The Painted Lie

Chapter 24: Aftermath of Truth

Michele climbed the three flights to his old room above the cordwainer's shop with his satchel against his chest, as if it held something breakable. He had not slept there in weeks. The stair smelled the same—of glue and leather scraps and the tallow the cordwainer burned because he was too stingy for wax.

The door was unlocked. Nothing worth stealing, and he'd told the landlord he might be back. Inside, dust had drawn a grey skin over everything: the table, the jars of pigment, the pallet in the corner where he'd first learned to sleep alone in Florence.

He set the satchel down. His hands wanted something to do. He found himself straightening the jars, then unstopping the little pot of malachite, then stoppering it again.

He should have felt lighter. That was the strange thing. He had walked out of the safe house with the taste of a clean anger in his mouth, the good hard anger that comes when a man finally says the true word aloud. He had expected it to last.

It lasted until the second turning of the street. By the third he was hearing Lorenzo's voice again—*It is arithmetic*—and then the other voice underneath it, the one Lorenzo had used the night before when he'd said, quietly, without looking up, *I have not lied to you about everything.*

Which was, Michele understood, a confession and a warning at the same time, like most things Lorenzo said.

He sat down on the pallet. He should paint. There was the widow's face waiting in his satchel, half-formed on the panel, and the panel itself was cracked at the edge and needed mending first. He did not move.

Two days he kept himself busy, which is to say he kept himself from thinking. He went to the Mercato and bought a loaf and did not think about the way Lorenzo tore bread with his thumbs instead of cutting it. He walked to Santa Croce and stood before the frescoes and did not think about the light in them. He threw away the pot of light-mixed green, then dug it out of the rubbish bin that same night and set it back on the shelf, dirtied, useless, because throwing it away had felt like losing an argument.

On the second evening someone knocked.

Michele did not get up at first. He sat with his back to the door and let the knocking come again, and only when it came a third time did he call out, "It is late."

No answer. Then a folded paper slid under the door, and footsteps went away down the stairs.

He let the paper lie there a long while. He knew what it would be. That was precisely why he did not want it—because to open it was to admit that he had been waiting for it.

He opened it.

The hand was neat, small, a clerk's hand, not Lorenzo's, which was large and careless. But the words were his.

*Michele. I have no defense that you would call a defense. I told you the truth about Domenico only after; you would be right to say that the arithmetic ran the other way. I will not ask you to forgive it.*

*But I do have one thing left to say, and it should not be said in a letter, and it should not be said in front of anyone.*

*Say where. I will come. If you tell me not to come, I will not.*

*L.*

Michele read it twice and then a third time, and the third time he noticed the L. Just the one letter, as if the name itself were too much to write on paper that might be found. That was Lorenzo. Even apologizing, he was careful.

He sat at the table with the letter and no lamp lit. Below, the cordwainer's hammer went on past dark.

*If you tell me not to come, I will not.* That was the sentence he kept returning to. It was either a genuine offering or the most careful thing Lorenzo had ever written, and he could not tell which, and the not-telling was the whole of his problem.

He took out a scrap and wrote three lines. He read them, tore the paper, and wrote three more.

Then he put his cloak on and went out to have the letter delivered, because he did not trust himself to hold it until morning.

He chose the church of Orsanmichele, at the hour after the midday meal when the traders were back at their stalls and the nave stood mostly empty. It was public, which was the point. Whatever Lorenzo had to say, he would say it where there were a dozen witnesses, and half the Bargello in the city knew Lorenzo's face by now, and a man is careful about what he says in a church.

*Only do not sit beside me,* Michele had written. *Across the aisle is close enough.*

He arrived early and chose a bench where a pillar gave him something to rest his shoulder against. He did not pray. He watched the doors.

Lorenzo came in quietly, as he did everything, and stopped at the font, and crossed himself—Michele had never known whether he meant it—and then walked the length of the nave without looking left or right and sat down across the aisle, three benches back, with his hands folded, looking at nothing.

For a moment neither of them spoke. Two men in a church, not looking at each other, is the most ordinary thing in the world.

"You came," Michele said, low.

"You said to."

"I said not to sit beside me."

"You said across the aisle. I am across the aisle."

Michele almost smiled, and caught it before it reached his mouth. "Say your one thing."

Lorenzo was silent long enough that a woman's heels crossed the whole nave and went out the far door.

"I have told you the truth in pieces," he said at last. "Every piece was true. That is what I would say in my own defense, if I were defending myself, and I am not. The trouble is that the pieces always came after, never before. I gave you the piece about Domenico when you had already met him. I gave you the piece about the chest when you had already found it."

"You gave me the chest when I asked."

"Yes. When you asked."

"That is something."

"It is not enough, and I am not pretending it is." Lorenzo's voice stayed flat and careful, the voice he used in rooms where other people were listening. "This is what I have come to say, and I will say it once. You were right that the painting has a lie at the bottom of it, and you were right that a lie at the bottom of a painting does not stay at the bottom. It rises. It gets into the hands. And I have been treating the lie like a tool I could pick up and put down, and you have been treating it like a sin, and I think—"

He stopped.

"You think what."

"I think you are more right than I am. That is the thing I did not want to write in a letter."

Michele looked at the floor. Somewhere behind them a priest was moving a candle.

"That is not an apology," he said.

"No."

"You still have not told me what you are protecting me from."

"No. I have not." Lorenzo's hands stayed folded. "And I will not until the portrait is finished. That was your condition. I remember it."

"You remember everything."

"I remember everything," Lorenzo agreed, without pride.

The woman's heels came back, and stopped, and knelt somewhere near the front. Neither of them moved.

"Here is my one thing," Michele said. "You may have it, and then we are even for one afternoon." He took a breath. "I walked out on you, and I meant it, and I slept badly, and I went on meaning it. And then your letter came and I read it three times like a boy."

Lorenzo did not turn his head.

"So I will finish the portrait," Michele said. "I said I would. I keep my word even when I am angry, which is more than some people in this church can say. You will bring me what I need—the panel, the pigments, the story of who this widow is supposed to be and why anyone would risk their neck to send her out of the city—and I will paint it. And when it is done, you will open the chest in front of me and empty it on the table and tell me where every paper came from and who it will hang. That is the condition. That was always the condition."

"That is a fair condition."

"Do not agree so quickly. There is one more." Michele turned his head at last and looked at him across the aisle. Lorenzo was sitting very still, in profile, and the church light did not flatter him; it never had. "Do not lie to me again about where you are going when you go out at night. I do not ask to come. I do not even ask to know everything. I ask not to be managed. If you tell me it is better that I do not know, say that. But say it. Do not hand me half a sentence and call it the truth."

For a moment Lorenzo said nothing. Then he nodded, once.

"You have my word," he said. "Such as it is. It is worth more than you have reason to think."

"I know what it is worth," Michele said. "That is why I am asking for it in a church."

They left separately, Michele first, and outside the light had gone the flat white of the afternoon and the stalls were shouting again. He walked home with his hands in his sleeves and did not look back, and Lorenzo did not follow, and that was the whole of the meeting.

At home he mended the cracked panel with a little glue and a strip of linen, and set it to dry against the wall, and then he sat and looked at the empty place where the widow's face would be.

He was still angry. He was aware of it the way you are aware of a tooth—present, tender, not going anywhere. But under the anger something had loosened that had been clenched for days, and he could not decide whether that loosening was the beginning of forgiveness or only the end of a quarrel, and he decided in the end that it did not matter. A man does not have to name a thing to sit down and work.

He lit the lamp. He would need to grind fresh malachite in the morning—real malachite, this time, the honest green, the one that looked like a leaf in light.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 24: Aftermath of Truth · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads