The Mismatch

Chapter 55: Duval's Arrest

The courthouse on Smithe Street had the flat fluorescent smell of every institutional building Roman had ever hated — arenas, hospitals, the league's disciplinary offices. Same recycled air, same waxed floors, same feeling that the building had already decided something about you before you walked in.

He and Jack took the third row, behind Talia, who had a legal pad divided into columns and a pen she clicked like a metronome. The gallery held maybe forty people. Two rows of press. A handful of Vipers in street clothes who had come on their own — Delgado and Okonkwo near the back door, not making eye contact with anyone official. Toby Lund sat alone on the aisle, arms crossed, wearing a jacket with the community rink's crest on the breast.

At the front, between two sheriffs, Dr. Anne Duval sat with her hands folded. She looked smaller than Roman remembered. The last time he'd seen her she'd been holding a clipboard at the Kelowna combine, telling a room of eighteen-year-olds that the numbers didn't lie.

"All rise."

The proceeding was a preliminary hearing, not a trial — the Crown laying out enough to bind her over. The prosecutor, a compact woman named Reyes, walked the judge through the intake log page by page. Dates. Player identification numbers. Pre-draft evaluation scores that appeared in no other record, retroactively entered weeks after the physicals had been conducted. Twelve players. Roman's name was the fourth.

"These alterations," Reyes said, "were made to justify suppressing medical flags that would have triggered mandatory follow-up. The accused accepted payment from clubs seeking to reduce their exposure to players with documented anxiety conditions."

Jack's knee had started bouncing. Roman put a hand flat on it without looking over, and the bouncing stopped.

The judge turned to Duval's lawyer for a response. The response was that the records were incomplete, that the Crown's anonymous source was unreliable, that the chain of custody was unclear. Roman listened and felt the old thing uncoil in his chest — the familiar drop, the tightening at the base of his skull. He did the breathing without counting, four in, six out, the way he'd done in the car, the way he'd done every night in the guest room down the hall from Jack's.

Then Reyes said, "The Crown calls Roman Kovacs."

Talia's pen stopped clicking.

He'd known. They'd talked about it Saturday, sitting on Jack's floor with takeout containers and the intake log spread across the coffee table. Talia had been blunt: the log alone made the case for the league, not for him. If he wanted the evaluation struck from the record — if he wanted anything to be *his* — he had to say it in his own voice, under oath, in front of everyone.

Jack had said, *I'll be right there.*

Roman stood. Walked to the witness box. Swore the oath, and the words felt borrowed from someone else's life.

Reyes kept it short. Name, team, draft year. Then she handed him a single sheet — a certified copy — and said, "Do you recognize this document?"

"Yes."

"Can you read the marked line to the court?"

He looked at the paper. He'd read it a hundred times in the last five days. The line was the same line every time.

"Recommendation: Do not advance," Roman read. "Subject demonstrates atypical pheromone response and elevated reactivity to partner bonding; anticipate performance instability under sustained stress. Assign provisional score of four of ten. Advise clubs to avoid."

The room was very quiet.

"Can you tell the court what a provisional score of four meant in your draft year?"

It meant the difference between a first-round contract and a tryout. It meant three teams that had scouted him stopped calling. It meant a summer in Kelowna working construction while his friends signed entry-level deals. It meant the Vipers had picked him in the fifth round as a flier, and he had spent six years proving a piece of paper wrong and never quite believing he had.

"It almost ruined my life," Roman said. His voice did something on *almost* and he let it. "I was nineteen. I didn't know what a pheromone response was. I read that line and I thought it meant something was wrong with the part of me that wanted a team. So I hid it. For years. I got good at hiding it. That's the part of me that made me a fourth-line grinder instead of a player who trusted his linemates. That's the part of me that almost —"

He stopped. Breathed. The judge watched him, and behind the judge, in the third row, Jack was leaning forward with his forearms on his knees, absolutely still.

"That's the part of me that almost cost me my career before it started," Roman finished. "On the strength of a score that the accused altered after the fact. So I want it struck. I want it on the record that it wasn't true when she wrote it, and it was never true after she changed it, and I'd like my name back."

Nobody clapped. This wasn't that kind of room. But Delgado, in the back row, put his fist over his mouth and didn't move it.

Duval's lawyer had one question on cross. "Mr. Kovacs, were you not recently suspended by your league for an on-ice incident involving a captain and a broken glass door?"

"I was."

"And was that incident not attributed, in the league's own report, to uncontrolled reactivity consistent with precisely the profile the accused identified?"

Roman looked at Duval. She looked back at him, and there was nothing in her face at all.

"I broke a door," Roman said. "I got suspended, and I'm serving it. That doesn't make her a doctor. It makes me a man who broke a door."

The lawyer sat down.

The judge bound the case over for trial and, on the Crown's motion, revoked bail. Two sheriffs moved to either side of Duval and lifted her by the elbows. She walked the length of the gallery without looking at anyone, and the doors swung shut behind her.

The room exhaled. Phones came out. Reyes shook Talia's hand. Somewhere behind Roman a reporter was already dictating.

He stayed in the witness box for a second longer than he needed to. Then he walked back to the third row and sat down, and Jack didn't say anything, just put a hand on the back of his neck the way you'd steady someone who'd stepped off a moving bus.

Outside, the rain had started again. Toby caught them on the courthouse steps with his collar turned up.

"That was the right thing," he said. "Not the smart thing. The right one. They're not always the same."

"Which is it today?" Roman asked.

"I don't know yet. Ask me Monday."

They made it halfway to the car before Talia's phone rang. She answered, listened, and stopped walking in the middle of the sidewalk. Jack and Roman stopped with her.

She lowered the phone. "That was the union's general counsel. The executive committee's called an emergency session Sunday night. There's a motion on the floor."

"What motion?"

"A policy vote. Mandatory pheromone testing gets abolished — no testing without written consent, no exceptions, no draft-time evaluations without the player present and a union rep in the room." She looked at Roman. "They want a witness. Both of you, if you'll come."

"Who's opposing it?" Jack asked.

The rain picked up. Talia tucked the phone into her coat.

"Harroway's office is already lobbying against it," she said. "And an hour ago, someone leaked the emergency session date to the press. So the vote isn't private anymore."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 55: Duval's Arrest · The Mismatch · Lumen Reads