The Guardian’s Oxford office was a rented room above a bookshop on Cornmarket, and it smelled of wet wool and old paper. The journalist, a woman named Priya Nair with cropped grey hair and reading glasses pushed up into it, set two recorders on the table and did not turn them on yet.
“Before we start,” she said, “I want to be clear about what I can and can’t protect. You’re naming a lot of people. Some of them have lawyers.”
“I’ve read the file Lena sent you,” Theo said.
“I’ve read it twice. That’s why I’m here on a Saturday.” She looked past him to Adrian, who had taken the chair at Theo’s left and set his coat over the back of it. “And you’re sure you want to be in the room for this? A family named in the piece—that’s different from a source.”
“I know what my family’s name is worth,” Adrian said. “That’s why I’m here.”
Priya watched him a moment, then clicked both recorders on. “Theo Mercer. Doctoral candidate, classical studies. Tell me why you’re talking to me.”
Theo had rehearsed this with Adrian at half past four that morning, over tea neither of them drank. The words came out steadier than he expected. He described the invitation that arrived in the wrong way, the card with the woman’s signature that matched the one on Felix’s placement fee, the dinner on the nineteenth of November, the empty chair at the head of the table with his name on it. He laid the documents on the table as he went: the trial records, the metadata printout from the original recording, the transcript of Felix’s hospital statement.
“Slow down,” Priya said, when he reached the tape. “This is the recording that was circulated to your department. Dated the nineteenth.”
“Yes.”
“And you say it wasn’t you. That it was fabricated.”
“Felix Hale—Felix Braithwaite, I should use his real name—was interviewed for weeks in a private clinic. The interviews were recorded. What was circulated was edited from them.” He slid the metadata across. “The original file exists. Dr. Hale—Edmund Hale, no relation to Felix—had access to it.”
Priya wrote for a while. “You understand what you’re alleging. That a physician and a member of a dining society conspired to manufacture evidence against a student.”
“I understand it.”
“And the empty seat. You’ve told me it was meant for you. An initiation.”
Theo hesitated. This was the part he had not rehearsed to the end, because it still did not fit together in his hands.
“That’s what Edmund Hale told me,” he said. “At the hospital. He said the recording was never about discrediting me. He said the seat was an initiation, and that the tape concerns the person who failed to occupy it. Then he told me to ask Dr. Renn.”
Priya’s pen stopped. “Renn. Martin Renn.”
“You know him?”
“He was named in a complaint in 2011. Nothing came of it—the complainant withdrew.” She looked at Theo over the rim of her glasses. “How long has he been unreachable?”
“He’s called me nine times in the last two days,” Theo said. “I haven’t picked up. I don’t know what he wants.”
“That’s a problem for the piece. Not fatal, but a problem.” She made a note. “I’ll try him myself. If he answers, and he gives me something, it changes the shape of this.”
Adrian leaned forward. “It changes the shape either way. If he’s been trying to reach Theo, then he’s not the man the society says he is. He’s a witness.”
“Or he’s a man covering himself,” Priya said. “Which is why I’m asking, not assuming.”
She turned a page. “Now. Your family, Mr. Ashworth.”
Adrian did not flinch. “My father sat on the society’s board from 2009 to 2016. He signed the transfer that paid for Felix Braithwaite’s placement. I found the ledger in the estate office. I copied it. I’m not here to protect him.”
“Have you told your family you’re doing this?”
“No.”
“Do you intend to?”
“They’ll read it,” Adrian said. “That’s how they’ve always preferred to hear things.”
Priya wrote that down too, and Theo noticed the way her pen moved—fast, unhesitating. She believed them. That was the thing he had not let himself hope for.
“One more thing,” Priya said. “There’s been a leak. Someone inside your department told the society you were coming to me. I received a call on Thursday from a man who wouldn’t give his name, warning me that my source was unstable and that the documents I’d been sent were forgeries.”
Theo’s mouth went dry. “Who?”
“He wouldn’t say. But he knew about the stairwell.”
Adrian went very still beside him.
“What stairwell?” Priya asked, and she asked it of Theo, not Adrian, which meant she had been listening for the reaction and had found it.
Theo did not look at Adrian. “The night of the dinner, there was a photograph taken in the stairwell of my college. Of me and Adrian. Hale threatened to release it if I didn’t withdraw.”
“I see.” Priya wrote. “And you didn’t tell me.”
“I’m telling you now.”
“You’re telling me because I caught you.” She set the pen down. “I’m not judging you, Theo. I’m telling you that if the society has it, they’ll use it, and it’s better that it runs with the story than that it appears three days later as a correction. So. Do you want it in the piece?”
The room was quiet. Through the window, Cornmarket ran with grey Saturday light and the sound of a bus pulling away.
Adrian said, “Put it in.”
Theo turned. “Adrian—”
“Put it in,” Adrian said again, and he said it to Priya, not to Theo. “They photographed us because they thought it would humiliate me into silence. I’d rather it be in print than in a drawer somewhere with their fingerprints on it.”
Priya looked at him for a long moment, then nodded and wrote it down. “Three days,” she said. “It runs Wednesday. I’ll need your phone records, the original audio file, and a statement from Braithwaite’s solicitor. Can you get me all three by Monday noon?”
“Yes,” Theo said.
“Then we’re done here.” She switched off the recorders and stood, and for the first time her professional mask slipped a little—she looked tired, and not unkind. “For what it’s worth. I’ve been doing this fourteen years. Most people who come to me with a story like this are wrong about something. You’re not. I checked.”
She walked them to the stairs. At the top step, she said, “Don’t answer calls from numbers you don’t know. Don’t go anywhere alone until Wednesday.”
“That bad?” Adrian asked.
“That bad,” Priya said, and shut the door.
They came out into the cold. The bookshop below was doing a brisk trade in secondhand paperbacks, and a boy in a soaked hoodie was chaining his bike to the rack by the door. Theo pulled his coat tighter and stood under the awning while the rain came slantwise off the roofs.
His phone buzzed in his pocket. He did not take it out. The anonymous number from that morning had gone quiet, but he could feel it there the way you feel a splinter.
“Nine missed calls,” Adrian said, beside him. “Renn.”
“Not Renn. Someone from the department.” Theo watched the rain hit the pavement. “Priya’s right. They know. They’ve known since Thursday.”
“Then we’re ahead,” Adrian said. “They think we’re hiding. We’re publishing Wednesday.”
Theo looked at him. Adrian’s hair was flat with rain, and there was a smudge of ink on his thumb from signing the consent form Priya had given them at the door. He looked tired and stubborn and entirely unrepentant about any of it—the ledger, the family, the photograph. It occurred to Theo, not for the first time, that he had spent two years hating this man for things that had been done to him rather than by him, and that the hating had been, at bottom, a way of not looking at anything clearly.
“Your father,” Theo said. “When it runs.”
“He’ll call my mother, and my mother will call me, and I’ll say yes, it was me, and she’ll hang up.” Adrian shrugged. “It’s not the worst thing that could happen in a week.”
“What’s the worst thing?”
“You going back to America.” Adrian said it lightly, but his eyes did not move off the street. Then, because Theo did not answer, he said, “I’m not asking. I’m just saying what it is.”
Theo reached over and took his hand. That was all—just took it, there on the wet pavement outside the bookshop, while the bus went by and the rain kept coming down. Adrian’s fingers were cold, and then they weren’t.
“Let’s go get something to eat,” Theo said. “I haven’t eaten since yesterday.”
“You haven’t eaten since Thursday,” Adrian said, and did not let go of his hand, and they walked down Cornmarket together in the rain, and for the length of one street, nothing in Theo’s life was asking anything of him.
His phone buzzed again, six times in rapid succession. He ignored it. Then Adrian’s phone buzzed in his other pocket, once, and Adrian stopped walking.
“It’s not a number I know,” he said. He read it. Then he read it again, and the color drained out of his face.
“What?” Theo said. “Show me.”
Adrian turned the screen. One line, no sender:
*Ask him why Renn called the ninth chair the spare.*