The Missing Seat

Chapter 66: The Payoff of the Missing Person

The inquiry convened in the Old Schools, in a hall built for disputation. Theo had sat in it once as an undergraduate, half-asleep through a lecture on Aristotle's categories, and the room had felt enormous then. Now, packed with survivors, reporters, three counsel in wigs, and a panel of five, it felt small enough to suffocate.

He and Adrian took seats at the back, near the wall, where they could see everything.

Felix was already in the witness box. He wore the same grey suit he'd worn to the townhouse on Holywell Street, and the same expression — the bland, pleasant attentiveness of a man who had spent forty years being underestimated and had built a career on it.

The chair of the panel, a retired High Court judge named Calder, adjusted her reading glasses. "You have already given a written statement, Mr. Ashworth. The panel would like you to elaborate on the fourth paragraph."

"The ledger," Felix said.

"The ledger, yes. You have stated that you removed two pages from it in the spring of your second year and retained them until last month, when you surrendered them to the inquiry. Is that correct?"

"It is."

"Who instructed you to remove them?"

Felix's gaze moved, unhurried, across the room. It rested for perhaps half a second on Dr. Hale, seated three rows from the front with his hands folded, and then moved on.

"Dr. Edmund Hale," Felix said. "He was a fellow of the college then, and the society's secretary. He told me the ledger contained material that would embarrass living men, and that the ninth chair — a man who had been present at the trials — had asked that his name be struck. I was twenty years old. I believed him."

Hale did not move. His hands stayed folded.

"You later came to believe otherwise."

"I came to believe," Felix said, "that Dr. Hale had three motives, not one. The first was genuine embarrassment. The second was that he had personally administered the trials to at least six men whose consent he had forged. The third was that the ninth chair was not a man at all."

The room went very quiet.

"The name on the removed pages," Felix said, "was Margaret Ellsworth. Subject Eleven in Dr. Hale's own protocol. She was not a member of the society. She was a subject of it, and then, for twenty-two years, its financier — because Dr. Hale told her that if she did not continue to fund the work, he would publish the records of what had been done to her, and she would lose her teaching post, her marriage, and her standing. She paid to remain hidden. He kept her hidden."

Adrian's hand found Theo's under the desk. Neither of them looked at each other.

"Dr. Hale also arranged," Felix continued, "for the eighth chair — a man now deceased — to record a tape. A tape designed to end a student's career, precisely because that student had begun asking about Subject Eleven. The tape was falsified. I know this because I was asked to authenticate it, and I refused, and Dr. Hale found someone else."

The tape. Theo's tape. The one that had taken his supervisor, his fellowship, his standing, and his oldest friend.

Calder's pen had stopped moving. "You are referring to the recording circulated in relation to Mr. Theodore Mercer."

"I am."

"Did you know at the time that Mr. Mercer was innocent?"

Felix was silent for a moment. It was, Theo thought, the only honest pause the man had made all morning.

"I suspected," Felix said. "I told myself suspicion was not knowledge. That is the whole of my defence, and it is not a good one."

The panel took the tea adjournment at eleven and returned at half past. By then Hale's counsel was on his feet, and by one o'clock it was over: the inquiry found the allegations substantiated, referred the matter to the Crown Prosecution Service, and recommended that the college's compensation scheme be extended to Subject Eleven's estate in full.

The hall emptied slowly, in a rustle of notebooks and coat sleeves. Outside, on Catte Street, the reporters were waiting, but Theo did not want to go out yet. He stood by the window at the top of the stairs, watching the last of the panel depart, and heard footsteps behind him.

Felix had his coat over his arm. He looked older than he had in the box.

"Theo."

"Felix."

"I won't ask you to be glad of this. You shouldn't be." Felix reached into his coat pocket and took out a small brass key on a leather fob. "This is yours. From your second year. You left it in your door when you moved out."

Theo looked at it. The key to a room he had not seen in eighteen months, a room in a staircase he had been barred from entering, a life he had been evicted from in a single afternoon.

"Why do you have it?"

"Because when you were removed from the college," Felix said, "someone had to clear your rooms, and Dr. Hale asked me to do it. I kept the key. I told myself I was holding it in case you came back." He turned it over once in his fingers. "You came back. But this doesn't open anything you need anymore."

He held it out. Theo took it. The brass was warm from Felix's pocket.

"I'm sorry I didn't give it to you two months ago," Felix said. "I was still doing arithmetic. I've stopped, now. There's no arithmetic left that works."

He walked down the stairs without waiting for an answer, and the door at the bottom clicked shut behind him.

Adrian came up to stand beside Theo at the window. Below them, on Broad Street, the reporters were still milling. Bicycles went past. A college porter was wheeling a trolley of dining hall chairs.

"A key," Adrian said.

"A key."

"Do you want to go and see the room?"

Theo turned the key once in his palm. The old room had been small, cold in winter, with a window over the lodge gate that he had loved because it let him watch the bats come out over the quad. He had written his first essay in that room. He had cried in it, twice. He had met Adrian in it, the week before everything broke, and they had argued about whether Aristotle's *Poetics* was really about theatre at all, and Adrian had won, and Theo had been furious about it for a week.

"No," he said. "I don't need the room back. I need to know it's still mine."

Adrian looked at him for a long moment. The light off the stone was very bright; it made the lines around his eyes visible.

"Then keep the key," he said, "and stop holding it like it's evidence."

Theo closed his hand around it. It was small, and it weighed almost nothing, and he had carried its absence for eighteen months without once being able to say he was missing it.

He put it in his pocket.

Adrian's hand slid into his, warm and deliberate, and Theo let him, and for a moment they stood at the top of the stairs where anyone could see.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 66: The Payoff of the Missing Person · The Missing Seat · Lumen Reads