The Market of Borrowed Names

Chapter 52: The Trial

The canal at Grand Canal Dock had been emptied of water.

Not drained — emptied. The surface sat a foot below the quay stones and held perfectly still, a black mirror that refused to ripple when the wind came off the Liffey. Someone had strung lights along the lock gates, warm and festival-bright, and by eight o'clock there were cameras: two from RTÉ, one from a Danish documentary crew that had been circling Niamh for a week, and about forty phones belonging to people who had heard something was happening and had come to watch it happen.

Maeve stood on the north bank with Iona at her left and Niamh at her right, and she counted the jury.

Thirteen. They sat on the far quay on chairs that had not been there an hour ago — folding chairs, ordinary ones, the kind you'd get from a hardware shop — and every one of them was beautiful in a way that made your eyes slide off. She had learned to look at their hands instead. Hands gave them away: too many fingers, or not enough, or knuckles in the wrong places. The Weaver sat at the end of the row, palms flat on its knees, wearing the shape of a woman in a green wool coat who might have been anyone's aunt.

The book sat open on a lectern between the banks, and it was the book that decided what the city saw. Maeve understood that now. She had watched the first witness speak for six minutes and seen the RTÉ feed show her saying something else entirely.

The fae who presided wore the shape of a barrister, grey wig and all, and its voice carried without amplification.

"You may call your first witness."

"I call the names," Maeve said.

A murmur. The barrister-shaped thing tilted its head. "The names are the accused. You cannot call them."

"Then I'll call what's left of them." Maeve stepped to the water's edge and took out Cian's slate card. It was hot in her pocket, ticking like a slow watch, and when she held it up the canal went denser, the black surface thickening into something you could almost stand on. "Bríd Ní Mhurchú. Forty-one. Midwife at the Rotunda for nineteen years."

The water moved.

Not far — a hand's width, near the south quay — but it moved, and the reflection in it changed, and for about four seconds every camera in the place showed the same image: a woman in scrubs, laughing, holding a newborn up in a delivery room, and a nurse beside her saying, *Bríd, look at her, look at her face.*

The reflection flickered out.

"Objection." The barrister did not raise its voice. "Sentiment is not evidence."

"Everything about a person is evidence," Maeve said. "That's the whole point of a person."

Iona had the folder. She opened it and read without looking down at the page, because she had spent two nights learning it by heart.

"Bríd delivered four hundred and six babies," Iona said. "She lent money she didn't have. She wrote birthday cards to people she hadn't spoken to in years. On the fourteenth of March she sat with a woman called Aoife Dunne in a hospital corridor for six hours and didn't say a word, because Aoife wasn't ready to hear anything yet." She paused. "Aoife's baby lived. She's two now. She'll never know why the midwife took her shift off."

One of the jury — a young one, wearing the shape of a teenager in a Dublin GAA jacket — shifted in its chair.

"Next," Maeve said. "Sinéad Bracken. Thirty-three. She ran a coffee cart on Suffolk Street."

The water stirred again. The cameras saw a woman handing a cup across a counter, laughing at something, wiping down a machine at half past five in the morning in the dark.

"She kept a list of regulars who couldn't always pay and never wrote down what they owed," Niamh said. "There were eleven names on that list. She knew all eleven birthdays."

The barrister-shaped thing let its gaze travel along the jury. Two of them had turned their heads. Four had not. One — a fae in the shape of an old man with a stick — had closed its eyes, which Maeve could not read as either contempt or patience.

"Third," Maeve said. "Ruth Okafor. Twenty-nine. Hospice orderly."

Something in the jury moved, quick and involuntary, and Maeve filed it away. She kept going. She called eleven of them: the hospice orderly and the secondary-school teacher and the woman who did the accounts for a boxing club and the two sisters who ran a laundry and the girl who was nineteen and had been gone three weeks, whose mother was standing on the north quay right now with her hands over her mouth, watching the water show her daughter's face and never hearing a word of what Niamh said about her.

That was the cruelty of the book, and Maeve had known it going in. The jury heard everything. The families got the faces and nothing else.

By the ninth name the barrister had stopped objecting. By the eleventh, the canal was showing images without being asked — a corner of a kitchen, a bus stop, a hand reaching for another hand — and the crowd had gone quiet in the way crowds do when they have forgotten they came to be entertained.

Then the old man with the stick opened his eyes.

"You are building a case for the value of the individual," he said. "We concede the individuals were valuable. The vault's accounts have never disputed that."

"Then what are you disputing?"

"That value is not the question." He leaned forward. "The question is ownership. When a woman gives her name freely, in a moment of extremity, with full knowledge of what she surrenders — she is not stolen. She is spent. We did not take Sinéad Bracken. Sinéad Bracken bought her son's chemotherapy with herself."

The crowd made a noise. Somewhere on the south quay someone started to clap, once, and stopped.

Maeve felt Niamh go still beside her.

"Síle," Niamh said quietly. "Sinéad's sister. She's here. I didn't think she'd —"

Sinéad. Not Síle. Maeve turned her head a quarter inch and saw, on the north quay, a woman in a grey anorak with her hood half up, and she understood in one second what was about to happen, and she could not stop it, because there was no way to stop anything in a hearing where the book decided what the city saw.

The woman stepped forward.

"I want to speak," Síle Bracken said.

The barrister-shaped thing looked at her with an expression that was almost kind. "You may."

"My sister's boy is fourteen," Síle said. Her voice carried — the book took it and magnified it, and Maeve knew, she *knew*, the book was choosing its moment. "He's in remission. He's been in remission since he was nine. He thinks his mother walked out on him." She swallowed. "He's had five years of thinking that, and last week he told me he doesn't want to hear her name in the house. And now you're going to tell me she *chose* it?"

"Yes," the old fae said.

"Then where's the receipt?" Síle said.

The jury went silent.

"Where's the receipt?" she said again, louder. "If she bought something, there's a price on a page somewhere. If she signed something, I want to see the signature. If she gave herself away — and Christ knows she was the sort to, she'd have given herself away for any of us, that's who she was — then she signed it in her own hand and I want to *read it*."

"That is not how the ledger is kept."

"Then it's not a sale," Síle said. "It's a theft with paperwork."

The book snapped shut.

Maeve heard it — an audible slam, though no hand touched it — and the canal went smooth and empty and the images of the eleven women vanished out of the water as if a plug had been pulled. Somewhere behind her a phone screen went black. The RTÉ camera operator swore and started pressing buttons.

"Recess," the barrister said.

"No," said the Weaver.

It had not moved, and it did not raise its voice, but thirteen of the fourteen fae on that jury turned to look at it and the barrister-shaped thing went still in a way that had nothing human in it.

"The objection stands," the Weaver said. "Not the objection to sentiment. The objection to the books." It stood up. In the green wool coat, in the cold, it was so ordinary that it took a second to remember it was not. "The vault has produced no instrument of transfer for a single name it holds. I have sat in this court for two hours and watched eleven mortals establish that their people existed, and I have watched this court answer with an argument about *ownership* that it has never once been asked to prove."

"You overstep," the barrister said.

"I am the Weaver," it said. "It is my function to notice when a thread is missing."

It looked, then, at Maeve.

"Ask for the documents," it said. "Under our law, a hearing cannot close without the instruments. If they cannot produce them by sundown tomorrow, the vault opens."

The barrister-shaped thing said nothing for a long moment. Then it said, "The instruments are in the market."

"Then produce them in the market," the Weaver said. "Tomorrow, at the market, in open court. Or admit that the vault holds names it never lawfully received."

The jury broke without a vote. The crowd had begun to talk, and the cameras were back, and Síle Bracken was standing at the water's edge looking at her own reflection as if it owed her an answer.

Maeve walked to the Weaver before it could leave the row of chairs.

"Tomorrow," she said. "What happens tomorrow?"

"The market will not open the vault on a technicality," the Weaver said. "They will find a way to make the books appear. And if they cannot, they will change the law instead of losing." It glanced at the crowd on the quays. "You have eleven women's faces in every phone on this bank and none of their names. That is the shape of the problem."

"Then tell me the shape of the solution."

"You need the city to say the names," the Weaver said. "All of them. Out loud. If enough mortals acknowledge the missing, the rule that hides them cannot hold — the market is bound by acknowledgment. It is the one clause they cannot argue with."

Maeve looked at the crowd. Forty people. Fifty, maybe, drifting in along the quay for the lights.

"Fifty won't do it."

"No," the Weaver said. "It won't."

It turned up its collar against the wind and started walking north, and its voice came back over the water as flat as the canal, as ordinary as a woman in a wool coat giving directions to a stranger.

"So you'd better make a great many more than fifty people want to know who Síle Bracken's sister was."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 52: The Trial · The Market of Borrowed Names · Lumen Reads