The Missing Seat

Chapter 61: The Article Draft

They had been in the Bodleian for three hours, and neither of them had said a word about the third paragraph.

Theo had read it seven times. He could feel Adrian two seats away in the pale winter light of the Upper Reading Room, the great vaulted ceiling gathering dust and silence the way it gathered everything else. Adrian had a pencil in his teeth and one leg crossed over the other, the way he always sat when he was actually thinking, and Theo had learned to hate and love that posture in roughly equal measure across the years. Now he mostly just loved it, which was its own kind of problem.

"You've stopped writing," Adrian said, not looking up.

"I've stopped and started. It's a different thing."

"It's the same thing viewed from a distance of approximately one meter."

Theo set his pen down. "The opening's wrong."

Adrian looked up then, gray eyes narrowing in the way that meant he was going to disagree on principle and find a reason afterward. "The opening is Felix's. He wrote it. We agreed."

"We agreed he could revise it. That's not the same as canonizing it."

"It's two sentences. 'In the winter of 1871, a small dining society at an unnamed college began recruiting the brightest undergraduates in the university. Within a decade, three of them were dead.' That's—Theo, that's good. That's a hook."

"It's a hook that makes us look like we're writing for a Sunday supplement." Theo picked up his pen again and tapped it against the page. "It implies a body count the article can't support. Two of the three died of typhoid and a carriage accident."

"In 1871."

"What are you implying?"

"I'm implying nothing, I'm saying 1871 was not a medically careful era."

They both sat back. The Bodleian's heating system made a sound somewhere overhead like a very old man shifting in his sleep. Somewhere in the far stacks, a scholar Theo couldn't see turned a page with the particular violence of a person who had been asked to leave their coffee outside.

"Fine," Adrian said. "The opening stays. What's actually bothering you?"

Theo looked at the page. The problem was not the opening. The problem was paragraph four, where he had written that Felix had consented to the referral, and then crossed it out, and then written it again in the margin, and then crossed that out too.

"Consent," he said.

Adrian was quiet. Then: "It's true."

"It's true in the way that it's true when a nineteen-year-old says yes to something he doesn't understand because everyone around him is older and institutional and pleased with him. It's legally true. It isn't actually true."

"You can't put that in an academic article."

"I know I can't. That's why I keep crossing it out." Theo pressed the heel of his hand against his eye. "Felix asked to be first author because he wants the record straight about what he did. He doesn't want the record straight about what was done to him."

Adrian leaned over and pulled Theo's draft toward him, turning it so he could read the marginalia. His sleeve brushed Theo's wrist. Neither of them moved away.

"You've written 'he was recruited by flattery and he was fifteen years younger than the men recruiting him' in the margin," Adrian said. "Twice."

"It's a good line."

"It's the whole article, Theo. It's the argument we're actually making." Adrian found Theo's pen, uncapped it, and drew a line under the marginal sentence. "Put it in. Not in the consent paragraph. In the conclusion. Make the consent real and then show the conditions. That's the honest version."

Theo stared at him. "That's—"

"Ruthless? Yes. I am a man with reputational capital to burn. So are you. This is what we do with it."

Theo took the pen back and did not write anything for a moment.

"You just solved the article," he said.

"I did."

"You're insufferable."

"And yet you moved in with me," Adrian said, and went back to his page.

Theo wrote the sentence out in the margin in his own hand, then rewrote the paragraph. He got through four pages without stopping, and the light changed, and the reader at the far table got up to leave and was replaced by a woman with three books and an air of determination. When Theo finally looked up, Adrian had his feet on the bottom rung of the chair opposite and was reading Theo's pages with a pencil in his mouth and the expression of a man doing arithmetic in his head.

"You changed 'referral' to 'selection' on page six," Adrian said.

"He wasn't referred. He was selected. Referral implies a person who does the referring."

"There is a person who does the referring. That's what the file says."

"The file says a name. The name says a signature. The signature is Fitzwilliam's, and you know it, and if we write 'referral' the entire paragraph reads as though some anonymous administrative process happened to Felix, and it didn't. A man did it. A man who is presently uncharged."

Adrian was quiet. Then he said, "Write 'selection' in the text and 'by Fitzwilliam' in the footnote."

"That's cowardice."

"That's publication. You want to say it in the text, say it and accept that no journal will take it and Felix will never get his name in print. You want the record on file, put it in the footnote and let a hundred graduate students in fifty years find it." Adrian tapped the page. "I've spent my whole life being told I was allowed to say things because of who my father was. I've spent the last year not being allowed to say them because of who my father was. The footnote is the thing that survives him."

Theo looked down at the page, then at Adrian, whose face had gone still in that particular way it did when he'd said something true and hadn't planned to.

"You've thought about this," Theo said.

"I've thought about a lot of things in the last six weeks. There's very little to do in Cowley Road except think and argue with you about dishes."

"We haven't argued about dishes in nine days."

"We've been busy."

They worked until the light failed and the reading room began to empty, and by the time the lamps came on they had eleven pages: opening, methods, three case histories, an argument that turned on the difference between what a record permits and what it conceals, and a conclusion Theo had written in forty minutes without once looking up. Adrian read it twice and said nothing, and then said:

"It's good."

"Say it again."

"No."

"It's the best thing either of us has written."

"It's the best thing we've written together," Adrian said, and then looked faintly embarrassed, as though he'd handed something over he hadn't intended to. "Which is unsurprising. I've never had a reader who actually read."

Theo capped his pen and slid the pages together. "Email it to Felix tonight. He can mark it up and send it back. He asked for that."

"He'll hate the footnote."

"He'll like the footnote. Felix has a longer memory for grudges than either of us. He'll want Fitzwilliam named in print in ninety-point type." Theo stood and stretched, and heard his own spine complain about the last three hours. "He'll fight me on the consent paragraph, though."

"Let him. That's the argument the piece needs."

They packed the pages into Theo's bag and walked down the stone stairs and out into the cold. Broad Street was wet from a rain that had come and gone, and the college gates stood open with their lamps on, and a few late cyclists went by with their lights blinking against the dark.

"We should send it to a journal next week," Adrian said. "If it holds up."

"If Felix doesn't rewrite it."

"If Felix rewrites it, we send it the week after."

They turned up toward the High and Theo found he was doing arithmetic in his head, the way a person does when they are not quite ready to be hopeful and are testing the shape of it anyway. Words in a draft become a submission become a publication; publication becomes a line on a grant application; a grant application becomes October, and October becomes the difference between staying and leaving.

At the corner where they turned off toward Cowley Road, Adrian stopped.

"One thing," he said.

"Yes."

"Felix's ninth chair." He said it flatly, as though he had been holding it the entire way home. "You've written the whole article around the society's first ten years, and every case history we have comes from that period. But the ninth chair was never filled, and Felix says the texter's questions about subject seven are misdirection. If the ninth chair is what matters—"

"Then the article isn't finished," Theo said. "The article is about the wrong decade."

Adrian looked at him in the lamplight, and his face was doing the thing it did when he had arrived somewhere ahead of Theo and was waiting for him to catch up.

"The article is about the wrong decade," he agreed.

They stood there a moment longer, and then walked on toward the flat, carrying eleven pages that had just stopped being the end of something and become the beginning of something else.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 61: The Article Draft · The Missing Seat · Lumen Reads