The Painted Lie

Chapter 26: The Testimony

The Bargello's prison smelled of wet stone and old urine, and the guard who led Michele down the corridor walked with the bored unhurriedness of a man who had done this ten thousand times. Michele kept his hands still at his sides. He had paid a week's wages for this visit, and he had a story ready—old teacher, nearly dead, a debt of gratitude—but no one had asked him anything, which frightened him more than questions would have.

The cell was narrow, lit by a slot of a window too high for a man to reach. Maestro Paolo sat on a straw pallet with his back against the wall, thinner than Michele remembered, his great beard gone gray and tangled, but his eyes when they lifted were the same. He looked at Michele for a long moment and then began, very quietly, to laugh.

"Michele." His voice was cracked from disuse. "You. Of all the fools in Florence."

"I brought bread." Michele knelt and put it in his hands. Paolo's fingers were cold and knotted with the old palsy that had always made him mix his colors with a shaking hand, and which had never once made him get a color wrong.

"Sit," Paolo said. "The floor is filthy, which is why I have it all to myself." He tore the bread and ate like a man who had decided long ago to keep living out of spite. "How did you get in?"

"Money. And a lie."

"Good. You were always better at lying than at keeping your mouth shut." He chewed. "You've gotten thin and you've gotten hard. Something's happened to you."

Michele had rehearsed a hundred openings and discarded them all. What came out was: "Fra' Domenico."

Paolo stopped chewing. For a moment the only sound was the drip of water somewhere beyond the wall.

"So," he said at last. "You found him."

"He's in the city. He's working with men I'm—" Michele stopped. "He testified against you. He stood in the court and said you had sold consecrated ground to the Jews for burial rites, that you mixed your pigments with the ash of holy relics, that you—" He couldn't finish. Even now, saying it made his hands shake. "They have you in here because of him. I want him destroyed."

Paolo set the bread down on the straw. He was silent so long that Michele thought he had decided not to answer, and then he said, "He was telling the truth."

The corridor seemed to tilt.

"What?"

"Not the way they wrote it. The way he *said* it—yes. I did sell that ground. There were four Jewish families in Santa Croce who could not bury their dead in the plague year because the cemetery was full and the priests would not open the walls, and I had a field behind my workshop and I gave it to them, and I put my hand on the earth with them and I said the prayers I knew, because they were people and they were dying and I was a Christian man who did not know what else to do." Paolo's voice did not rise. "Domenico knew. He came to me before he ever went to the court, and he begged me—*begged* me, Michele—to denounce myself first, lightly, to take a small penance, before the cardinal got hold of it and made it into a war."

"What cardinal?"

"Borgia." Paolo said the name the way a man says a winter he has survived. "Cesare's man. He wanted the Jews of Florence under his hand—their money, their houses, everyone who sheltered them. He needed a heresy, and a heretic, and a story in which the Church was merciful. He had Domenico's brother."

Michele stared at him.

"In a cell like this one, three streets over," Paolo said. "Domenico's younger brother, a lay brother in the San Marco house, who had written letters to a Venetian printer about reform. Twenty-three years old. They told Domenico that they could hang the brother on Wednesday for heresy, or he could stand in a court on Monday and give them the heretic they were actually looking for, and the brother would walk free with a penance and a new name in another city." He ran a thumb along his knuckles. "He came to me and told me all of it. He wept. He asked me to understand that he had no choice, and I told him he had no choice, and I told him to do it. I told him to save the boy."

"You told him to destroy you."

"I told him to save his brother. There is a difference, and it took me a year in this cell to find out whether I believe it." Paolo smiled, and there was nothing gentle in it. "He has never forgiven himself. I have forgiven him, which is the cruelest thing I have ever done to a man. He visits. Twice a year, in secret, and he prays with me, and he cannot look at me, and I hold his hands until he can bear to look, and then he leaves. He is in torment, Michele. He has been in torment longer than I have."

Michele found that he was standing. He did not remember standing. "Then why," he said, "didn't you denounce Borgia? If you knew—"

"Who would I have denounced him to?" Paolo said. "The Signoria, who wanted Florence quiet? The cardinal's own court? I tried, once, in my second month here, and the friar who took my confession told me that if I said it again they would put the boy on the gallows in Santa Croce and make Domenico watch, and then hang him beside his brother. So I have said nothing for eleven years." He looked up at Michele, and his eyes were wet and entirely dry at once. "You should go. This room has ears, and yours are younger than mine."

"I can't leave him rot in there and let Borgia use him for the rest of his life."

"No," Paolo agreed. "You cannot. But you cannot free me either, Michele. I have made my peace. What I want from you is not my freedom."

"Then what?"

"The truth," Paolo said. "Written down. Domenico's testimony as he *gave* it, not as it was recorded—the court wrote it up to make him the villain and me the greater one, and the original is sealed in the cardinal's own archive, because the cardinal could not burn it. He needed it as a weapon, and a weapon is only good if you keep it. Find it. Make it visible. Borgia cares about nothing but power, and power is only worth what people believe. If Florence knows what he did to a twenty-three-year-old boy to buy himself a heresy—" He shrugged. "He loses a little belief. It is not much. It is what I have."

Michele knelt again and took the old man's hands, and they were still cold. "I'll bring it to you."

"Bring it to the printer in the Via dei Servi," Paolo said. "I will be dead by the spring, either way. But bring it to me first, so I can read it."

——

Lorenzo was on the stairs at the safe house when Michele came back, and he must have read something in Michele's face, because he stepped aside and let him pass without a word, which Michele had not expected and did not thank him for.

"Paolo told me everything," Michele said at the top of the stairs. "Domenico was coerced. The man who coerced him was Borgia's man, and there is a written testimony in the cardinal's archive that was never burned, because Borgia needed it. I need you to get it."

Lorenzo had gone very still. "You know what you are asking."

"I know exactly what I'm asking." Michele turned. The room where they had slept side by side—before—was to his left, and he did not go toward it. "You broke into a bishop's house in Ferrara. You broke out of the Bargello's yard in Rome with me on your back. Don't tell me the cardinal's archive is beyond you."

"It isn't the walls," Lorenzo said. "It's what's in there. The archive holds everything Borgia has on every family in Florence. If they find us inside it, it isn't a hanging. It's a question no one walks away from." He was quiet a moment. "And it means I stop everything else. The chest. The letters. Alessandro."

"You told me the arithmetic was mine to do." Michele's voice came out harder than he had intended. "This is the arithmetic. I will not put one more brushstroke on your widow's face until I know whether the men you work for are also using me the way Borgia used Domenico." He held Lorenzo's gaze. "Get me in. Tomorrow night. Or I burn the painting and the sketch and every green I ever mixed, and you can explain to Alessandro why his dead wife has no face."

Lorenzo looked at him for a long time. Then he crossed to the table and sat down and drew the candle toward him, and when he spoke it was in the flat voice of a man laying out a map.

"The archive is in the cardinal's palace, behind the chapel, second floor. Two locks, one keyed and one lettered. There's a clerk named Tommaso who sleeps in the antechamber and who cannot be bought, only avoided—he goes to matins at the Carmine on Wednesdays and Fridays and is gone about an hour." He looked up. "Tomorrow is Thursday. That means Thursday night, or we wait four days, and in four days a Bargello man has already been to your dyer's door asking after your greens."

Michele's skin went cold. "Then tomorrow."

"Tomorrow." Lorenzo reached for a second candle and lit it from the first, and the two flames stood side by side on the table, and neither of them moved. "I'll need you inside with me. Not as a lookout. The outer lock is lettered—twelve rings, and the setting for each night is a date in the papal calendar. You're the only man I know who can read a calendar without wanting an explanation for why."

"That's the reason you're taking me?"

"No." Lorenzo's eyes came up, and there was something underneath the flatness that Michele did not want to name. "I'm taking you because when I am in that room, I want one person in Florence who will tell me the truth about what I am looking at."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 26: The Testimony · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads