The Missing Seat

Chapter 14: The Photograph

The photograph had been in his desk drawer for six days, flat under a folder of unmarked essays, and Theo had taken it out so often that the crease down its center had begun to soften from handling. He laid it on the desk now, under the hard white light of the reading lamp, and made himself look properly, the way he'd been trained to look at a fragmentary text—not for the whole picture, but for the joints where it had been broken.

Someone had torn it cleanly, once, along a diagonal that removed two-thirds of the original frame. What remained showed the corner of a long table, eleven men seated along one side of it, and behind them a paneled wall hung with a dark rectangle that might have been a portrait or a door. The men wore dinner jackets. Most were middle-aged or older, faces soft with good living. Three were laughing at something outside the frame.

At the far end of the row, near the torn edge, sat the youngest of them. He could not have been more than thirty. Fair hair parted flat, a narrow face, hands folded on the table in front of him like a man waiting to be told what to do next. Theo had stared at the 1949 photograph long enough to know the Master's face at seventy; he'd seen Elias Voss only in the grainy reproduction of a 1961 obituary, thirty years on from this picture. But the bone structure held. The same high, cramped brow. The same way of sitting slightly turned away from the men on either side, as though he'd been invited but not quite included.

Theo set his pencil down and breathed out slowly through his nose. Elias Voss, 1957. Eight years after the photograph in the cabinet. Standing—sitting—beside a man at his left hand who was very obviously not related to him by blood: broader through the shoulders, darker, with a heavy jaw and hair cropped close to the skull. The man had one hand raised, caught mid-gesture, and he was looking not at the camera but at Voss.

Theo leaned closer. The resemblance was the kind you could dismiss if you wanted to, the way you dismissed a false etymology—same general coloring, same width across the cheekbones, the same faint asymmetrical set to the mouth. But he'd spent four months looking at Felix's face across seminar tables and in the dim light of the society's dining room, and he could not unsee it. If you took this man and aged him sixty years and hollowed him out a little, you got something close to a face Theo had seen in the photograph his own mother had sent him in September—Felix on the steps of the Bodleian, caught mid-turn, laughing at whoever held the camera.

He turned the photograph over. On the back, in faded pencil, in a hand that had pressed hard enough to leave a groove: *Midsummer, 1957. The Twelve, less one.*

Less one. The phrase sat in him like a splinter. In the 1949 photograph there had been twelve men at the table. Here there were eleven, and the seat at the presiding officer's left hand was occupied by the dark-haired man whose face would not stop resolving into Felix's.

He sat back. The lamp hummed. Somewhere down the corridor a door closed, and he heard the particular shuffle of the night porter doing his rounds, and he waited until it had passed before he let himself think the thing he'd been circling since the archive.

The paper said the advantage was durable. *Durable* could mean a great deal. It could mean that a subject seated at that left hand for a single evening carried the effect for a year, or a decade, or a life. It could mean that the society had spent ninety years feeding particular men into a particular chair and measuring what came back out. And it could mean—Theo pressed the heel of his hand against his eye, hard—that a missing second-year student with Felix's coloring and Felix's quick, uncareful mind had been seated there, in that chair, in this century, because a pattern established in 1932 required a body in a seat.

He did not sleep. At six he showered, dressed, put the photograph in the inside pocket of his coat, and went to find Adrian.

Adrian's rooms were in the old range, up a stair that turned twice and smelled of wet stone. He answered on the second knock, unshaven, in a dressing gown, a cup of coffee already in his hand—the unnatural composure of a man who had been awake for hours and had decided not to show it.

"You're early," he said.

"I need to show you something."

Adrian looked at him for a moment, and something in his face closed like a door being eased shut so as not to make a sound. But he stepped back and let him in.

The room was the same as it had been at the dinner: books in double rows, the desk by the window, the single good chair. Theo did not sit. He took the photograph from his pocket and laid it flat on the desk, face up, then turned it over with two fingers so the pencil annotation showed.

"That's your grandfather," he said. "1957."

Adrian picked up his cup, drank, set it down. He did not look at the photograph for what felt to Theo like an unreasonably long time. When he did look, he looked at the back first—at the words—and Theo watched the blood leave his face in a slow, even tide, from the cheekbones down.

"Where did you get this."

"The cabinet. The week you caught me in the archive. It was in with the 1949 print." Theo kept his voice level. "Look at the man beside him. At his left hand."

Adrian did not look. He set both hands flat on the desk on either side of the photograph, the way a man braces himself against a table that is not, in fact, moving, and he breathed twice through his nose before he raised his eyes to Theo's.

"I don't know who that is," he said.

"You haven't looked."

"I don't need to look. I've seen the photograph." His voice had gone thin at the edges. "It's been in my family's papers since before I was born. There's a copy in my grandfather's study, in Gloucestershire, and I have looked at it a hundred times, and I don't know who the man is."

"Then you know it's him. You know it's his face."

"I know what you think you see." Adrian straightened, and the dressing gown slipped off one shoulder and he did not fix it. "Theo. Listen to me. Whatever you have decided this photograph proves—"

"He's the same age Felix would have been if—" Theo stopped himself. Started again. "You told me to look for the name under the name. I did. The 1932 file was requested in 1957 by a proxy. There's a photograph from 1957 in the same cabinet, torn, with your grandfather and a man who looks like Felix, and a caption that says *less one* beside a table that is supposed to seat twelve. Tell me you don't see it."

Adrian's jaw worked once. He looked at the photograph then, finally, for a long moment, and Theo watched him arrange his face into the expression of a man encountering an unfamiliar document—the slight frown, the tilt of the head, the careful blankness. It was a good performance. It was not good enough. Theo had watched Adrian Alcott read a fifteenth-century hand he'd never seen before and his face had come alive; here his eyes stayed flat and still and he did not once look at the man at Voss's left hand, which was the one thing a person actually looking at the photograph would have done.

"I don't know anything about this," Adrian said at last. "And I would be careful who you show it to."

Theo took the photograph back and put it in his pocket. "Careful," he repeated.

"Careful." Adrian picked up his cup again; his hand was steady and Theo hated him for it, and hated himself for noticing the steadiness and wanting, obscurely, to be told what it meant. "You came here to see whether I would flinch. I didn't flinch, Theo. That should tell you something."

It told him something, all right. It told him that Adrian had known which words to say before Theo had said them, which meant he'd rehearsed this conversation, which meant he had already seen the photograph.

"I'll let myself out," Theo said.

He made it to the bottom of the stair before his phone buzzed. A number he didn't recognize. He answered on the third ring—and heard, in the background, the clatter of a dining hall he knew, and then a voice he knew, though it was speaking the way a man speaks when he wants to sound like a stranger.

"Mr. Mercer," it said. "You've been asking about 1957. Stop. Or the seat will be filled again."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 14: The Photograph · The Missing Seat · Lumen Reads