The Lightkeeper's Fiancée

Chapter 85: The Finished Film

The cinema was a converted church on the river, and it still had the bones of one — the high vaulted ceiling, the gallery where the choir used to sit, the small confession of light coming through three lancet windows someone had decided not to board over. Fenn had been in worse rooms. She had been in a barn in the Outer Hebrides with a projector balanced on a feed trough and the wind coming through the door every time someone arrived late. This was a barn with better acoustics.

She sat between them. Callum on her left, still in the jacket he'd worn to the meeting, Ewan on her right, upright as a fence post, his hands folded on his knees. There were two hundred and forty seats and every one of them was filled, and near the back, in the row by the pillar, she could see Duncan's shoulders, and Tam beside him, and beside Tam, the woman she was fairly certain had been Duncan's sister since the first day on the pier. Kirsty was three rows behind Ewan, directly in his eyeline, though she'd never once let him turn around and find her looking.

The lights went down at seven minutes past seven. Ishbel walked to the front with a page of notes she did not look at.

"Ladies and gentlemen, honoured guests, and anyone who came because a friend told them to and now isn't sure they should be here." A laugh rolled through the room. "I'm Ishbel, I chair the Orasay community trust, and I have been asked to say a few words. I will say them quickly because the film is better than my words."

She turned a page and didn't read it.

"This started as a job. A lighthouse is being decommissioned and there's a fund to make a record of it before the light goes out for good, and the trust applied, and we got a director on loan who was meant to be here for eleven days." She looked at Fenn, and Fenn looked at the aisle. "She has been here four months. In that time she has filmed a bell being rung, a harbour at four in the morning, a man saying a sentence he did not want to say, and a village meeting at which every person in the room raised their hand — including her, which is in the film, and I will not spoil it further. She has also, and this is the part that matters to me, told the truth about a bay that four generations of us were told was fine."

The room went very still in the way rooms do when a chair has scraped somewhere and nobody wants to own it.

"One of the things the film does not contain is an answer to the question of who is to blame. That work is still going on, and it is going on in Inverness and elsewhere, and I am not going to stand in a cinema and pre-empt it." She closed the folded page. "But I will say this. The water here keeps our records now. We take it every month. We write down what we find. Nobody in this room can be told again that they imagined it."

She nodded once, and the lights came down the rest of the way.

The film opened on water at the foot of the rock, grey and moving, the sound of it recorded close enough that the room physically tilted toward it. Fenn had watched the cut eleven times and it still took her a second to remember that she was in a chair and not on the pier, boots wet, hands cold, the wind taking the boom.

There was Ewan's voice, unedited, unmixed, saying the tide goes out but the water doesn't leave. There was the animation unfurling from his nine years of charts, the colour bleeding from the centre of the bay outward, and somewhere in the dark the community trust's quarterly record going up on screen as a straight line the audience could read.

Then, near the end — and this was the part she had promised herself she would not watch the audience during — the harbour recording. Duncan's voice, no name, no face, just the sound of a man saying the thing he could not say sitting down. And then, cut hard against it, the creel boat, and the line Tam had said at the boatyard about being honest, and Duncan on the deck with his hand on the gunwale, no name, no explanation, just a man getting what was offered.

Fenn kept her eyes on the screen and felt Callum's sleeve shift beside her. She did not look at the back row. That was the rule she'd made for herself, and she kept it.

The last shot was the show of hands. Twenty-three to nothing, and then a hand from the aisle joining them — her own, filmed by Priya, at Fenn's request, in the last ten minutes of the last day. She had argued with herself about it on the drive down. Some part of her had said it was the director walking into the frame, which is the thing you don't do. Another part had said the film's subject was a decision, and the director had made one.

It held for four seconds and then went black.

The room was silent for one full breath. Then the sound came up all around her — not a cheer exactly, more like a room taking its first air in an hour — and the lights came up, and Fenn saw that Ewan had both hands gripping his knees, and that his eyes were wet, and that he was not going to do anything about that.

"Right," he said.

"Right," she said.

The Q&A was Ishbel's idea and Fenn had agreed to it in a weak moment. There were three of them on the low stage at the front — Fenn on a stool, Ewan beside her, Callum on the end because Ishbel had said, flatly, that a film about a place should have someone from the place on stage, and Callum had not argued, which was itself a kind of argument.

Ishbel moderated. The first questions were what Fenn had expected. How long was the shoot. Four months and eleven days. Was the animated sequence made from original charts. Every one, scanned by Ewan himself at the kitchen table. What happened after the inspection. Ishbel fielded that one and said the process was ongoing and the film would be updated if anything material changed, which was code and everybody knew it.

A woman near the front asked about the community's decision to publish its own record, and whether that would make the bay a test case.

"It already is one," Fenn said. "It was one before we arrived. We just wrote it down."

Beside her, Callum's knee settled an inch, and stayed.

Then a man in the fourth row put his hand up and did not put it down, and Ishbel nodded to him. He was maybe forty, in a good coat, and his voice had the flat politeness that comes from having decided on the question before arriving.

"This is for the director." He looked down at a card in his hand, then up. "There's a story going round that you came here as somebody's fiancée. That the paperwork for the trust had a name on it and it wasn't —" He made a small gesture at the stage. "That the whole engagement was invented. I read it in a paper and I'd like it confirmed or denied from the horse's mouth, since you're standing here."

The room did not gasp. It did something worse. It went quiet in a particular way, the way of two hundred and forty people all deciding at once not to look at Callum, which meant that everyone did.

Fenn felt her own face do nothing, which was practice. She had been asked worse things on camera. She had been asked, once, by a man with a boom mic over her head, whether the drowning coast film was a career move, and she'd answered that one too.

She found the microphone with her hand, brought it half an inch closer. Behind her, Ishbel had gone still. Beside her, Ewan's breathing was audible, once.

"No," Fenn said. "It wasn't real. It was a form."

The man's pen moved.

"Two years ago there was a subsidy process that required an application to be made by a household, and a household required..." She paused. "It required a name. A name was put on the form without my knowledge, by someone who had seen my earlier work and thought an honest name on a document would do more good than a convenient one. When I found out, I was angry. That's on the record and it's in the film's companion short, which we'll screen last for anyone who wants to stay."

She could feel Callum not moving beside her. She did not look at him, because if she looked at him now, in front of this room, she would lose the thread.

"It was a form," she said again, slower. "And then it was a choice. Everything after the form, I chose. I stayed. I filmed. I put my own hand in the frame. So if the question is whether something true came out of something untrue, the answer is yes, and it's the film. That's the only answer I have."

She set the microphone down on the stool beside her. The sound of it touching the wood went through the whole room, which was how quiet it was.

The man in the good coat looked at his card, and then at her, and then he wrote nothing down, and sat back. That was the whole of the moment. Nobody applauded. That was fine. Applause would have been the wrong tool.

Under the seat, Callum's hand found hers.

He didn't take it exactly. He laid his fingers over her knuckles, the way you might settle a piece of paper that was about to blow away, and he left them there, not gripping, just present. His thumb moved once along the side of her hand and stopped. He was looking straight ahead at the back of the room, at nothing in particular, and his face gave away entirely that he was doing it. Anyone watching would know. That was the point, she thought. That had become the general point of him.

Ishbel, bless her, stood up and said there would be tea in the foyer and the companion short would run again at nine, and asked people to move in an orderly fashion, and it was over.

They sat while the room emptied around them. Ewan stood up, stiffly, and looked at the two of them and the joined hands and said nothing at all about it, which from Ewan was a speech.

"I'll get the door," he said, and went.

The three lancet windows had gone dark with evening. Out beyond the river there were lights on the far bank and someone's dog barking at nothing. Fenn turned her hand over slowly under Callum's, so their palms met, and he closed his fingers then.

"You could have stopped at no," he said, very quietly.

"I could have."

"You didn't."

"No."

He was silent a moment. Then he said, "I'd have understood."

"I know," she said. "That's the trouble with you."

He laughed once, mostly through his nose, and for some reason that was the thing that made her eyes sting — not the question, not the two hundred faces, but Callum MacLeòid laughing quietly in a deconsecrated church with her hand in his, six days out from an inspection, with a bay behind them that was still not clean.

"Come on," she said. "Tea. Ishbel will come looking."

They got up. Her hand stayed in his until they reached the aisle, because the aisle was public and there would be time. There would be a drive north and a meeting with a compliance officer and a document in a drawer in Inverness that nobody had yet opened, and a release form still unsigned in a van somewhere, and a light in a tower that had six weeks left before it was switched off for good. All of that was still true.

But the film was finished, and the room had heard her, and nobody had stood up and told her she was lying, which meant the truth was now simply the story, out loud, and it could be carried.

At the door to the foyer, with the tea already steaming and Ishbel already waving at them, Callum let go of her hand and put his shoulder against the heavy wood and held the door, and she walked through it in front of him.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 85: The Finished Film · The Lightkeeper's Fiancée · Lumen Reads