The Market of Borrowed Names

Chapter 32: The Councillor's Deal

Cabra at eight in the evening smelled of chip fat and wet leaves. Maeve sat in her car across from the clinic with the engine off and the heater ticking as it cooled, watching the last of the staff leave. Cian Doyle's rooms were above a pharmacy, a brass plaque polished to a smug shine: *Dr. Cian Doyle, MB, BCh, BAO. Counselling & Psychotherapy by Appointment.*

She'd been there since half six. He'd left at seven, walked to the Spar on the corner, bought a roll of mints, walked back. No shoeboxes under the arm. No black hawthorn petals falling out of his pockets. Just a man in a good coat with a bad habit.

He came out again at ten past eight and went to the side door, the one that fed the stairs. Maeve got out of the car.

"Councillor."

He stopped with the key in the lock. He didn't turn, and that told her more than anything he could have said. He'd known. The whole time, since the depot, since Aoife, since the lawyer who had never existed, he'd known the shape of the thing coming for him, and here it was, and he wasn't surprised.

"Ms. O'Callaghan." He turned. Grey at the temples, decent suit, the sort of face people voted for. "It's late."

"It is." She stopped six feet away and kept her hands where he could see them, because men like Cian liked to think they were the reasonable party in any room. "I've a photograph of you at the canal gate handing a list to a man who isn't a man. Four names on it. One of them was Nuala Brennan, Dorset Street. One of them was my mother."

The lock clicked. He opened the door and stood in the light of the stairs like a man on a stage, and for a moment she thought he'd go up and shut it in her face. Instead he said, "Come in. Not here. Inside."

His office was two rooms and a kettle. Certificates on the wall, a leather couch that had been sat on by a lot of other people's misery, a desk with a laptop closed and squared. He didn't offer her tea. He sat behind the desk, which put her on the couch, and she took the chair instead, the hard one, and turned it so her back wasn't to the door. He noticed. He was noticing everything - it was the first thing about him that felt honest.

"You want to know why," he said.

"I want to know why I shouldn't put you in a photograph on the front of the *Inquirer* on Friday morning."

"Because it won't run." He said it flatly, no pleasure. "Or it will run, and the next day your journalist will be told she never wrote it. Or her editor will be, which is worse. You've already seen it happen. That lawyer. What was his name?"

"Cian." She held his eyes. "You tell me."

Something went out of his face. Just a flicker, then back. "I don't know the mechanism. I want that on the record, whatever record you're keeping. I don't know how it works or why it works and I've stopped asking."

"But you know it does."

"I know it does."

Maeve sat back. The chair creaked. "Then start with the first name. And how you tell yourself you sleep."

He looked out the window at the street and said, "I was elected in 2009. Do you know what a first-term councillor runs on? Nothing. You run on being present. You run on showing up. And then you're in, and every good thing you want to do - the shelter, the addiction services, the wraparound for the women on the canal - needs money, and the money isn't there, and the men who control the money look at you like you're a child asking for sweets."

"So you found a different lender."

"I found a market." He said the word carefully, and for a moment he was just a tired man in a bad chair. "I didn't go looking. It found me. Someone left a card in the clinic letterbox - a name, an address that isn't on any map, and a line that said *we fund public goods*. I went. I was curious. Everyone's curious until they're not."

"And you traded."

"I traded names," he said, and the flatness came back, and it was almost worse than if he'd wept. "Names of women who were - gone from themselves anyway. Already walking through their own lives like it was a rented room. Addicts. Women living rough on the canal. Women who'd have told you, if you'd asked them at the right hour on the right day, that they'd rather not exist at all. That's what I put on paper. Not the names. The willingness. I offered the transaction, and the market took it, and money appeared in accounts I could direct without my fingerprints on them, and I built the shelter on Capel Street and the halfway house on the North Circular, and you know how many women went through those doors last year? Four hundred and sixty."

"Did you tell any of them what it cost?"

"No."

"Did any of them survive your shelter and then get taken anyway?"

He didn't answer that. Which was an answer.

Maeve leaned forward. "Your mother's name on that list, Cian? Anyone you loved? Or is it only the women who were already halfway through the wall?"

"You've got no idea," he said, sudden heat, "what it's like to be handed a way to do good that nobody else would ever give you, and to know the price, and to pay it, and to watch it work. You want me to be a monster because it's easier than the other thing."

"What's the other thing?"

"That it works." He stood up. "That the shelter is full and the canvas is full of women who'd be dead otherwise by now, and I built it with names the world was already doing its best to forget. That's the other thing, Ms. O'Callaghan. That's what you're coming up against, so bring better than a photographer."

Maeve stood too. She'd heard enough. "I don't want to expose you for the shelter. I want to expose you for the four names on that paper and the twelve on Róisín's map, including a woman called Sinéad O'Callaghan who disappeared outside a Spar on Dorset Street in 2009 while raising a daughter your age, and who I am going to bring back or die trying. Can you be useful, or are you just going to be another man who tells me the market is bigger than me?"

He was quiet for a long moment. Then: "I can't help you. And I'll tell you why, because you'll hear it from someone worse than me otherwise. If you push on this, they'll take the rest. Not just you. The girl who drives you. The old woman in your office. The journalist. The lawyer's already gone. They'll unmake every person who touched the story, and they'll do it kindly, and no one will remember to miss them." He picked up the laptop, tucked it under his arm. "I'm telling you this because I've watched it happen, and I'd like you to stop."

"Tell me who the Ledger is."

"No."

"Tell me the market's address."

"No."

"Is there anything you're going to do other than threaten me in a nice room?"

He looked at her then, and for one second the decent face cracked, and under it was something hollow and old, and he said, very quietly, "Ms. O'Callaghan. I've been waiting for someone to come to this office for sixteen years." He walked past her to the door. "That should tell you everything about whether I'm the one who started this."

He was gone before she got her coat on, down the stairs and out the side door, and she didn't chase him, because chasing him wasn't the point. She stood in the empty office with the certificates on the wall and the couch that had held other people's misery and thought: *he's right about one thing. They'll come for everyone.*

She took out her phone and looked at the photograph. Cian at the canal gate, the dark figure who wasn't a man, the four names on a piece of paper, one of them Nuala Brennan's. The lawyer who'd tried to authenticate it was gone. Aoife's assistant didn't remember him. The tin on Maeve's desk had a hawthorn petal crawling toward the centre of the table, and it would not stop, and something on the other side of the counter was already deciding how to deal with Friday.

Fine. Let it decide.

She walked out to the car and sat in the cold dark and did the arithmetic. Escalating to the public record wasn't enough on its own; the market edited the record. But there was one place the record couldn't be edited, which was the inside of people's heads, and that's how it had kept the women for sixteen years. Which meant the way to bring Cian down wasn't to prove him a criminal in a court that could be unwritten. It was to prove him a liar in front of the two hundred people he'd built his name on - every woman who'd come through his shelters, every volunteer, every voter in Cabra who thought Dr. Cian Doyle was the only honest man left.

Two hundred people remembering his voice, and every one of them picturing the same four names.

Maeve started the engine. "Right," she said to no one, and pulled out into the wet Cabra night. "Let's see what the market does when it has to erase a whole room instead of just one lawyer at a time."

Then her phone lit on the passenger seat, and the name on the screen was Niamh's, and it was a quarter to eleven, and Niamh never called after nine.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 32: The Councillor's Deal · The Market of Borrowed Names · Lumen Reads