The Missing Seat

Chapter 79: The Rivalry Rekindled

The Isis office was three doors down from a pub called The Lamb, and by half past nine the pub had already begun to colonise the pavement with men in corduroy holding pints against their chests like breastplates. Theo stepped around them and pushed into the journal's building, where a stairwell smelled of lemon polish and old paper and someone had taped a hand-lettered sign to the banister: PAST THIS POINT, HISTORY IS STILL ARGUED ABOUT.

Edgerton met them on the landing. He was younger than Theo had expected, perhaps forty, in a cardigan that had given up on buttons, and he shook their hands in a way that suggested he did it a great deal and enjoyed it not at all.

"You're the sheet signer," he said to Theo. Not a question.

"I am."

"And you're the Ellsworth man." He turned to Adrian. "Your abstract came in last night. I read it on the train. I've put you both on this afternoon's panel, which I admit is theatre, but it's the useful kind. One hour. Then we talk properly."

"Both of us," Theo said.

"Both of you. Same manuscript, opposite readings. It'll smoke out whoever wrote to me, if nothing else." Edgerton smiled thinly and gestured them toward the reading room. "Behave yourselves."

The panel was held in a converted lecture hall with a high window and a radiator that ticked. Thirty-odd people, mostly academics, a few students, one elderly woman in the front row with a notebook and a pen uncapped before either of them had sat down. Theo laid out his pages. Adrian, across the table, did not look at him. That was the old discipline, and it came back so fast that Theo's mouth went dry with something that was not quite fear.

He went first. Beinecke MS 395, the unbound quire, the watermark that did not match the supposed date of hand. He argued for a late interpolation, an argument that made Ellsworth's methods less a scandal than a slow institutional drift, and the room listened with the particular stillness of people deciding how they felt about you. He was halfway through the third page when Adrian's pen stopped moving.

Theo knew that paused pen. It meant Adrian had found the thing.

"May I?" Adrian said, when Edgerton opened the floor.

"By all means."

Adrian didn't stand. He turned his copy of the folio photograph toward the room. "Dr. Mercer's watermark analysis is beautiful. It's also a red herring, and I'd like to show you why in ninety seconds." He traced the chain lines with a fingertip. "The quire is unbound, which he takes as the anomaly. But the stitching holes are there, and there are four of them, not three. Four holes means it was bound, at some point, in a different sequence, and rebound after. Which means the interpolation — if there is one — is not late. It's early. It's the first thing anyone did to this manuscript."

The room made a low noise. Theo felt it in his sternum.

"That doesn't follow," he said.

"It follows exactly."

"Four holes could be a repair. Binders reuse stations. You're building an argument on the absence of a signature you'd expect to have been trimmed, and then calling the trim your evidence."

Adrian looked up at him then, and there it was — the old light in his face, the one Theo had spent two years hating and four months loving, the one that meant he was enjoying himself. "You'd rather believe Ellsworth was careless than believe he was deliberate. That's not history. That's comfort."

"That's evidence."

"That's a preference dressed as evidence. You do that. You did it at the Archive too and it cost you."

The room had gone very quiet. The elderly woman's pen was moving. Theo heard his own voice come out level. "And you'd rather believe he was a monster than admit you can't prove what he did with the four names you left out of your own citation."

Adrian's jaw moved. Edgerton's eyebrows had climbed, and the room was now definitively awake.

"That's not — " Adrian began, and stopped, and Theo watched him decide, visibly, not to say the thing he wanted to say, because thirty people were watching and the thing was not for them. Adrian set his pen down. "That's a fair charge," he said, at last, quietly. "We'll take it offline."

The panel dissolved into questions that were mostly about the manuscript and only slightly about the two of them standing at the same table with their hands flat on their copies like men at a duel. Afterwards there was sherry in the reading room, and Edgerton worked the room with the efficient patience of a man gathering rope, and Theo found himself against the window with a glass he had not drunk from, watching Adrian across the room do the same.

They looked at each other for four seconds. Then Adrian tilted his head toward the door.

Theo set his glass on the sill and followed him out.

The stairwell was empty and cold. Adrian was already on the second landing, not waiting exactly — moving, fast, so that Theo had to take the stairs two at a time to catch him, and when he did, Adrian turned, and they were very close on a narrow landing with a window showing the street below.

"You called me careless," Theo said.

"I called your argument comfortable."

"Same word in a nicer coat."

"Yes." Adrian's breath was short, though they had only come down a flight. "You called me a monster's apologist in front of my editor."

"I called you an apologist for a man whose records you've read. You know what's in them. I know you know." Theo's voice had gone quiet. "You cited three names and withheld four. That's not history either."

Adrian looked at him for a long moment. Then, unexpectedly, he laughed — one short breath through the nose. "God, I've missed this."

"Arguing with me."

"Arguing with you when you've read the folio and I haven't slept." He took a step, and the step made the landing smaller. "Do you know I nearly threw the abstract away twice? Because I knew you'd be on this panel, and I knew you'd find the stitching holes, and I wanted you to."

"That's perverse."

"That's the whole problem." Adrian's hand came up and did not quite touch Theo's collar, hovering there, and Theo could feel the heat of it through his shirt. "Come outside," Adrian said. "I can't do this under a portrait of some Victorian librarian."

They went down the last flight and out through a side door into the alley. The air had turned since morning; it had the flat metallic smell it gets an hour before snow, and above the rooftops the sky was that bruised Oxford-London grey that means the weather is deciding something. Adrian leaned against the brick and pulled his coat closed and looked at Theo properly for the first time all day.

"You were right," he said. "About the four names. I know I was right about the holes."

Theo laughed despite himself. "We're going to have to stop doing this in public."

"I don't think I'm capable of it." Adrian was smiling now, not the panel smile, the other one, the one that only ever appeared at two in the morning over a shared text. "Edgerton's going to come down that alley in about ten minutes looking for us."

"Then we should be gone."

"Yes," Adrian said. "We should be gone."

They walked out of the alley without discussing it, past The Lamb and its corduroy breastplates, down toward the river, and it began to snow as they reached the bridge — thin, unromantic London snow that would be slush within the hour, but snow. Adrian stopped at the parapet and put both hands on the rail and did not say anything for a while.

Theo stood beside him and waited, because he had learned, finally, that Adrian always said the thing he meant if you gave him the silence for it.

"There's something I have to tell you," Adrian said to the river. "It's not about the manuscript."

Theo's phone buzzed in his pocket. He ignored it. It buzzed again.

"Adrian — "

"Check it," Adrian said. "It might be Felix."

Theo pulled out the phone. Two messages, both from Felix, sent four minutes apart.

*theres a man outside the house*

*dont come alone*

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 79: The Rivalry Rekindled · The Missing Seat · Lumen Reads