The Painted Lie

Chapter 38: The New Plan

The barn smelled of wet hay and blood. Michele had torn his own shirt into strips to bind Lorenzo's arm, and the strips were already dark. Lorenzo sat against the timber wall with his eyes half closed, breathing shallow, his good hand pressed over the wound as if he could hold himself shut.

"We can't stay here past dark," Michele said. He was crouched by the door, watching the marsh road through the gap in the boards. "If Guardi found a boy to call us out, he'll find a boat to put ashore."

"Then we go back to the cottage."

"And then what? Sit in the reeds until your arm rots and Ricci's men find us by torchlight?" Michele stood. His hands were shaking and he hated it. He wiped them on his breeches. "We've been running since the villa. Running is the one thing we're good at, and it's getting us nowhere."

Lorenzo opened his eyes. Fever had made them brighter than they should have been. "You have a plan that isn't running."

"I have the letters."

Lorenzo was quiet for a moment. Then he said, very evenly, "No."

"You don't even know what I mean to do with them."

"I know you. You mean to spend them." Lorenzo tried to shift his weight and winced, his breath catching. "Michele, those documents are the only thing keeping us alive. The moment they stop being a threat, we stop being useful."

"They're the only thing keeping *me* alive," Michele said. "You, they don't need to keep alive at all. You're the one they want to see hang from a window in the Piazza."

"Lower your voice."

"There's no one here." But Michele lowered it anyway. He came and knelt beside Lorenzo, close enough to feel the heat coming off him. "Listen to me. The tube is worth something to exactly one man in Florence—the man who can make Tommaso stop. Not Ricci. Ricci is a puppet with his hands clean and his name off the page. Someone put him there. Someone Tommaso answers to."

Lorenzo's jaw tightened. "You're speaking of the Cardinal."

"Borgia. Yes." Michele had thought it through on the walk from the marsh, step by step, until the shape of it was as clean as a drawing. "Tommaso holds the port, Ricci holds the dungeon, but a cardinal in Rome holds *them*. Whoever wants these ships blockaded and these refugees sold wants nothing traced to his own hand. That's what the letters are. Traced hands. Dates, names, sums, and a seal I've already smelled the wax of."

"You've read them."

"I read enough before we ran." That was a lie, mostly. He had read a little. But he had seen the seal, and the seal was enough to guess whose desk it came from, and a guess was all he had.

Lorenzo let his head fall back against the timber. "And you propose to write to him. To a cardinal. From a barn."

"Better from a barn than from a prison. Lorenzo, when your father sent you here, who did you write to when the Sainte-Claire was seized? Who did you ask for letters, for introductions?"

Lorenzo was silent.

"Tell me."

"Borgia's secretary." Lorenzo's voice had gone flat, the way it did when he was cornered. "It's how I got the meeting at San Marco. A formality. Every foreign legation in Florence writes to that office."

"So the office knows your hand. It knows your name, your seal, your business. A letter from you goes into that building and it is believed." Michele leaned closer. "That's why it has to be you who signs it."

Lorenzo looked at him the way he had looked at him in the fishing boat before the villa—measuring, unwilling, already losing. "And what do we offer him? The documents. What do we ask?"

"Alessandro."

"Nothing else?"

"Nothing else."

Lorenzo laughed, a short ugly sound that turned into a cough. "Michele. You're offering a cardinal his own crimes in exchange for a boy he's never heard of. He'll send men to kill us and burn whatever they find on us."

"He might. But look at what he stands to lose if I'm lying about what I have—if I've already sent a copy somewhere, if the thing ends up in Medici hands, if the English get it. He can't know. That's what a threat is. Not that you have the knife, that he can't be sure where it's aimed."

"And if he calls your bluff?"

"Then we're in the same place we are now," Michele said. "Which is a barn with your arm split to the bone and a boat hunting the reeds. We are not choosing between danger and safety. We are choosing between two dangers, and one of them has an end."

Lorenzo was quiet a long time. Outside, the light through the boards had gone amber and long. Somewhere far off a bell rang, and Michele counted the strokes without meaning to. Six.

"You'll want the name," Lorenzo said at last. "For the letter. A name to sign, an identity for you to carry, something Ricci either can't check or won't dare to."

"Yes."

"And a place. Not the villa, not the city. Somewhere neither side can bring numbers."

"The chapel at Sant'Angelo. The old one, past the last vineyard. One road in, one road out, and a wood on three sides." Michele had passed it a dozen times on the way to the marsh. "No one lives within a mile of it."

"If it's on the Via Pisana, then Guardi can be there in a quarter hour once he knows."

"Then we don't give him time to know." Michele stood, crossed to the bench where his satchel lay, and took out the small kit he had salvaged: three sticks of charcoal, a penknife, a half sheet of rag paper, and the brass-backed mirror he used for self-portraits. No ink. He would have to burn a cork and write with the black of it, as he had when he was a boy apprenticed to a man too poor for ink.

He set the paper on the plank table and knelt to it. His hand, which had shaken, was steady now. That was the mercy of work.

"Write it," he said. "To the Cardinal's secretary first, and then to the Cardinal himself, if you can get past the first gate. Say that the painter who was commissioned to the Via del Giardino has property belonging to the office, and that it was left with him for safekeeping against the day when the office wished to reclaim it."

Lorenzo pushed himself up the wall with his good hand and came to the table. He had to hold the pen in his left hand and it was clumsy, but he had been trained to it—a diplomat's hands know more than one alphabet. "Safekeeping. That's what we call stealing now."

"Say that he will return it in person, at the chapel of Sant'Angelo on the Via Pisana, at the second hour after sunset tomorrow, and that he will exchange it for one article of property currently detained at the villa: a boy, Florentine, about fourteen years old, held without charge."

Lorenzo's pen stopped. "He'll see it at once. The boy is exactly the thing they were using to bait us on the water."

"Then let him see it." Michele smiled without much warmth. "It tells them we know what they've done. That's not weakness, that's a second knife on the table."

Lorenzo wrote. His left hand made a slower, more careful script than his own, and the difference might save them—any clerk reading it would see a foreigner's hand, a legation hand, a thing that belonged on a cardinal's desk. When the letter was done he read it back, twice, changing nothing except one word: *article* became *person*, which Michele thought was better anyway.

The wax was a stub from the church at San Frediano, no seal to it. Lorenzo folded the page, pressed the wax flat with his thumb, and looked at it with disgust. "A letter with no seal from a man with no country, offering to trade a cardinal's sins for a boy. It's a mad thing, Michele."

"Most things that work are."

Michele took the letter and slid it into his doublet next to the waxed tube, so that for the rest of the day the two things lay over his heart like a pair of stones.

Then Lorenzo, who had been watching him, said, in a different voice, "There's something you should know before we send it. I've been lying to you about the Sainte-Claire. The blockade isn't Tommaso's doing. Tommaso couldn't blockade a wash-basin. It's Borgia's order—the whole thing, the port, the refugees, all of it—and I knew it, or guessed it, from the day the ships were stopped." He looked at Michele steadily, fever-bright, waiting to be forgiven for the third time.

Michele took a breath and set that aside, the way you set down a tool you'll need later. "Then good," he said. "The man who can end it is the man we're writing to. Get up. We need the wood before the light goes."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 38: The New Plan · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads