The Missing Seat

Chapter 22: The Missing Recording

The recorder was gone.

Theo stood in the middle of his room with his hand still on the desk drawer, open to the dark, and felt the world tilt by a degree. He kept the Olympus between the second and third notebooks, flat against the wood, where it had lived for eleven months. He pulled the drawer all the way out. He searched the gap behind it. He checked the pockets of every coat on the hook, then the laundry basket, then the bed, sliding his palm under the mattress the way you checked for something you already knew was not there.

Nothing.

He sat on the edge of the bed and made himself breathe. His door: the college locks were old brass, and the man who ran the lodge had never once looked up from his crossword when Theo came in. Anyone could walk in. Anyone had.

He pulled up the last file he had transferred to his laptop and played ten seconds of it at low volume—the scrape of a chair, his own voice, the words *disengaged by the fourth session*—and then deleted it, because his hands had started shaking and he did not want to hear Felix's name spoken in that flat clinical tone while he sat alone.

He thought of Adrian at the kitchen table in Dorset, holding the recorder, thumbing the pause. *I'd like to hear it back*, he had said. And then, later, in the dark of the library, close enough that Theo could feel the heat of him: *you should keep it somewhere you'd notice if it moved.*

Theo had noticed.

Adrian was in the senior common room with two other graduates and a chessboard he was losing. He looked up when Theo came in and something crossed his face—not guilt. Something more careful than guilt.

"I need to talk to you," Theo said.

Adrian slid his king across the board without looking at it. "I resign. Ben, take my money, it's in my coat." He followed Theo out to the corridor, and down the stairs, and out into the cold gravel of the quad, where the lamps were just coming on and no one could hear them.

"The recorder's gone," Theo said.

"Gone."

"From my drawer. Between the second and third notebooks. Nobody else knew where it was." He watched Adrian's eyes the whole time he said it.

Adrian was quiet for a moment. Then: "Are you asking me if I took it."

"I'm asking you where it is."

"I don't have it."

"You had it at the estate. You asked to hear the files. You told me to move it, which is a strange thing to say to someone if you're not thinking about where it is."

Adrian's jaw worked. The lamps threw his shadow long across the grass. "You think I planned that. The whole weekend. To get your recorder."

"I don't know what I think right now. That's the problem."

"Right," Adrian said. "The problem." He said it softly, which was worse than if he'd shouted. "Fine. Ask me properly."

Theo asked him properly.

"No," Adrian said. "I did not take your recorder, and I did not send anyone to take it, and I don't know who did. Someone may have come into your room while you were at the archive reading room this afternoon, because you told Hale to her face last week that you'd stop asking questions, and she doesn't believe you, because you're a bad liar, Theo. You're a very bad liar. It's one of the more attractive things about you."

"Don't."

"Don't what."

"Don't do that. Don't—be like that, and make me forget what I came down here to say."

Adrian looked away first. He put his hands in his coat pockets. "Ask me the other question."

"What other question."

"The one you're actually here for. Whether I've heard Felix's voice."

The cold came up through the gravel and into Theo's shoes. "Have you."

"Yes."

The word landed and sat there. Theo had kept a version of Felix in a plastic box between notebooks, and he had played it back on bad nights, and he had believed—somewhere under everything—that he was the only one who had it.

"Where," he said.

"I can't tell you that."

"Can't, or won't."

"Both," Adrian said. "It wouldn't help you. It wouldn't give you anything you could use. It would just—" He stopped. Started again. "You have to trust me that it would make this worse."

"I have to trust you." Theo laughed, once, and it came out wrong. "Adrian. Last week you gave me a letter opener that opened a dead man's files and told me afterward that it was a test. This week my recorder disappears out of a drawer only two people knew about. I've spent six months trying to decide whether you're the trap or the man caught in it, and you keep—" His voice cracked and he hated it. He straightened. "You keep making the trap look like the truer answer."

Adrian flinched. He actually flinched, small, like a movement of the shoulder, and said nothing for a long moment. Then he spoke, evenly, in the voice he used for other people. "That's fair."

"So where did you hear it."

"I'm not going to tell you. Not tonight."

"Then we're finished. With the files. With the estate. With all of it."

"No," Adrian said, "we're not, and you know we're not, because Hale has your name in a seating chart and I have mine bracketed next to it, and neither of us can get out of this by sulking in a quad." He took half a step closer; Theo didn't move back. "Theo. I heard it before. Before any of this. That's all I'll say."

"Before."

"Before the term started. Before you and I were ever—before the library."

Before the kiss, he meant. Before that.

Which meant he had heard Felix's voice—the voice of the man he was supposed to have been assigned, in a way Theo could not yet name—in some room, some archive, some house, and had decided not to say anything. Which meant he had a reason. Which meant everything Adrian had done between that moment and this one had been done by a man already holding a piece of the board, moving Theo around it, or moving *with* him, and there was no way from the outside to tell the two apart.

"You could have said something when I told you about him," Theo said. "That very first night. I sat across from you and I told you my friend was missing, and you put your hand over the cuff of my sleeve, and you said nothing."

"I know," Adrian said.

"That's the part I can't get past."

"I know," he said again.

A door opened somewhere across the quad; two undergraduates came out laughing, and Adrian and Theo stepped off the path automatically, standing in the shadow of the chapel wall until they passed. It was absurd, Theo thought, the way they kept hiding. It was all they'd ever done.

When the quad was empty again, Adrian said, "I don't have your recorder. That part's true. I'd like you to believe one thing."

"One thing," Theo said. "That's a small budget."

"It is." Adrian looked tired in a way the lamps made worse. "Use it however you like."

He turned and walked back toward the common room stairs, and did not look back, and Theo stood alone in the cold with his hands loose at his sides, doing arithmetic he couldn't finish.

He went up to his room and sat on the bed and did not turn on the light.

Then he noticed the envelope.

It was on his desk, which it had not been when he left, and it was the wrong shape for the college post—thin, cream, no stamp, no address, just his name in a hand he didn't recognize. Someone had come in while he was in the quad. Someone had walked past him on the path, or stood by the chapel door, or watched him and Adrian standing too close in the shadow of the wall.

He reached for it and stopped, because under the bed, pushed deep into the gap between the frame and the boxes, something small and black caught a sliver of light off the streetlamp.

The recorder.

He pulled it out. The card door was open. The SD card was not inside it.

He sat holding the empty machine for a long time. Then he opened the envelope.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 22: The Missing Recording · The Missing Seat · Lumen Reads