The Painted Lie

Chapter 12: The Confession

The knock had come three times, quick and uneven, and then nothing. Michele stood with his hand still raised toward the door, his heart hammering against his ribs, waiting for a fourth that did not come.

Lorenzo moved past him and pressed his eye to the shutter's seam. "Gone," he said. "A boy. Barefoot, by the sound of it."

"What did he want?"

"He delivered his message and ran. That's how it works." Lorenzo crossed to the table where the note lay—a scrap of paper no larger than a playing card. He had read it twice already. Now he turned it over, as if the back might hold something the front did not.

Michele watched him. The candle guttered, and the shadows in the studio shifted like water. On the easel, the half-finished portrait of a wool merchant's wife stared back at him with wet, patient eyes.

"You said Alessandro was your student," Michele said quietly. "You said that when I first asked."

Lorenzo did not look up. "I said many things."

"Who is he, Lorenzo?"

A long silence. Outside, a cart rattled over the cobbles, and someone laughed drunk in the street below. Florence going about its life, oblivious to the trap closing inside one small room above a dyer's shop. Lorenzo set the note down and turned. His face in the candlelight was stripped of everything—the irony, the charm, the easy deflect. What remained was older. Tired in a way Michele had never seen on him before.

"He is my brother," Lorenzo said.

Michele had braced himself for something else. A lover. A collaborator. A name from the old conspiracy. Not this.

"Your—" He stopped. "You told me your family was gone. The plague. You said you had no one."

"I said my brother died three years ago. That part is true—as far as anyone knows. I made it true." Lorenzo's voice was flat, as if he were reciting a ledger entry. "I paid for a death certificate. I arranged for a body to be buried under his name. A poor wretch from the Ognissanti who had no one to claim him. I watched the coffin go into the ground and I stood there and let our neighbors weep on my shoulder."

"Why would you do that?"

"Because Cosimo de' Medici wanted him dead, and a dead man is of no use to anyone. Not to Cosimo. Not to the Signoria. Not to the men who come in the night." Lorenzo picked up the note and crumpled it slowly in his fist. "As long as Alessandro was dead, he was safe. As long as Cosimo believed he had nothing left to threaten me with, I was free."

Michele's mind struggled to fit the shape of it. "But you are not free. Cosimo has your debt—"

"Which is the joke of it. The debt was never the leash. The debt was the pretext. Cosimo has held my paper for six years, and for six years I have paid the interest and kept my head down, and he has let me, because he thought he held only money. Then last month someone told him otherwise. Someone told him Alessandro lived."

"The brother-in-law," Michele said. "The man with the silver clasp."

"Giulio. My sister's husband." Lorenzo's mouth twisted. "He rides for Cosimo now. He found the payments I make to the monks at Santa Croce—the ones who keep Alessandro hidden. He put two and two together and sold the answer to the highest bidder, which is always Cosimo."

The candle spat. Michele took a step toward him, then stopped, unsure whether he was permitted. Lorenzo's hands were shaking. He had not let go of the crumpled note.

"So they took him," Michele said. "To make you do something."

"They took him to force me to give them names. Everyone in the old circle. The men who still write the pamphlets, who still smuggle the banned books in from Basel, who still believe—" He broke off. "Alessandro knows some of them. Not all. Enough. If they put him to the question, he will break, because he is nineteen and he has never been hurt in his life. I kept him safe so carefully that I made him soft, and now they will open him like an oyster."

"Thursday," Michele said. "The escape is Thursday. You told me—"

"Thursday is when they move him. Out through the southern gate, down to the river, and onto a boat for Rome. In Rome he will be tried by men who have already written the verdict. The trial will take a morning. He will be burned in the Campo dei Fiori and his ashes will go into the Tiber and Cosimo will send me the bill for the firewood." Lorenzo's voice cracked, just once, on the word firewood. He pressed the heel of his hand against his eye. "That is what happened to the last one. A printer from Lyon. I knew him. I have his last letter in the chest under my bed."

Michele stood very still. The studio smelled of linseed and dust and the faint sourness of Lorenzo's fear. He thought of the prison by the leather market, of the crowd of women and old men waiting with their bundles of bread and their hopeless faces. He thought of the boy who had led him there.

"So we go tonight," he said.

Lorenzo lowered his hand. "What?"

"You said it yourself: Thursday is when they move him. If they move him before we are ready, we lose him forever. We go tonight."

"There is no plan for tonight. I have spent three weeks—"

"Then we make one." Michele heard his own voice and was surprised by it. It did not sound like the voice of a painter who haggled over ultramarine and kept a begging bowl under his bed. It sounded like someone else's. "You are not the only one who knows how the city works, Lorenzo. I have painted half the guards in the Bargello. I know which of them drink and which of them kneel. I know the man who keeps the keys at Santa Maria Nuova, and I know the scribe who forges episcopal letters for a fee. I have no money, but I have hands, and I have a name that opens certain doors, and I am not going to sit here while you watch your brother burn."

Lorenzo stared at him. Then something crossed his face that Michele had never seen there either—something raw and unguarded that he immediately tried to hide, and could not.

"Why?" Lorenzo asked. "You owe me nothing. Less than nothing. I dragged you into this. I used you. I stood in your studio and told you pretty lies so I could keep the inkwet and the brushes and the excuse of you, and you—" He stopped. "You should walk out that door right now and never come back."

"You kissed me," Michele said.

Lorenzo went still.

"You kissed me and then you said it was a mistake. I have thought about that for two weeks. I have thought about very little else, which is inconvenient, because I am trying to finish a portrait." Michele's mouth was dry. "I don't know what you meant by it. But I know you did not lie when you did it. You lie about everything else. You did not lie about that."

Lorenzo opened his mouth and closed it. For a long moment the only sound was the candle and the distant cart and the city going on being a city.

"I lied about Alessandro," he said at last. "I have lied about money and names and the reason I needed a studio in the first place. I have lied to every person in this city who has ever been kind to me, including my own sister." He took a breath. "I did not lie to you when I kissed you. And then I told you it was a mistake, which was the worst of all of it, because it was not."

Michele crossed the room in three steps and took Lorenzo's face in both hands. His thumbs pressed into the hollows under Lorenzo's cheekbones. There was no plan, no cleverness, no painterly composition in it—only the two of them in a small room above a dyer's shop, holding each other's gaze for the space of a heartbeat.

"Then stop lying," Michele said. "Tonight. Tell me everything you know about where he is held, and we will get him out, and after that you can decide whether it was a mistake."

Lorenzo's hand closed over Michele's wrist. He did not pull it away. He held it there, palm against Michele's pulse, and for the first time since Michele had met him he looked like a man who had been given permission to want something.

"All right," he said. His voice was unsteady but it was his own. "Not Thursday. Tonight."

And then, before Michele could answer, there was a second knock at the door.

This one was slow. Four deliberate strokes, the last one dragged, the sound of a man who wanted whoever stood behind the door to know exactly who he was and to have time to be afraid.

Lorenzo's face drained of all color. He looked at Michele, and Michele looked at the door, and somewhere in the street below, a dog began to bark.

"That is not one of mine," Lorenzo whispered.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 12: The Confession · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads