The Memory Broker

Chapter 57: The Settlement

The settlement conference was held in a windowless room on the nineteenth floor of the federal building, and Rebecca had expected something like a trial. Instead there were eight people around a laminate table, a court reporter, and a mediator with a voice trained to absorb anger.

Aisha sat at the head. Rebecca sat beside her, and the class counsel sat across from Elysium's new general counsel, a woman named Preeti Raman who had been hired three weeks ago and had the exhausted look of someone who had inherited a house fire.

They had been at it for ninety minutes.

"Fifty million," Preeti said, sliding a term sheet across the table. "Class-wide. Full deletion of all simulation data, all backups, all derivatives, certified by an independent forensic auditor within sixty days. Release of all claims, civil and administrative."

Aisha picked up the sheet and read it without expression. She had been up until two, Rebecca knew, going through the numbers. There were one thousand four hundred and six people in the class. That came to about thirty-five thousand dollars apiece before fees.

"That's thin," Aisha said.

"It's the number the board authorized."

"Then the board authorized a thin number."

Rebecca looked down at her own copy. Fourteen hundred people. She thought about the names she had read in the deposition exhibits. The accountant in Daly City who had talked to her dead son every night for four years. The woman in Fresno who had stopped going to work. The twelve who had died in 2005, whose families were here as a separate subclass.

"Aisha," she said quietly. "Can I say something?"

Aisha turned her head. "You're the named plaintiff. You can say anything you want."

Rebecca looked at Preeti. "I'm not going to argue about the money."

"Good," Preeti said, and something in her shoulders loosened.

"I'm going to argue about everything else." Rebecca pulled the term sheet toward her and turned it over, writing on the back with a pen she borrowed from the mediator. "Three things. One: a public apology, read into the record here and posted on Elysium's website for the life of the company. Not a non-admission of liability. An actual apology. With the words negligent and the words we harmed people in it."

Preeti's face didn't move. "Non-admission is standard."

"I know it's standard. I'm telling you it isn't happening."

"Two?"

"A memorial fund. Two million dollars, administered by an independent board, for the families of the twelve subjects who died under the second-input protocol. Not a settlement payment. A fund, named after them. With their names on it."

The mediator made a note. Preeti said nothing.

"Three: three million into independent memory ethics research. Not Elysium's own lab. An academic consortium, peer-reviewed, open access. Twenty years from now I want there to be papers about this that weren't written by the people who did it."

Silence. Preeti looked at her lawyer, who shrugged minutely.

"That's nine million on top of fifty," Preeti said.

"That's nine million on top of fifty," Rebecca agreed. "And in exchange, I will personally appear at the fairness hearing and tell the court this is a good settlement. I will not give interviews saying it was too small. I will not encourage anyone to opt out. You know why that matters?"

"I know why it matters," Preeti said.

"Then we understand each other."

They broke for twenty minutes. Rebecca stood by the window looking at a parking structure and the gray slice of the bay beyond it, and Aisha came to stand beside her.

"You did well in there," Aisha said.

"I don't feel like I did well. I feel like I just put a price on my mother."

"No," Aisha said. "You didn't. You left the file. That was the price, and you didn't pay it." She paused. "I need to tell you something, though. If they come back at fifty-five total and refuse the apology, I'm going to advise you to take it. The class needs the deletion more than it needs the words. Deletion is the only thing that stops it from happening again."

"I know."

"Do you?"

"Yes," Rebecca said. "I hate it, but I know."

Preeti came back with sixty-one million, the fund, the research money, and an apology with the word negligent in it, which she said had required a call to the chair of the board and which she had made while standing in the hallway. Aisha read it three times.

The apology was read into the record at 4:15 that afternoon. Preeti read it herself, standing, and Rebecca watched her mouth form the words and thought about how strange it was that a corporation could be made to say sorry by a woman who didn't work there a month ago, and how the saying didn't heal anything, and how it still mattered, somehow, anyway.

The settlement was approved by the judge eleven days later. The class notice went out the same afternoon.

The check came by courier six weeks after that, in a stiff envelope from the settlement administrator. Rebecca signed for it at her door and stood in the hallway looking at the number.

Eighty-nine thousand four hundred dollars. Her share, after fees and the subclass allocation.

She brought it inside and put it on the kitchen counter and did not open it again for two hours. Then she did the arithmetic on the back of an envelope of her own, the way she used to do it in the bad years, when the card interest compounded and she had learned to be afraid of her own mail.

Sixty thousand to the memorial fund. That left twenty-nine thousand four hundred. David's loan had been twenty-two thousand, plus the four she'd borrowed when the car died, plus whatever interest he'd refused to take.

She called him on a Tuesday evening.

"Hey," she said. "Are you home?"

"I'm home. Why do you sound like that?"

"Like what?"

"Like you're about to tell me something and you're nervous about it."

She laughed, one short breath. "Can I come over? I have a check for you."

There was a pause. "Rebecca."

"I'm not asking. I'm telling you. It's been four years and it's eating me."

"Come over," he said.

He had left the porch light on. She came up the steps with the envelope and he opened the door before she knocked, wearing a shirt with a stain on the sleeve and holding a spatula.

"You're cooking," she said.

"I'm attempting to. Sit down, I have ten minutes on the pan."

She sat at the kitchen table, which was his parents' table, the one with the cigarette burn near the edge. He'd told her once it had been there since before he was born.

She slid the envelope across. He looked inside it, and then he looked at her, and his face did something complicated.

"You paid the fund first," he said. It wasn't a question.

"How did you know?"

"You did the math on the back of the envelope and it's still on the envelope. I can see it from here." He set the spatula down. "Sixty thousand. That's most of it."

"It's not most of it. It's — "

"It's most of it."

She looked at the table. "I couldn't take money that came from those twelve families and use it to pay you back. It felt like laundering it."

He was quiet for a moment. Then he sat down across from her and folded his hands.

"When Dad died I was twenty-six," he said. "You remember what I did with the life insurance?"

"You paid off the house."

"I paid off the house." He nodded. "And then I sat in that house for a year and I couldn't figure out why I didn't feel better. Because I thought money was going to be the thing that made it even. And it wasn't. It's never the thing." He tapped the envelope. "This is the thing that made it even for you, but it isn't the money. It's that you kept me on the books for four years while I did nothing to earn it and you never once made me feel like I was your project."

"You weren't my project."

"I know," he said. "That's why I let you pay me back."

He stood up and went back to the stove and flipped something over. It smelled like garlic and burnt butter. He said, over his shoulder, "Sam coming?"

"He's coming at seven. I told him to bring wine."

"Good. Because I bought two bottles and I don't want to drink them alone." He turned and pointed the spatula at her. "And you're not going to sit there all night being solemn about it. We're going to eat and we're going to be normal, because that's what you never got to do in the bad years. Deal?"

"Deal," she said.

The doorbell rang at 7:02. Sam came in with two bottles under his arm and a bouquet of grocery-store flowers that he handed to Rebecca without ceremony, and David made fun of the flowers for eleven consecutive minutes while the pasta overfilled the pot. Rebecca sat at the table with her hands wrapped around a glass and listened to them argue, and did not think about her mother, or the file, or the twelve names on the memorial fund. That, she was learning, was a skill. You practiced it.

They ate. They drank both bottles. At some point David said something about the fundraiser the newsroom was doing for laid-off reporters and Sam went quiet in a way Rebecca noticed but didn't push on. She put her hand on his knee under the table. He covered it with his own.

Later, at the door, David hugged her for a long time.

"You're going to do something now," he said into her hair. "I can tell. You're doing the face."

"What face?"

"The face where the design won't resolve yet."

She laughed and pulled back. "I hate that you know me."

"I love that I know you," he said. "Go home. Call me when it resolves."

In the car, Sam was quiet for three blocks.

"You okay?" she said.

"David mentioned the fundraiser."

"I noticed."

"They're trying to buy out the paper. Some investment group." He looked out the window. "They've offered voluntary buyouts to the whole newsroom and they want an answer by Friday."

Rebecca kept her eyes on the road. "Do you want to take it?"

"No," he said. "I want to write the book. And I've been scared to say that out loud because it feels like quitting." He turned to look at her. "There's an office. Four hundred square feet, on Valencia, above the bakery. Lease starts the first of next month."

She pulled the car to the curb and put it in park and turned to face him.

"Sam."

"I know we haven't talked about it."

"I've been sketching it for three weeks," Rebecca said. "I have drawings in my bag right now. I've been too scared to show you because I didn't know if it was real yet."

He laughed, once, disbelieving. "Show me."

She reached into the back seat and pulled her bag forward.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 57: The Settlement · The Memory Broker · Lumen Reads