The cab dropped them at the top of St Giles', where the evening had gone the colour of weak tea and the colleges wore their lights like old jewellery. Theo paid, and for a moment they stood on the pavement with their bags at their feet, looking at the townhouse.
It looked smaller than he remembered. It always did, in daylight. In his memory it had been vast and candlelit and full of watching men. Now it was just a tall thin Georgian terrace, sash windows blind with dust, a blue plaque for someone else entirely, and a door that needed painting.
"You don't have to do this," Adrian said.
"I know."
"You said that last time as well."
"And I did it last time as well." Theo picked up his bag and walked to the door. He pressed the bell and heard it die somewhere deep in the house, unanswered, the way a bell dies in an empty place. He tried the knocker instead. Three times.
The door opened on a man in his sixties with a caretaker's ring of keys at his belt and reading glasses pushed up onto his head. He looked at Theo, then at Adrian, then at the bags.
"You'll be the ones from the college," he said. "They said someone might come. Something about a box."
"Something about a box," Theo agreed. "We only need ten minutes."
The caretaker stepped back to let them in. The hall smelled of floor polish and cold, and the strip of carpet runner was worn the way carpets wear in houses that have been walked through by decades of men in the same shoes. Their footsteps sounded loud. The paintings had been taken down; you could see the clean rectangles where they'd hung, paler than the wall around them, like ghosts of the men who'd sat for them.
"Everything's going to the archive next week," the caretaker said, leading them along the corridor. "Furniture, the lot. I've been here thirty-one years and they're taking it apart in a morning. They'll put up a lift." He said it the way a man says a diagnosis.
He stopped at the double doors of the dining room and pushed them open.
Theo had rehearsed this. He had decided he would walk in and feel nothing, or feel only the clean cold anger he'd earned, the anger that had carried him through the winter. The room refused him that.
The long table was still there, stripped of cloth, its surface a dull dark shine under a film of dust. The chairs were pushed in. He counted them out of habit — and stopped counting, because he knew what he would find and did not need to see it written in wood. Two hundred years of boys standing with their glasses raised and their voices knotted into some old oath, and the whole thing was a room with a table in it, and a caretaker with a ring of keys.
"Which one was yours?" Adrian asked. He had walked the length of the table and stood at the far end, hands in his pockets, looking back the way Theo had come the first night.
"Fourth on the left. Nearest the window." Theo ran his fingers along the chair back. The dust came away grey on his fingertips. "I sat there and worked out in eleven minutes that I was the only person in the room who hadn't been to school with anyone else at the table. And then you spoke."
"I remember what I said."
"So do I. You said the college's record of the Ellsworth bequest was deficient in three particulars, and you would be glad to be corrected by so diligent a classicist." Theo wiped his fingers on his coat. "You'd been briefed. You'd done it on purpose."
"I'd done it on purpose," Adrian said quietly. "I thought if I embarrassed you into arguing, they'd see how fast you were. I thought it would help you."
"It didn't."
"No. It didn't." Adrian looked down the table at the chair. "It helped me. It made me look like the man who knew what the record said. Which was all I wanted, that year. To be the man who knew."
Theo crossed the room and stood beside him. Their shoulders touched. Out on St Giles' a bicycle bell rang and faded. The caretaker had gone back down the corridor; they could hear him moving things around in the front room, a clink of metal, the patient sound of a man taking a house apart one object at a time.
"Say it," Adrian said.
"Say what?"
"The thing you came here to say. You've been holding it since the cab." He turned his head. "You always do this. You arrange the visit, and then you stand in the room being noble and silent, and I have to drag the actual sentence out of you."
Theo laughed — a short, real laugh, startled out of him by the accuracy of it. "Fine. Here it is." He looked around the room: the dust, the empty walls, the dust-sheeted sideboard, the high dark window with the last of the day behind it. "I came here to find out what happened to Felix. That's what I told myself. I was going to work the room, and be careful, and get access, and then get out with what I needed, and never mind who got cut. I was very proud of that plan."
"It was a reasonable plan."
"It was a rotten plan, and you know it, because you made the same one." He turned to face Adrian properly. "I was going to use you, and I did use you, and the whole time I was telling myself it was for Felix, it was for the truth — and it wasn't. It was for me. I wanted someone to blame, and you were standing right there and you were willing to be blamed. So I blamed you."
Adrian didn't move. "And now?"
"Now I don't." Theo reached into his coat and took out the letter opener. The pearl handle caught what light there was; Margaret Ellsworth's initials showed in it, small and worn, the way initials get worn when a woman has used a knife every day of her adult life. He turned it over. It had stopped being evidence somewhere between Adrian's flat and the flat they'd just emptied. "I came in here a person who wanted to open a case. I'm leaving a person who opens letters."
"You're leaving in about eight minutes, by the meter," Adrian said. "The cab's not waiting."
"Six, if the caretaker locks up early."
"It's the same thing, with you." Adrian took the opener from him, looked at it, gave it back. "You'll do the room. That's what you're like. You'll stand here and hold the blade and think about how you failed him and how you're going to make it up in Bristol tomorrow, and you'll do all of it properly, and you'll feel worse by the end, and then we'll get in the car and you'll be quiet all the way to the ring road."
"That's a very generous reading."
"It's not generous. I've watched you do it four times." He reached up and straightened Theo's collar, which didn't need straightening. "So do it now. I'll wait in the hall."
He was halfway to the door when Theo said, "Adrian." He stopped. "There are still four extra names on that sheet. Four people who were experimented on and never consented and never knew, and the college has spent thirty years making sure nobody counts them. And the editor wants to talk to whoever signed it. I'm going to Bristol tomorrow to hand Felix his own journal back, unread, and I don't know whether he'll open the door, and I don't know if his name is the one I'm going to have to put in the article." He paused. "I wanted to say it out loud in this room. So that if I have to ruin someone, it happens here, and not somewhere I've been happy."
Adrian looked at him for a long moment. Then he said, "All right," and went out.
Theo stood alone in the dining room of the Ninth Chair.
He walked the table once, slowly, the way he had once walked it with a glass in his hand and his heart going and every man in the room watching him. He touched the chair backs. He counted them anyway, all nine, and stood at the ninth one — the one nobody in the surviving records had ever sat in, the seat behind the letter and the secrecy and the money, the seat someone had been willing to send two anonymous letters and one hand-delivered envelope to protect. His envelope. The signer's. And he thought: whoever you are, you know I'm coming, and you know my handwriting now, because it's the last thing I signed before I left this house.
He set the opener flat on the table, blade pointing away from him, the way you set down a card when the hand is over — and left it there.
Then he walked out, closed the doors behind him, and went to find the caretaker.
He was in the front room with a clipboard. He handed Theo a pen.
"Sign for the visit."
Theo looked down. The visitor's book was open on the table, columns ruled in pale blue, a column for the date, a column for the name, and a column for the time in and the time out.
His eyes went down the page.
There, four lines up, in the same hand as the sign-in sheet and the third envelope, fresh enough that the ink still had a sheen on it:
Elm, J. — 4:15 p.m.
Today's date.
He was still in the building.