David arrived at four o'clock on a Tuesday, which is how Rebecca knew before she opened the door that it was about money. Her brother scheduled nothing else. He stood on her porch in the flat gray Oakland light holding a folder the way other people hold flowers.
"Becca."
"David." She stepped back. He walked past her into the house without wiping his shoes, which was its own message.
He looked around the living room, at the desk she'd turned into an evidence board, at the printouts she'd taped to the wall and then torn down and then taped up again. He looked at all of it the way a man looks at a fire he didn't start.
"You want coffee?"
"No." He sat. He opened the folder. Inside were the loan documents from three years ago, the ones she'd signed in a title office in San Leandro, her signature a small illegible wound at the bottom of each page. "I'm calling the note."
Rebecca sat down across from him. "I have a payment plan with you."
"You have a payment plan with me that you've missed twice."
"I missed once in March and once in June because I had—"
"I know what you had." He said it flatly. "You told me. The studio. Then the studio thing ended and you started at Elysium and I thought, good, now she can pay. Instead you're still paying the minimum. And now I hear you've been taking time off."
"Who told you I've been taking time off?"
He didn't answer. He never answered that kind of question. It was the oldest thing between them—the way David moved through the world collecting information about his family the way other men collected stamps, and never said where he got it.
"Forty thousand," he said. "Or I file. End of the year, Becca. That's seven weeks."
Outside, a delivery truck idled and pulled away. Rebecca counted to four before she spoke, because her mother had taught her that, count to four, and she used it now without meaning to.
"You know what I've been doing this week?" she said. "I've been trying to find out what happened to Mom in 1998. At a place called Somnia. There's a file with her name on it. There's a file with my name on it. There's a woman named Maya Chen who disappeared in 2005 and her emergency contact was our mother. None of that means anything to you, does it."
David's face did something small. Not much. But something.
"It means something," he said.
"Then help me."
"Help you how? You think I have forty thousand dollars lying around that I'm just withholding out of spite?"
"I'm not asking for money. I'm asking for—" She stopped. She didn't actually know what she was asking him for. Information. Corroboration. A second body on the wall. Something. "You had a childhood too. You were there."
"I was ten when we moved here. You were four."
"That's exactly my point. You remember more."
David was quiet. He looked down at his folder, and Rebecca saw his thumb move along the edge of it, back and forth, a habit he'd had since he was a kid, the thumb on the paper edge, and it meant he was deciding.
"The simulation," he said finally. "You did it. You went in."
"Yes."
"I did it too." He said it to the folder, not to her. "In July. The recruiter was doing a study, they paid two hundred dollars. I did two sessions."
Rebecca didn't move.
"It was her," David said. "She looked exactly like her. The mole on her cheek, the way she—she called me Xiao-David. Nobody's called me that since she died. Nobody's even known to." He looked up. "So it was real. Or it was real enough that I sat in a parking garage for an hour afterward and couldn't drive."
"What did she say to you?"
David exhaled. "She said she was proud of me. Which she never said, not once, not in my whole life, so that's how I knew." He gave a short ugly laugh. "And then she said something I didn't understand. She said, *protect the turtle*. She said it twice. She said it like it mattered."
The room got very quiet.
"*Protect the turtle,*" Rebecca repeated.
"You know what it means."
"Do you?"
"No." He shook his head slowly. "I figured it was gibberish. Some kind of glitch. I figured the machine was broken and they paid me two hundred dollars for a broken machine and I was going to keep the two hundred dollars." His jaw set. "But you know what it means. You've got that look on your face. That's the look you used to get when you'd broken a dish and you were deciding whether to tell Mom."
Rebecca stood up. She walked to the desk. She picked up the photograph—the printout Priya hadn't given her, the one Sam had pulled from the sealed Mnemosyne archive, the one of her eighth birthday in a park she had no memory of ever visiting, her mother's hand on her shoulder, and in the corner, cropped out to the shoulder by whoever had catalogued it, a man in a green shirt holding a small dark object that Rebecca now understood, with a cold clean certainty, was a ceramic turtle.
"The turtle is evidence," she said. "From a lawsuit against Somnia. It was in a box of things that came out of Mom's house after she died, and I've had it on my shelf for eight years, and I never once looked at it."
David said nothing.
"Mom's simulation told you to protect it. Which means either the simulation has access to things Mom knew—"
"Or it's been *told* to say that."
Rebecca turned around. David was standing now, folder under his arm, and his face had closed up the way their father's used to, all the doors shut at once.
"Listen to yourself," he said. "You're building a conspiracy out of a two-hundred-dollar psychology study and a coffee mug from a dead woman's house."
"It's not a mug."
"It's *a turtle*, Becca. It's a knickknack. And you've got printouts all over your living room and you're not sleeping and you're missing loan payments—"
"I missed two payments."
"—to chase a company that is currently *paying your salary*, which means you're going to lose your job, and then you're going to lose the house, and I'm going to be the one who has to explain to Aunt Mei why my sister set herself on fire in public."
"So you're not going to help."
"I'm going to get my forty thousand dollars."
"Then say the real thing," Rebecca said. "*Say the real thing, David.*"
David's mouth opened. For a second she thought he'd deny it. But David had never once in his life managed to lie to her face, which was, she realized, the only reason she had ever loved him easily.
"I don't want to know," he said.
"That's not it either."
"No. It is." He put the folder under his arm and buttoned his coat, methodically, top button down. "I did the session. I heard her voice. And for one hour I had a mother who was proud of me, and then I got in my car and drove home to a wife and two kids who have never met her and never will, and I understood something. I understood that I can either have that, once in a while, for two hundred dollars—or I can have the truth, whatever it is, and no mother at all. And I'm forty-five years old, Becca. I already made that choice. I made it in the parking garage."
He walked to the door. Rebecca didn't follow him.
"The end of the year," he said. "Get me the money or get a lawyer."
"David."
He stopped with his hand on the knob.
"The simulation knew to say it," Rebecca said. "You told me to protect the turtle. That's not a comfort. That's an instruction. Mom didn't put that in there to make you feel better. She put it in there because she was trying to reach somebody."
David stood a moment with his back to her.
"Then you should wonder," he said, "why it took until this year."
He left. The door closed with the specific softness of a man being careful not to slam it, which was somehow worse than a slam. Rebecca listened to his car start, back out, turn onto the street, and go.
She sat down at the desk. She looked at the photograph for a long time, at the man in the green shirt, at her own mother's hand on her eight-year-old shoulder, at the small dark cropped thing at the edge of the frame.
Forty thousand dollars by December. Forty thousand dollars she did not have, because what she had was a thumb drive of stolen memos, a forensic psychiatrist referral she hadn't called yet, a journalist in Oakland with a storage unit full of catalogued evidence, and a company watching every session she sat through.
David, she thought, had been the only person left who was on her side without needing a reason.
She picked up her phone. There was a new message in the thread that had no number, the one that had said she was an active subject flagged for review.
This one said: *December is a good deadline. Keep going.*