The Long Polar Night

Chapter 63: Confronting the Past

The office smelled of old paper and pipe tobacco, though Erik doubted anyone had smoked in it for twenty years. Dr. Halvard Ness stood at the window with his back to them, watching the harbor lights tremble on the black water. He was smaller than Erik remembered—an old man in a cardigan, not the giant who had sat at their kitchen table arguing with his father about the isotope ratios of the Svalbard cores.

"You're Jorgen's boy," Ness said, without turning. "You have his voice. I heard you on the stairs before I saw you."

"Dr. Ness." Erik's hands were cold. He had not taken off his coat. Beside him, Martin stayed a half step back, quiet, letting him lead. "Thank you for seeing us on a Sunday."

"I don't get many visitors who want to talk about your father." Ness finally turned. His eyes were clear, unclouded. "You want the 1998 data. The Nordfjord transect."

"Yes."

"Then it's not a social call." Ness shuffled to his desk and sat down heavily. "Sit. Both of you. Who's this?"

"Martin Aas. I'm a colleague of Erik's."

"Meteorologist," Ness said. It wasn't a question. "I read your dust-deposition papers. Good work. Wasted on a weather man."

"Halvard," Erik said, and the first name came out before he could stop it, because his father had always used it, "I've spent six months with the original logs. The core data in the 1998 paper doesn't match the field sheets. The benthic foram ratios are off by a factor that isn't drift or contamination. It's not an error. Somebody changed the numbers."

Ness looked at him for a long moment. Then he opened a drawer, took out a manila folder swollen with age, and set it on the desk between them.

"I was wondering when someone would come," he said.

Erik's mouth went dry. "You knew."

"I suspected. I was the second author. I never saw the raw sheets until after publication." Ness tapped the folder. "That's a copy of the correspondence. Your father was under pressure. The Norwegian Research Council had already turned him down twice. The Nordfjord grant was going to fund the lab for three years, and the preliminary numbers were weak—the signal was there but it was soft, a few tenths of a per mil, well within the noise of what we could measure then. He wanted it stronger."

"So he made it stronger," Erik said.

"He made it *cleaner.* That's the word he used, in here." Ness opened the folder and slid a single sheet across the desk. Erik recognized his father's handwriting immediately—small, precise, left-handed slant. *Cleaned to remove obvious drift artifacts. H. agrees the underlying trend is robust.* "I didn't agree. That's a lie he wrote in my name. I told him so. We didn't speak for two years after that."

Martin leaned in, reading the page over Erik's shoulder. "The paper's been cited four hundred times. It's the foundation of half the Nordfjord literature."

"It is." Ness's voice was flat. "And it's wrong. Not catastrophically—God knows the trend probably is real, we just couldn't prove it then. But the numbers are fabricated. Erik." He waited until Erik looked up. "Your father wasn't a fraud. He was a frightened man with a mortgage and a lab full of people depending on him, and he made one decision he spent the rest of his life regretting. He asked me to co-sign a corrigendum in 2006. I refused. I was still angry. He died in 2019 with it unpublished."

Erik sat very still. Somewhere below, a ferry horn sounded, long and mournful, the sound of Tromsø at night.

"He asked you," Erik said.

"He did. And I said no." Ness closed the folder. "That's my failure, not his. I've had eleven years to think about it. You can have the folder. There's a full draft of the corrigendum in there, his version and the one I should have helped him write."

"I need to publish it," Erik said. The words came out steady, which surprised him. "His name's on the paper. So is yours. If the data's fabricated, the record needs to say so, and it needs to say so while somebody who was there can still vouch for the correction."

Ness looked at him for a long moment, and something in the old man's face loosened, like ice letting go of a rock.

"Your father would have hated that," he said. "You know that. He'd have called it a betrayal."

"Yes."

"And you're going to do it anyway."

"Yes."

Ness nodded slowly, twice. "Then I'll co-sign. Send me whatever you draft. I'm eighty-one, I don't have the stamina to write it, but I'll put my name to it and I'll say the same thing in writing to whatever journal you choose."

Erik stood. His legs felt strange, as if he had been sitting for hours rather than twenty minutes. He picked up the folder—heavier than it looked.

"Thank you, Halvard."

"Don't thank me. I should have done this in 2006." Ness didn't get up. He turned back to the window, and his reflection floated in the glass, thin and gray above the lights of the harbor. "Erik. He was proud of you. That's the thing I never got to tell you at the funeral. Whatever else he was, he was proud of you. He told me so the last time we spoke."

Erik didn't trust his voice. He nodded, and Martin's hand found the small of his back, warm through the coat, and they left.

They walked back along the waterfront without speaking. The wind came off the fjord with a knifing edge, and the streetlights haloed in the sea mist. Erik held the folder against his chest like something that might blow away.

"Are you all right?" Martin finally said.

"No." Erik stopped at the railing and looked at the water. "I've spent my whole career trying not to be him. Trying to be—proper. Careful. To never put a number in a table I couldn't defend. And the whole time the man who taught me that was the one who didn't."

"He taught you wrong, then. Or he taught you right and couldn't live up to it himself." Martin leaned on the railing beside him, close but not crowding. "Those aren't the same thing."

"No. They're not."

The mist beaded on the folder. Erik thought about the abstract in his bag, the oral session on Thursday, the eight days left on the grant. He thought about the hall in Oslo and his father's name on the moderator's card, and about what it would mean to stand up at the Arctic Marine Systems meeting forty-eight hours before his corrigendum hit the preprint server, and say, in front of his father's old colleagues, that the foundation of the Nordfjord literature was built on a lie—and that he had found it, and that he was fixing it.

"Martin," he said. "I have to tell you something about Oslo."

"I figured." Martin's voice was gentle. "You've been carrying it since the station. I gave you the canister and you nearly cried, and then you went quiet for a week. Who's chairing your session?"

"My father."

Martin didn't flinch. He turned to face Erik, and the light from the streetlamp caught the gray in his beard, the fine lines at the corners of his eyes. "J. Solberg. The moderator's J. Solberg."

"Jorgen. Yes." Erik watched the water. "He's not dead, Martin. I said he was dead. I let you believe it. He emailed me three weeks before we left the station and told me he'd been asked to chair it, as if it were a courtesy, as if he thought I'd be pleased. I haven't answered him."

"Why did you say he was dead?"

"Because it was easier than explaining that he isn't." Erik's hands tightened on the railing. "That he's alive and he's still disappointed and I still can't make him stop."

The wind moved between them. Martin was quiet for a long time.

"Okay," he said finally.

"Okay?"

"I'm not going to lie to you and say that's fine, because you lied to me and I get to be angry about it later. Right now I'm just—" Martin exhaled, and his breath hung white in the cold. "Right now I'm standing next to a man who just decided to correct his dead father's scientific record in public, three days before he has to present his own work under that father's moderation, and I'm supposed to be upset that the father is alive? Erik." He shook his head, and something almost like a laugh escaped him. "You're not the man who lies to make things easier. You're the man who tears up the foundation to put the record straight. I've watched you do it all winter. I just didn't know the foundation was personal."

Erik's throat closed. He looked at Martin, at the folder in his arms, at the black water and the lights, and for the first time in years he felt the weight of what he was carrying—and also, unmistakably, under it, something clean. A floor. Something to stand on.

"I'm going to lose access," he said. "The Nordfjord group will blacklist me. My father will never speak to me again. The grant—"

"The grant's ours. We wrote it on the ship. It doesn't cite the 1998 paper." Martin reached out and closed one hand over Erik's on the railing, cold fingers over cold fingers, and didn't let go. "And when the corrigendum publishes, the Arctic Marine Systems people are going to be reading it in the same week as your father's session. That's not a problem, Erik. That's the whole point. You fix the record in the same room where the record was made. Nobody's ever had a better stage."

Erik looked down at their hands. Then he looked up, at the dark fjord, at the faint green shimmer of aurora just beginning to unspool behind the clouds to the north.

"Okay," he said. "Let's write it tonight. The corrigendum and the talk. Both of them, one draft, and whatever falls, it falls."

Martin nodded and let go, and they turned together toward the hotel, and the folder was warm under Erik's arm, and he walked the whole length of the waterfront without once thinking about what his father would say.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.