The Missing Seat

Chapter 87: The New Seat

The restaurant was on Little Clarendon Street, in a converted terrace house with a blue door and no sign, only a small brass number that caught the streetlight as they came up the pavement. Adrian stopped outside it and looked at the menu in the window for longer than the menu required.

"You've read it four times," Theo said.

"I'm deciding."

"You're stalling."

"I'm deciding and stalling. Both are allowed." Adrian pushed the door open and held it with his shoulder, which was his way of saying after you, and Theo went in.

The room was small and warm, maybe nine tables, all of them full. Candles in squat glasses. A waiter took their coats and led them to a table by the window, a table for two, small enough that their knees would meet under it if either of them forgot. Theo sat with his back to the room, which he had done on purpose, and Adrian sat facing it, which he had also done on purpose, and neither of them mentioned it because it had stopped being a joke about two years ago and become simply how they sat.

They had walked here from the flat. The evening was cold and dry, the sort of October night that makes Oxford look like a stage set for itself, the college walls going amber under the lamps, punts tied up and empty on the Cherwell. It was the first time they'd been back properly since the graduation. The city had not changed. Theo had half expected it to.

"Wine," Adrian said, when the waiter came.

"Which?"

"Whatever the second cheapest red is. I'm not doing the thing where we pretend to know."

"Bring the second cheapest red," Theo told the waiter, and the waiter, who looked about nineteen, wrote it down with the seriousness of a man transcribing a will.

Adrian watched him go. Then he looked at Theo across the candle and said, "So."

"So."

"We're here."

"We're here."

Adrian had a way of going quiet when he was happy, which Theo had learned to read the way you learn to read a difficult hand in a manuscript: the absence of motion meant something. For months Adrian's stillness had been the stillness of someone bracing. Tonight it was different. He had his sleeves pushed up, no watch, no jacket, the collar of his shirt open because he couldn't be bothered, and he was looking around the room at the other tables with mild, unguarded curiosity, the way a man looks at a room he's allowed to be in.

The landlord of the old place on Cornmarket had asked them to leave once, back in February, on the grounds that they were disturbing the other customers by arguing. They had not been arguing. They had been discussing. But the distinction had not survived the landlord's patience.

Theo thought about that now and found it funny, which was new. For a while it had only been humiliating.

The wine came. Adrian did the pouring, which was his self-appointed office, and raised his glass before Theo had lifted his.

"To no more secrets," Adrian said.

Theo picked up his glass. "That's a big toast."

"It's a short one. That's the point."

"You're aware we're still not supposed to know who the third examiner was."

"Not a secret," Adrian said. "An unanswered question. Different thing. Secrets are things you keep from each other." He tilted his glass. "We keep nothing."

They drank. The wine was better than the price suggested, which Theo chose to take as a sign, though he knew better than to believe in signs.

"Say it anyway," Adrian said.

"Say what?"

"You know what. The thing you do."

Theo set his glass down. He looked at the candle for a second, then at Adrian, who was watching him with the flat patient expression he wore when he had already lost an argument and wanted to hear it properly.

"I spent two years thinking I'd failed him," Theo said. "Felix. I thought if I'd pushed harder, gone to the porters, made a scene at the lodge — that he'd still be here. And I built a whole version of myself around that. Someone careful. Someone who doesn't make a scene. It was easier to be that person than to be the one who'd let it happen."

Adrian didn't say anything.

"And then I found out it wasn't my fault at all. It was theirs. The recording, the file, all of it — it was done to him, and to you, and the only thing I could actually do about it was the thing I'd spent two years avoiding. Making noise." He turned the glass a quarter turn. "So I made noise. And he walked across the Bodleian lawn with a cane and he smiled at me, and I still don't entirely know what to do with that."

"Nothing," Adrian said. "You do nothing with it. You let it be a good thing."

"That's appallingly sensible."

"I've had months to work on it."

The waiter came back. They ordered without looking at the menu properly, which meant Adrian ordered the lamb and Theo ordered whatever Adrian had pointed at, and they ended up with two identical plates, which made Adrian laugh — a short, real laugh, not the dry one he used in seminars.

They ate. The room filled and emptied the way small rooms do, a couple leaving and another arriving, the waiter threading between tables with a bottle in each hand. At some point the candle guttered and Adrian reached over and cupped his hand behind it to shield it while the flame came back, which was a small thing, and Theo watched him do it, and thought: this is the whole thing, this is the actual whole thing, this is what it looks like when it's fine.

"Tell me about the corrections," Adrian said, spearing a potato.

"They're minor. Chapter two, the dating of the second recension. Chapter four, the incompleteness argument — I overclaimed. I need to soften it."

"By when?"

"The end of the month. Errata in writing, to the faculty office."

"And after that?"

Theo shrugged. "Then it's a book. Or it isn't. Someone will decide."

"Cambridge will come through," Adrian said.

"You don't know that."

"I know you. That's close enough."

Theo looked at him. There was a version of this evening he had imagined a year ago, in the worst of it, in the weeks when Adrian was the man who had ruined him and every glance across a reading room was a knife — in that version, this table did not exist. There was no candle. There was no second-cheapest red. There was just the long hallway of the archive and a locked door.

He reached into his jacket.

"What's that," Adrian said.

Theo set it on the tablecloth between them: the letter opener, pearl-handled, the blade dulled with age, eight inches of somebody else's nineteenth century. He had carried it since March. He had never once used it for anything but opening envelopes, which he supposed was the point, and also not the point at all.

"I'm putting it away," Theo said. "Properly. In the flat, in a drawer, and I'm not carrying it anymore."

Adrian looked at the thing on the cloth. He didn't reach for it.

"You don't have to explain it to me," he said.

"I know. I'm explaining it anyway."

"All right."

Theo put it back in his pocket. He would put it in the drawer when they got home. He meant it.

Adrian finished his wine and set the glass down and said, "There's a dog I've been looking at. On the rescue site. A greyhound. She's four and she's very ugly."

"Greyhounds aren't ugly."

"This one is. But she's retiring, is the word they use. She's finished racing. She needs a sofa."

Theo laughed. It surprised him a little, the sound of it, in this small room, with the candle between them.

"Get the dog," he said.

"I might."

"Get the dog, Adrian."

"I'll think about it," Adrian said, and smiled, and it was the smile he had, the one that started at the corner of his mouth and took its time, and Theo had spent a long time — longer than he liked to admit — believing he would never be on the receiving end of it.

The waiter brought the bill. Theo paid, though they'd argued about this before and would again; Adrian let him, which was its own kind of statement. They stood. Theo took his coat from the hook and held Adrian's while he got into it.

Outside it had got colder. Little Clarendon Street was quiet, the shops dark, one bicycle leaning against a wall with its lock slack. Adrian turned up his collar and looked at the street and said, "Home?"

"Home," Theo said.

They started walking. Theo reached over and took Adrian's hand out of his pocket and held it, and the pearl handle of the thing in his coat sat warm against his hip like an object that had been returned to its shelf, and the city went on being Oxford, stone and lamplight all the way down to the corner, and neither of them said anything else for a while because there was nothing left that needed saying.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 87: The New Seat · The Missing Seat · Lumen Reads