The water was cold to the bone and rising past Michele's knees when the first horse plunged into the ditch behind them.
"Down," Lorenzo hissed, and dragged him sideways into the shadow of the bank where the reeds grew thick and black. Alessandro was already there, pressed against the mud, one hand flat to his ribs as though he'd cracked something loose in the fall. Above them, the ridge glimmered with the light Guardi's men carried—three lanterns swinging slow along the causeway, riding the motion of the marsh.
"They'll see us if we run the bank," Michele whispered. He could hear the horses splashing somewhere behind, and men's voices, and then Tommaso's, flat and certain: "Spread out. They can't cross the marsh on foot. Ricci wants the tube. The rest is nothing to me."
The rest is nothing to me. Michele had heard enough men say that to know it meant the opposite.
"Here," Alessandro said, and his voice was a stranger's—quieter than it had been in the villa, sanded down by four days in a cellar. He pulled something flat from inside his shirt and held it out. A letter. Lorenzo's letter, unsealed, the wax still intact on the flap.
Lorenzo stared at it. "Where—"
"Guardi took it off me at the ford. He read it. Then he gave it back." Alessandro's jaw worked. "He wanted me to walk you into the water. That's what he meant by 'you did well.' I was to keep you here until the boats came around."
Michele's grip tightened on the waxed tube against his chest. "And now?"
"Now I'd rather die in a ditch than on my knees." Alessandro pushed the letter back into Lorenzo's hands. "Take it. Burn it. Whatever you like. But the boats are on the south bank and the men are on the north, so if you want to live, you go east through the reeds to the mill, and you don't stop for anything."
"East is the canal," Lorenzo said.
"East is the overflow channel," Alessandro said. "Dry this season. It runs under the mill and comes out at the fisherman's wharf. I've walked it."
Michele looked at Lorenzo. The question didn't need asking aloud, and Lorenzo's answer didn't need saying—his good hand was already on the knife Michele had planted in the villa, the one he'd kept.
They moved.
The reeds closed over them like fingers. Michele went first, feeling the ground with his boots, the water sinking from his knees to his ankles, then to a mud that sucked and gave. Behind him Lorenzo breathed hard through his teeth—the arm, the arm, he wasn't complaining but the wound was leaking again, Michele could smell it, that coppery warmth under the cold green of the marsh. Alessandro came last, turning once to look back at the ridge, and Michele saw his face in the lantern light and understood he was counting the boats.
"They've launched," Alessandro said.
"How many?"
"Six. Eight men."
"Horses?"
"Can't use them in the ditches. That's our luck."
It was the only luck they had. Michele had counted four men behind them on the bank and now eight on the water and however many more waiting on the road—and he had a tube of paper and a knife and two men, one of them wounded, and dawn was no more than three hours off. The fishermen's cottage. Boats cannot reach it. He fixed the thought like a nail and kept walking.
The overflow channel opened suddenly, a black seam cut through the reeds, and Michele stepped down into it and found the bottom firm. He turned and pulled Lorenzo in after him and the two of them stood chest to chest in the dark, the water to their waists, breathing each other's breath.
"Your arm," Michele said.
"It's fine."
"You're bleeding into the canal."
"It's fine." Lorenzo's good hand came up and touched Michele's cheek, quick and rough, and then fell away. "Keep moving."
They went along the channel single file, Alessandro behind them, and for a hundred paces the night was silent except for the water and the frogs. Then a lantern flared at the head of the channel, and a voice—Tommaso's voice—said, "There. Light the reeds."
Fire.
They were burning the reeds.
The flame caught the dry stalks at the channel's edge and ran along the bank with a noise like tearing cloth, and the whole eastern sky went orange. Michele could see the mill now, a black rectangle against the glow, and the bank in front of it where the channel narrowed. Four men stood on the bank with torches. Tommaso stood behind them with a pistol.
Alessandro was already moving. He came up out of the channel like something out of a story—the refugee boy who had survived four days in a cellar and learned to lie in three languages—and he hit the first man before the man had turned his head, drove him into the second with the whole weight of his body, and took the torch out of his hand. The man went into the water. The torch went into the reeds.
Michele lunged for the bank. A man swung at his head with a cudgel and he ducked and came up inside the swing and drove the knife into the man's thigh, felt the blade grate on bone, and let the man fall. Somewhere behind him Lorenzo shouted his name. He turned and saw Lorenzo with his knife out, his bad arm hanging, holding off a man twice his size—and then the man saw Lorenzo's arm and thought it an easy thing and came in fast, and that was the last mistake he made, because Lorenzo's left hand was just as good as his right when it came to a knife and he opened the man's wrist to the bone.
"Tommaso!" Michele shouted. "Call them off or you'll follow Ricci into the ground!"
Tommaso raised the pistol. The flame-light made him look older than he had at the chapel, the double payment printed on his face. "You think I care?" he said. "Ricci pays me to clean up his letters. He paid me double to clean up you."
"Then you know what's in the archive," Michele said. "Your name among the rest. The men who paid you."
Tommaso's finger tightened. "That's why the tube burns tonight."
He fired.
The ball went wide—Alessandro had struck his arm as he pulled the trigger—and the shot went into the dark and the water, and then Alessandro had the pistol by the barrel and Tommaso by the throat and the two of them went down onto the bank together, and Michele heard the wet crack of a skull on a stone.
He didn't see who it was. He was running.
The reeds were burning all around the bank now, a wall of noise and light, and there was one way through it and that was the channel itself, back the way they'd come, which was where the horses and the rest of the men were. And eight men on the water and no way over the marsh.
Michele stopped. The tube was hot against his chest. The letter was gone—no.
The letter was in Lorenzo's hand. Lorenzo had it. He had it because Alessandro had given it to him, and Alessandro had given it to him because Alessandro had decided something in that ditch, and Michele, standing in the shallows with the fire behind him, understood all at once what the boy had decided and what it was going to cost.
"Lorenzo!" he called. "The chapel!"
"What?"
"Not the marsh. The chapel. We go back the way we came and we go to Sant'Angelo. Borgia's men are waiting there—the ones who came for the exchange. They're still there. They don't know about this."
Lorenzo stared at him across the burning water. Then he laughed—a broken, hopeless sound, and turned and started back along the bank the way they'd come, toward the ridge and the causeway and the mounted men, and Michele went after him.
Behind them, on the bank, Alessandro lay still on the stones with Tommaso's pistol in his hand and his blood running down the channel, into the black water, into the reeds, and did not move.