The Mismatch

Chapter 16: The Sister's Warning

Emily was already seated at the corner table when Jack pushed through the door of the coffee shop on Commercial Drive, her coat folded over the back of the chair, a cup going cold in front of her. She had texted him at seven that morning with three words—*brunch. Non-negotiable.*—and Jack had known better than to argue.

She looked like their mother in the way she held her jaw when she was gearing up for something.

"You ordered?" he asked, sitting down.

"I ordered for you. Black, no sugar, because you're a joyless man." She slid the cup across. "You look like shit."

"Thanks."

"I mean it. You've got that thing you do with your eyes."

"What thing."

"The thing where you're about to say everything's fine." Emily wrapped both hands around her cup. "So let's skip that part."

Jack drank his coffee. Around them the shop hummed—steam, low music, a couple arguing quietly over a crossword. He counted the exits out of habit and hated himself for it.

"How's Mom?" he asked.

"Mom's fine. Mom's always fine. That's not why I'm here." Emily leaned back. "Priya called me."

"Priya called you."

"Two weeks ago. She said you've been showing up to practice early and leaving late and that Roman's game is falling apart and that you two aren't—" She made a vague gesture. "—whatever it is you are. She's worried."

"Priya's a physio, not a therapist."

"She's your friend, and she's mine, and she's not wrong." Emily's eyes were steady. "You've been calling me every Sunday for six years, Jack. You've missed three in a row."

Jack set the cup down. "Work's been busy."

"You're a hockey player. Work is always busy. You don't miss Sunday calls for busy." She let that sit. "You miss them when you're scared."

He didn't answer.

Emily reached into her bag and pulled out a folded envelope, worn soft at the edges, and set it on the table between them. Jack recognized their father's handwriting before he even read a word of it.

"What is that."

"Something I found when I was cleaning out the storage unit. I wasn't going to bring it." She tapped the envelope once, twice. "But then Priya called."

Jack didn't touch it. "Emily."

"Just read it."

"No."

"Read it, Jack."

He picked it up. The paper was thin and cheap, the ink faded to brown. His father's handwriting—angular, cramped, the same handwriting Jack remembered from birthday cards and, later, from nothing at all.

*I don't know how to say this so I'll just say it. When it started with him I thought it was something real. It felt real. It worked on me like a drug. That's the part nobody tells you—that it works. You feel calm and you feel seen and you think that's the same as being loved. It isn't. It was never the two of us. It was the chemistry. And when the chemistry stopped working I found out I didn't know the man I'd been living with for nine years.*

Jack read it twice. Then he folded it back along its creases and set it down.

"He was talking about Sharon," he said.

"Obviously."

"Sharon was—" He stopped. Sharon had been their father's third partner, the one who'd lasted almost a decade, the one Jack had thought of as a stepmother for most of his teenage years. She'd left when Jack was nineteen. His father hadn't come to his draft party that year because he'd been too drunk, and then he'd moved to Kelowna and stopped calling.

"He met her when I was ten," Jack said.

"Eleven. And he wrote this when you were fifteen."

"So this is old. This could mean anything."

"It's his handwriting on a piece of paper he never sent." Emily's voice was even. "I think that makes it mean more, not less."

Jack pushed the envelope back toward her. She didn't take it.

"You didn't show up here to give me a piece of paper," he said.

"No." She folded her hands. "I came here to ask you something and I want you to actually answer it. Not the version you give the press."

"Em."

"Do you love him? Roman. Do you love him, or do you just feel better when he's around?"

The coffee shop was too loud all of a sudden. Jack heard the crossword couple arguing about a seven-letter word. He heard the steamer hissing. He heard his own pulse, which was a stupid thing to hear.

"That's not—" he started, and stopped.

"It's a simple question."

"It's not simple."

"It's completely simple." Emily leaned forward. "Alpha-Alpha bonds, Jack. They're not like the others. You know that. The suppressants, the scent cascade, the whole HEARTH thing—everyone's been talking about it since your name came up. And I've been reading. I don't know how much of it's horseshit, but the basic thing, the part everyone seems to agree on? Alpha-Alpha is low-match. It's not supposed to work long-term. It's a spike, and the spike ends, and then people find out they don't actually like each other."

"Are you quoting a magazine at me?"

"I'm quoting Dad at you." She pointed at the envelope. "He called it a drug. He said it worked on him. He said he didn't know the man."

Jack's jaw tightened. "I know Roman."

"Do you? Because Priya says he doesn't talk to anyone anymore. Says he sits in his stall and stares at the floor. Says the two of you have this—" she gestured "—this *ritual*, and that's it. That's the whole relationship now. You scented each other before the Chicago game and then didn't speak for six hours on a bus."

"Priya needs to stop."

"Priya needs you to stop lying to her face." Emily's voice had climbed, and she glanced around, then dropped it back down. "I'm not saying this to hurt you. I'm saying this because I have watched exactly one Alpha-Alpha bond up close in my entire life, and it ended with our father drinking himself to death in a rental townhouse. That's my sample size. That's what I've got."

Jack sat very still.

"Is that the question? Am I confusing biology for love?"

"Yes."

He wanted to say no. He wanted to say it cleanly, the way he said things to reporters, the way he said things when he was captain-adjacent and the room needed a leader and his mouth knew what to do. He opened his mouth to say it.

"It's—" He stopped.

The thing was, he could still feel it. Not the ritual, not the pre-game thing they did with their wrists and their throats in the corridor—something underneath that. The night in Chicago when Roman had fallen asleep against his shoulder, and Jack had stayed awake for an hour just watching his breathing even out, and had thought, with a clarity that scared him now, *this is the only hour I've felt like myself in a year.* That wasn't chemistry. Chemistry didn't account for the specific way Roman held his stick, the two-pump tap he did before every faceoff, the way he flinched at the parking garage.

But he didn't know. That was the problem. He actually didn't know.

He could not put his hand on the wall between the feeling and the thing that made the feeling.

"Jack."

"I don't have an answer," he said.

"Okay."

"That's not—" He picked up the envelope, and this time he kept it. Folded it twice and put it in the inside pocket of his jacket, next to his phone, where the recording app sat, where the audio files sat, where the lawyer's last text sat unanswered on the lock screen. *Keep them coming.*

Emily watched him do it.

"That's not nothing," she said.

"It's not nothing."

"Then do something." She stood, pulling her coat off the chair. "I don't care what answer you land on. I care that you don't *find out* the way he did. Reading the letter afterward isn't the part I want for you."

She put a hand on his shoulder on her way past. Squeezed once. Didn't say anything else.

He sat alone with two cold cups of coffee and a folded piece of paper that felt like it weighed a pound.

His phone buzzed. He pulled it out.

Roman. 2:47 in the afternoon, on a Tuesday, which meant Roman wasn't sleeping either.

*Are you coming to the rink tonight or should I not wait*

Jack looked at it for a long time.

Then another text came, from a number with a Toronto area code.

*Call me when you can. New audio. This one's different—they're talking timelines. You have less room than we thought.*

Jack set the phone face down on the table and looked out the window at Commercial Drive, at the rain starting up, at people walking past with their hoods up, at the ordinary world going on being ordinary.

He had forty-eight hours. He had a lawyer. He had the letter in his pocket. He had Roman's name on his phone.

He didn't have an answer.

He was going to have to pick one anyway.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 16: The Sister's Warning · The Mismatch · Lumen Reads