The Painted Lie

Chapter 28: The Public Reading

The dyers' square smelled of indigo and wet wool, and the bell was already in the girl's hands when Michele arrived — small, bronze, green with age, the clapper wrapped in rag so it would not wake the quarter before he gave the word.

"He said you'd come before the second hour," the girl whispered. She could not have been more than twelve. Her hands shook.

"He was right."

"You're the painter." She said it like an accusation. "The one the Bargello's asking after."

"I'm the painter," Michele said. "What's your name?"

"Chiara."

"Then hold the bell, Chiara. And when I lift my hand, not before." He pressed a coin into her palm and she stared at it as though it might be a trick. "Not before," he repeated.

The square was a crooked elbow of stone between the dye-works and the river, the sort of place where washerwomen argued over water rights and nobody important ever came. That was the whole point of it. At the far end, a cart stood abandoned, its shafts resting on the ground, and Lorenzo waited beside it with a lantern hooded in red cloth and the stolen papers rolled inside his coat like a wound he was carrying under his ribs.

"You're late," Lorenzo said.

"I'm exactly on time. There's a difference." Michele climbed onto the cart. From here he could see the western edge of the square, where the first loaf-shaped figures were beginning to gather — a woman with a basket, two men from the wool guild, a priest from San Frediano who had reason to resent the cardinal and every reason to be here.

How had they known? He hadn't told them.

Lorenzo followed his gaze. "I sent word," he said quietly. "Four houses. That's all. Word does the rest."

"You sent word," Michele repeated. "Without asking me."

"You wanted a crowd." Lorenzo's jaw tightened. "You can be angry with me after."

Michele turned away from him and faced the square, and by the second hour it was no longer a square. It was people — forty, then eighty, then a body of them so thick the far lane closed up, dockworkers and dyers with their hands still blue, women from the Ognissanti quarter, two friars who should not have been there, a boy perched on a wall so high he might break his neck. Someone had brought a torch. Someone else was selling chestnuts, which Michele found obscene and wonderful in equal measure.

"What is this?" a man near the front called. "What's the word?"

Michele raised his hand.

Chiara rang the bell — three strokes, thin and bright, and the square went quiet as if the sound had cut a rope.

"My name is Michele di Bartolo," he said. His voice came out lower than he meant it, and he let it. "I'm a painter. Six weeks ago my master, Paolo della Rovere, was taken from his workshop in Via dei Cartolai and thrown into the Stinche for a crime he did not commit. He is accused of selling state secrets to the Sforza. There is no proof. There has never been any proof. There is only a man who wanted his studio, and a cardinal who wanted him silent."

The word *cardinal* moved through the crowd like wind through barley.

Michele drew the roll of paper from Lorenzo's hand. It was warm from Lorenzo's body. He unrolled it and held it to the torchlight so the seal showed — Borgia's own countersign, the wax still bearing the ridge of the ring.

"This is the deposition of Domenico Vespucci, wool merchant, sworn before a notary of the Signoria in the month of March." He read slowly, so the far edge of the square could hear, so the words would not fly past too fast to be caught. He read the confession: that Domenico had been summoned to the palace of a cardinal, that he had been told his debts would be forgiven and his brother's appointment secured, that he had named Maestro Paolo as the agent of a correspondence he had never seen, and that he had done so because he had been told it was that or the galleys.

A woman near the front began to weep. It was not grief. It was the sound of a knot being undone.

Michele held up the second paper. "And this is the cardinal's hand. His countersign. His seal upon the testimony he procured. The same cardinal who has spent five years telling Florence that his hands are clean."

Someone shouted a name Michele didn't catch. Someone else answered, and the name went around the square — Borgia, Borgia, a chant beginning, low and terrible.

"Maestro Paolo is innocent," Michele said. "He is innocent in the eyes of God and in the eyes of any court that reads these papers. And I will tell you what happens to innocent men in this city when a cardinal needs a scapegoat —"

The first stone came from the dark end of the lane, and it hit the cart and rolled.

The second came faster and found the shoulder of a dockworker who went down swearing. The crowd surged, broke, reformed. Michele saw the black-and-yellow of the cardinal's household coming up the lane from the river, twelve men at least, torches and iron, and behind them a mounted man in a robe, walking his horse into the square as though he owned the stones.

He did own the stones. It was Borgia himself.

"Seize the painter," the cardinal said. He did not shout. He never needed to. "Seize the traitor who forges papers and slanders princes. And seize that man beside him."

Lorenzo had already turned. He was not running toward the guards — he was running toward the lane on the north side, and Michele understood a half-breath later that he had chosen it long ago, that there was a route out of this square that Lorenzo had mapped before Michele had ever climbed onto the cart.

But Michele did not follow. Not yet.

"Read it!" he shouted. He shoved the roll of paper at the priest of San Frediano, who caught it against his chest as though it were a child. "Read it aloud! Copy it! Every one of you copy it and carry it out of this square tonight — they cannot arrest a whole city!"

The priest looked at the paper. Then he looked at the cardinal. Then he opened his mouth and began, in a voice that carried better than Michele's ever had, to read.

The crowd closed around him like water over a stone.

Michele jumped from the cart.

He went north. A hand caught his wrist at the mouth of the lane and hauled him in — Lorenzo, breathing hard, his coat torn at the shoulder, blood at his lip from a stone or a fist Michele hadn't seen land.

"Left," Lorenzo said. "Then the stairs — no, not the street, the stairs behind the tanner's —"

"He'll have men in the streets."

"Then we don't use the streets."

They ran. Behind them the square had become a noise Michele would remember for the rest of his life: the chant of Borgia's name, the priest's voice rising over it, the bell of the dyers' square ringing and ringing and ringing, Chiara pulling the rope without waiting for anyone's hand.

At the base of the stairs, Lorenzo stopped and pressed his back to the wall and looked at Michele with an expression Michele couldn't read — fear, yes, but something else underneath it, something that looked almost like relief.

"The chest," Lorenzo said. "It's already at the Cestello. Everything in it. The boat is at the badia landing."

"You moved the chest?"

"I moved the chest two nights ago," Lorenzo said. "Because I knew this would happen. Because I knew the moment you read those papers aloud, Borgia would burn this city down to find us, and we would have exactly one road out."

Michele stared at him. Two nights ago. Before Michele had even chosen the square.

"You knew I'd do it."

"I hoped." Blood ran from Lorenzo's lip down his chin, and he did not wipe it. "I've been hoping since the beginning, Michele, that you were the kind of man who would."

Then there were boots on the stairs above them, and the hunt began.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 28: The Public Reading · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads