, and she wanted it done before the ferry.