The Memory Broker

Chapter 73: The Reconciliation

They met at the Java Detour on Noriega, two blocks from the house, because neither of them had been back in twenty years and neither wanted to be the first to stand on the sidewalk alone.

David was already there when Rebecca pushed through the door, hunched over a drip coffee he wasn't drinking, his phone face-down on the table like he didn't trust it. He looked up. Something in his face had loosened since the letter — not healed, exactly, but unclenched.

"You ordered?" he asked.

"I lived three blocks from here for eighteen years. I know what the coffee tastes like."

"That's not an answer."

She sat down across from him. "Small black. I ordered at the counter. It's coming."

He nodded and went back to not drinking his coffee. Outside, a Muni bus wheezed past, and the windows rattled the way she remembered, a shiver that ran through the whole room.

"I walked by it first," David said. "Before you got here. I didn't go in. I don't know why I told you that."

"Because you want me to know you didn't cheat."

"Something like that."

The barista set down her cup. Rebecca wrapped both hands around it and looked at her brother. He was fifty-two now. She kept forgetting that. In her head he was still the kid who'd built towers out of her wooden blocks and then knocked them down laughing, the one she'd been jealous of and protective of in the same breath, in no particular order.

"I want to do this properly," she said. "I don't want to just stand there and narrate."

"Properly how?"

"I don't know. Talk first. Then walk."

So they talked. It came out crooked and out of order, the way it always did. David remembered a summer when their mother had taken them to Ocean Beach and a fog had rolled in so thick they'd lost each other for nine minutes — he swore it was nine, he'd counted — and when Lian found them she hadn't been angry, she'd just sat down in the sand and cried, and neither of them had understood why. Rebecca had no memory of that at all. She remembered a different beach day, sun the whole time, their mother wearing a hat with a ribbon.

"That's not the same day," David said.

"I know it's not."

"Then why do we remember different lives?"

"Because we had different mothers," Rebecca said. "That's the thing I keep coming back to. She was a different person to each of us. Not because she was lying. Because we needed different things from her."

David was quiet for a minute. "That's generous."

"It's true."

"It's generous." He turned his cup a quarter-turn. "You know what I remember more than anything? Being in the room when you did things. I'd be in the doorway. You'd be at the table doing something, and Ma would be leaning over you — not helping, just watching like you were the interesting one — and I'd stand there and think, *when's it my turn.*"

Rebecca didn't say anything.

"I'm not saying you did it," he said. "That's the part I've had to figure out. It wasn't a competition you entered. It was one I entered. I put myself in second place and then resented you for winning."

"How long did you carry that?"

"About thirty years."

"David."

"I know." He laughed, one short exhale. "I got it out in pieces. When I moved east. When Ma got sick. When she died and you were the one who handled the paperwork because you were the one she'd listed second on the emergency form. I sat with that for a long time."

"I didn't know that."

"You weren't supposed to. That's what 'second on the form' means."

Rebecca looked down into her cup. Something in her chest had gone tight and hot. "I was jealous of you too," she said. "You want to hear it?"

David raised his eyebrows. "Yes."

"You could leave. You left. You went to Boston and became a person who wasn't her daughter. I stayed. I stayed in the city and I stayed *hers* and I never got to be anything that wasn't downstream of her. So I did the thing where I made myself the good one. So I could earn it. Because I couldn't leave, so I had to be worthy of staying."

David set his cup down. Neither of them said anything for a while. The barista wiped the counter. Someone's phone buzzed and stopped.

"So we're both idiots," David said.

"We're both loyal," Rebecca said. "To the wrong versions of the same person."

"That's a nicer way to say the same thing."

"I'm a designer. Nicer words are my whole job."

He grinned, and it was the old grin, the tower-building one, and Rebecca felt something in her own face answer it before she'd decided to.

They left the café and walked up Noriega with the fog coming in off the ocean, thin and silver. She knew the route without thinking. Left on Forty-fifth. Two blocks to the house. The houses were the same as they'd always been — pastel, flat-faced, tucked shoulder to shoulder, each with its own small garden fighting the salt air. Some of the paint had changed. The lavender house was now a pale green. The plum tree on the corner was gone.

Then the house. Forty-eighth and Kirkham. Theirs had a low wall in front, always had, and a garage with a small window, and a second-floor bay window where Rebecca used to sit on the floor and read.

There was a car in the driveway she didn't recognize. Lights on in the front room. Someone's jacket draped over the rail.

"It looks smaller," David said.

"Everything looks smaller."

"I keep waiting for something to unlock. Like the wall would give it up. Some kind of— I don't know, a feeling that arrives."

"It's a house," Rebecca said. "The feeling's not in the house."

She could see it then — not a memory, but a shape. The way her mother used to stand at that window with a cup of tea, watching the street. The way David used to run up those steps two at a time. The way the front door had this exact squeak, and how her mother had never fixed it, saying it told her when her children came home.

She could remember all of that. What she couldn't remember: what her mother had said, the last time she stood on this sidewalk before leaving for good. The date. The conversation. The who of it. It was just gone.

"I don't remember leaving," she said. "The last time I stood here as a kid. I know I did. I know the dates. I can't find the moment."

"I don't remember it either," David said. "My last time here was in '99. I packed the car and I drove and I didn't look back and I've got nothing. No image. No words."

"Is that okay?"

"I think it has to be." He looked up at the bay window. "Do you want the truth? I don't miss her the way I used to. I miss the idea of getting to go in that door and have it be nothing. Just — come home from school and there's a sandwich. Not a reckoning. A sandwich."

Rebecca laughed. "There was that birthday."

"What birthday?"

"The one with the — the ice cream cake? The cake that Ma dropped on the way out of the car?"

David's face went blank, then cracked. "Oh God."

"You were eight. You screamed. She screamed back. It was on the driveway. Forty-eighth and Kirkham, right out front, chocolate on the sidewalk."

"The neighbors came out."

"The *neighbors* came out." Rebecca was laughing harder now. "And she stood in the middle of it and said, in her serious voice —"

"'This is fine,'" David said, and then he was laughing too. "'This is fine, this is fine.' And the cake was upside down, and it was *her* birthday cake, so there was nothing to give her —"

"— and we both started crying and she started crying and everyone was just standing on the sidewalk covered in chocolate —"

"— and then she walked in the house and came back with a spoon. And we ate it off the driveway."

"We ate our mother's birthday cake off the driveway, with spoons, in front of the neighbors."

"With our hands, at the end," David said, still laughing. "I remember the hands."

Rebecca had to step back and hold the low wall to steady herself. She was crying and laughing at the same time and it didn't feel like the bad kind. It felt like something loosening that had been cinched too long.

"I forgot that," she said, when she could. "I forgot the whole thing. I had to hear you say it."

"That's why there are two of us," David said.

She looked at him. Then at the house, at the stranger's jacket on the stranger's rail, at the light in the window where her mother used to stand.

"Come on," she said. "Let's go back to the Java Detour. I want to hear the whole thing again. Every part you've got."

David held out his arm. She took it. They walked back down Noriega, past the green house, past the empty corner where the plum tree used to be, and Rebecca felt something she hadn't felt in months — not the ache of what was missing, but the ordinary weight of a brother on her arm, walking beside her, holding half of what she couldn't remember.

They were two blocks from the café when her phone buzzed.

She pulled it out without breaking stride. A number she didn't recognize, Bay Area code. She almost didn't answer.

"Rebecca Lin."

"Ms. Lin." Older, careful, a voice with gravel at the edges. "I called you before. You were — I know you were in the hospital. I waited."

Rebecca stopped walking. David stopped with her.

"You still want the names," the woman said, "or you still want to know why I'm afraid to send them? Because I called to tell you something, and I'd rather say it in person. It's about your mother. It's about what she did in the last two weeks before she died. I was there. I think you need to know before the committee votes."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 73: The Reconciliation · The Memory Broker · Lumen Reads