The Missing Seat

Chapter 64: The Payoff of the Lie

The rain had started again by the time they reached Adrian's flat—that fine Oxford drizzle that didn't fall so much as hang, making the gas lamps bloom and the cobbles slick. Theo shook out his jacket on the landing while Adrian wrestled the lock, shoulder against the swollen door.

Inside, the flat was mostly boxes now. The apartment went at the end of the month; Adrian had been packing for a week and had made almost no progress, because every object seemed to require him to sit down and hold it.

"We could do the ledger again," Theo said. "Cross-reference the accession dates against the matriculation records. If the ninth chair was filled after 1908, there has to be—"

"Theo."

Adrian hadn't turned on the overhead light. He was standing by the window with his back to the room, and something in the flatness of his voice made Theo stop.

"Sit down."

Theo sat on the arm of the sofa, which was the only surface not buried. Rain ticked against the glass.

"I've been trying to work out how to say this for about three weeks," Adrian said. "I keep starting and then deciding it can wait until after the article, or after the wedding, or after whatever happens in October. But you're going to find out eventually, and it has to be from me."

"All right."

"The recording." Adrian turned around. His face in the lamplight looked younger than usual, and worse. "The one from the senior common room. I didn't just believe it."

"I know. You've said. We've—"

"Listen to me." Adrian's voice cracked and he pressed on through it. "I knew it was staged."

Theo felt the sentence arrive and then keep arriving, like a train that doesn't stop where you thought it would.

"I didn't know who did it," Adrian said. "I want you to have that. I didn't run the thing, I didn't commission it, I didn't conspire with anyone. Fitzwilliam put it in front of me and said he'd had it from a source and that I should hear it before I made any decisions about you. And I listened to it once, and I knew."

"How did you know?"

"Because there's a part on it where you're supposed to be talking about the Hooper bequest, and you say the accession number was in the second folio. And you would never say that—you'd know it was the third, and you'd say so, and you'd correct anyone who said otherwise, and you'd enjoy correcting them." Adrian's mouth twisted. "The editor was sloppy. They cut in someone else's voice for the middle eight seconds and it was still me they were trying to fool, and it worked anyway."

Theo looked down at his hands. "Then why."

"Because I wanted it to be true."

The rain kept on. Somewhere below, a bicycle bell.

"I'd been second to you for two years," Adrian said. "You came in from nowhere—a comprehensive, a state school, no connections—and you were better than me. Not by a little. By a distance I couldn't close, and I tried, I genuinely tried. I sat up with your commentaries like they were scripture. And every term there was one more thing you'd understood that I hadn't." He took a breath. "And then someone handed me a reason to despise you. I didn't have to check it. I didn't have to ask you. I had a version of events where I was the one who'd been wronged, and I took it, and I held it, and I used it."

"For eight months."

"Twelve. It was twelve." Adrian's voice was steady now, worse for being steady. "I let you lose your supervisor. I let people think you'd plagiarised. I sat in the Bodleian and watched you eat lunch alone and I felt *right*. That's the part I can't get past. Not that I was fooled. That I was relieved."

Theo stood up. He walked to the window, looked at the street, looked at nothing.

"Say something," Adrian said.

"I need a minute."

Theo made himself breathe. He thought about the senior common room on the fourteenth of February, and the six people who'd stopped speaking to him by the end of month, and the term he'd spent reading in the public library because he couldn't bear the college. He thought about the fact that he had, over the past two months, begun to build his life around the man who had done that.

"When the two of you did it," he said. "Did he know you knew?"

"Fitzwilliam?" Adrian laughed, one syllable. "He knew. That's what he was buying. He didn't need me to be fooled, he needed me to be complicit. He wanted leverage on me as well as on you. And he got it, which is exactly why he never expected me to say any of this out loud." He rubbed his eyes. "He assumed I'd protect myself."

Theo turned around. "You're giving that up."

"I'm giving that up."

"You understand what happens if I—" Theo stopped. "I could walk out of this flat."

"Yes."

"You're standing there in a room full of boxes with no money and a father who's about to sue you and you've just handed me the one thing that could finish you."

"I know."

Theo crossed the room. He didn't hit him. He put his hands on Adrian's shoulders and held on, hard, and Adrian's whole frame flinched and then didn't, and for a moment they stood like that with the rain behind them.

"You should have told me," Theo said. "At any point. The first week, when we were in the archive. The night of the vote."

"Yes."

"You should have told me before we—"

"Yes."

"I'm not going to pretend it doesn't matter," Theo said. "It does. It's going to matter for a while. You have to let me be angry about it on days when I'm angry about it, and not manage me out of it."

"Agreed."

"And you don't get to make it up to me. There's nothing to make up. You just have to be different from here, and I have to decide I believe that, over and over, for as long as it takes." Theo let go and stepped back. "That's the whole deal. That's what's on offer."

Adrian nodded slowly. His eyes were wet and he didn't wipe them.

"Also," Theo said, "you were never second."

"Don't."

"I'm serious. You were never second. I was faster at the syntax and you were better at the argument, and for the first year I used to go back to my rooms after seminar and rewrite my comments because I'd heard yours and they were sharper." He picked up his wet jacket. "If you'd asked me. If you'd ever once asked me instead of deciding, I'd have told you that."

Adrian sat down on the arm of the sofa, where Theo had been. "I've wasted so much."

"Yes," Theo said. "So let's not waste October."

He sat down beside him. For a while neither of them said anything, and the flat ticked with rain and the radiator and the traffic on the Iffley Road. Then Theo took out his phone, because he'd been thinking about it since the station at Lewes and had said nothing to anyone, and he opened the message thread he'd been avoiding.

It had come in the night before: a photograph, badly lit, of a page of a ledger. Along the bottom, one line, in a hand neither of them recognised:

*The ninth chair was never in the society's records. It was in the college's. Ask your friend what he was doing in the second year.*

Theo turned the screen so Adrian could read it.

"The second year," Adrian said, after a moment. "Felix's second year."

"Felix's second year," Theo said. "And the thing about the ninth chair isn't who sat in it. It's who put it there." He looked at the rain on the glass. "If it's a college record, it's in the college archive. And the college archive closes at five, and we have until Monday before Fitzwilliam's solicitor starts asking who's been into the records room."

Adrian reached for his coat.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 64: The Payoff of the Lie · The Missing Seat · Lumen Reads