She was waiting on the bench outside the Porter's Lodge when he came back from the Co-op with a bag of rice and two tins of tomatoes, because that was what his money had come to now — calories by the gram, cost per thousand. He nearly walked past her. A small woman in a green waxed coat, hands folded over the strap of a leather holdall, hair the same rust-brown as Felix's, cut short and pushed back behind her ears.
"Theo," she said, and stood.
He knew her from photographs. He had never met her. He had, four months ago, written her a letter he never sent.
"Mrs. Ashcombe."
"Rosemary." She said it the way you correct a waiter who has mispronounced the wine. "Is there somewhere we can sit? I've been on the coach since half six."
He took her to the churchyard behind St Giles, because it was free and quiet and he could not bear the thought of the college café, where someone would see him and look away. They sat on a low wall of warm stone. She set the holdall between them, unzipped, and took out a shoebox held shut with two rubber bands.
"I'm not going to pretend I don't know," she said. "About the recording. It came to me on Sunday. Somebody made sure it would."
Theo's fingers went cold on the box.
"I've had three emails from people I've never met in my life, telling me what a fraud you are. One of them was very well written." She looked at him sideways. "Did you say it?"
"Yes."
"He said you'd say yes." She nodded slowly, as though filing it. "Felix. He said, if it ever came to it, Theo will tell you the truth even when it costs him. He was a terrible judge of most things. Not that."
Theo did not know where to put his hands. He put them flat on the box.
"I'm not here about the recording," she said. "I'm here because the police have closed the file."
"They can't. He's—"
"Missing persons, they call it, and then they call it dormant, and then they call it this." She pulled an envelope out of her coat pocket and handed it to him. He unfolded it. It was two paragraphs, sigged by a Detective Inspector in Dorchester, thanking her for her patience and explaining that a young man of twenty-four with a history of depressive episodes and a cleared bank account—two hundred and forty pounds, withdrawn in cash over four days—was not, in the considered opinion of the constabulary, a person who had met with foul play.
"Cleared bank account," Theo said.
"On the fifth of June. Four days before he stopped answering." She looked at him steadily. "Did he have two hundred and forty pounds?"
"No." Theo said it before he had thought about it. "He owed me ninety. He was—" He stopped. They had both known what Felix was, and neither of them had ever said it out loud in front of the other, and now they had to. "He borrowed money for the rent in May. He didn't have two hundred pounds to withdraw."
"No," Rosemary said. "He didn't."
A wind came up off the river and moved the yew trees. Somewhere in the college a bell rang the hour.
"So somebody else moved it," she said. "And the police don't care, because the police have a story that fits, and my son fits it, because he was sad and he was short of money and he was—" Her mouth worked. "He was difficult. He was difficult at school and difficult at home and difficult to love, in the way that people who are frightened are difficult to love, and so when the constable sat in my kitchen and said this to me I could see him thinking, well, of course."
Theo said nothing, because there was nothing.
"He didn't disappear," she said. "He was taken, or he went somewhere to be safe, or he's—" She stopped. "I've read everything there is to read. Somebody sent me his college file. That's what's in the box."
"Who sent it?"
"Anonymous. Posted from Didcot. I assume it's the same person who sent the recording, and I assume they did it because they wanted me angry, and it worked, so I don't much care."
Theo pulled off the rubber bands. Inside were perhaps forty pages, loose, most of them in Felix's handwriting — a looped, cramped left-handed scrawl he had once watched fill a whole coffee-stained A4 pad in a single afternoon.
*Transcript, 14 March. Question: why is there a Dr Pollard Fund and no Dr Pollard?*
*Transcript, 21 March. Answered question: there IS a Dr Pollard. Maud Pollard, PhD, Physiology, matriculated 1961. Died 1968. Cause of death: 'misadventure.' I would like to see what counts as misadventure in Oxford in 1968.*
*24 March. Asked J. about Pollard at hall. J. went white and changed the subject. Who is J.?*
Theo knew who J. was. James Ashcombe. Felix's uncle, his father's older brother, who had been at Balliol in the eighties and now taught at Leeds and came to dinner twice a year.
He turned the page.
*2 April. L. says the Society's books are in the archive room but only old ones, nothing after 1972. Nothing after 1972 is interesting. The Pollard Fund pays for four first-year scholarships a year and a 'research stipend' that goes to one name every year, and I have been trying to find out where the stipend goes for three weeks and I think I have to stop asking in the open.*
Then a page where the handwriting changed, larger, pressing through the paper, written perhaps on a train.
*Draft. To: the Registrar; the Charity Commission; the Oxford Mail; the college. I am writing to place on record what I believe: that the death of Dr Maud Pollard in 1968 was not misadventure, that she was engaged in a programme of experimental work on unwilling or uninformed subjects under the auspices of a private dining society at this college, that this work continued after her death and continues now, and that the college has for fifty-seven years deliberately refused to open its archive to any independent party. I have asked twelve times. I have asked properly, through my supervisor, in writing. The answer has never been no. The answer has always been that the archivist is unwell, or the room is being rewired, or the request has been 'noted'.*
*I am frightened. I want that in the record too. I do not think I am a reliable witness about my own state of mind, so I have asked my GP to note this letter in her file, and I have posted a copy to my mother, in case.*
*If I stop writing, it is not because I have stopped.*
It ended there. There was no signature.
Rosemary was watching him read. When he looked up, she had her hands pressed together in her lap, knuckles pale.
"He did post it to me," she said. "It came on the eleventh of June. Two days after he stopped answering his phone. I didn't open it for a week. I thought it was—" She shook her head. "I thought it was one of his letters."
Theo read the last line again. *In case.*
"Dr Pollard," he said.
"His grandmother. My mother." She said it without ceremony, as if producing a document that had been in her pocket for years. "Maud. She died before I was born. I was told she had a fall in the lab at night and struck her head. I was told it was misadventure. My father told me and my father was a vicar and I believed him until March." She looked at the churchyard around them, the stones, the yew. "Felix found out from a library catalogue. A footnote. She published two papers, and then in 1968 the second one was withdrawn, and there is no citation of her anywhere after 1969 except in a schedule of endowed funds. He wrote to me about it in February as though he had discovered gravity."
"He was like that," Theo said.
"He was like that." Her voice cracked and she pressed her knuckles against her mouth and took a breath through her nose, and then she was steady again. "Do you know what I want from you?"
"Yes."
"Say it."
Theo looked at the box. "You want me to find him."
"I want you to find him." She took the letter from his hands and folded it back into the envelope, careful, as though it were already an heirloom. "Not because I think he's alive. I want you to find out. I want somebody to be able to tell me, in a room, with a face, what happened to my son, because if I hear it from a policeman on the phone I will die." She put the envelope back in the holdall. "You were the last person he trusted. He told me in April, in a letter I still have, that there was one person at that college he would tell anything to, and it was you, and he said you would not want to be told, and that he was going to tell you anyway. Did he?"
Theo thought of the photograph. Of the night in the pub in early May, Felix three pints in, leaning across and saying, *Theo, I need to tell you something and I need you not to be sensible about it,* and Theo—because he had an essay due, because he had mortgage-shaped debts and a supervisor with a temper, because he had spent his entire life being sensible and it had never once helped anybody—had said, *Not tonight, Felix. Friday.*
There had been no Friday.
"No," he said. "He didn't."
She looked at him for a long moment. Then she closed the holdall.
"Then you owe him," she said, "and you owe me, and I don't care about your reputation or your debts or your recording, and I don't care what they do to you, because they have already done the worst thing they can do to me. Keep the box." She stood, brushing her coat. "My train is at five. I don't want you to walk me to the station."
Mrs. Ashcombe," he said. "If it's dangerous—"
"Everything is dangerous." She pulled up the zip. "He was twenty-four. He was my only one. Find him, or find out."
She went out through the churchyard gate without looking back. Theo sat with the shoebox on his knees until the bell rang the next hour, and then he opened it again and read the draft letter through twice more, and on the second pass he noticed what he had missed.
The letter was undated. But the copy Felix had posted to his mother had a postmark, and the postmark was the eleventh of June, and Felix had last been seen on the ninth.
Which meant the letter had been posted after he disappeared. By someone who had it.