The contessa's carriage waited in a side street off the Piazza Banchi, plain as a merchant's cart, no crest, no lacquer. Michele climbed in with his ruined hand held against his chest and his mind still groping backward through the prison corridors, the guard's key, the bribed silence of the whole building. Beatrice sat in the shadows with a fur mantle around her shoulders and a lanthorn turning slowly on its hook, so that her face appeared and vanished and appeared again.
"You look worse than I expected," she said.
"I feel worse than you expected."
"Sit."
He sat. The carriage lurched, wheels grinding over wet stone, and the harbor fell away behind them. Michele watched the masts slide past the window, the lanterns of the coaster that was not going to Marseille, the black harbor water. Somewhere in that hull, crated, were the two panels. Somewhere deeper was the memory of Alessandro going down on the planks with the shot still ringing.
"Lorenzo," he said. "You said Sarzanello."
"He was taken there. Tommaso rode with him. Two days out, three days in—you'll want the coast road to Lavagna and the ferryman I told you of, Bargagli, a big man with a broken nose. He owes me. He'll put you across to the eastern shore below the fortress."
"And then?"
"And then you do what I have not been able to buy, bribe, or threaten anyone into doing for eleven years." She turned the lanthorn a quarter-turn so that the flame stood still. "You get inside Sarzanello. You find the crate with your panels in it. And you bring me the letter that is folded behind the lining of the second panel, the one with the Virgin and the two donors."
Michele said nothing. The carriage swayed.
"You knew," he said at last.
"Of course I knew. I paid for the commission. I paid the man who made the panels and the man who made the crate, and I have been waiting since the Feast of the Annunciation for one of them to tell me the other had cheated him, which is the only reason two such men ever speak to a third." She smiled without warmth. "It is my hand in the letter, Michele. My hand, my seal, my words. Cosimo has been sitting on the knowledge of it for two years, and Ricci will have it out of that crate within the fortnight, and then I am finished, and so is everyone who ever took my coin."
"Then you didn't free me for Lorenzo."
"I freed you for the letter. Lorenzo is the price you pay yourself for going." She looked at him levelly. "Do not pretend you would have gone otherwise. You would have gone anyway. That is why I chose you."
Michele looked out at the dark road. He thought of the prison, the rope, the questions. He thought of the thing she had told him in the cell block, dropped like a stone into still water, and which had been sinking through him ever since.
"Say the other thing again," he said. "About Lorenzo."
"That he once worked for Florence."
"Say it properly."
Beatrice sighed and set the lanthorn down on the bench beside her. "His name was not Lorenzo when he came to me. It was Lorenzo when he left, because I gave him the name, and the clothes, and the rooms in the Via de' Bardi, and the manner of a man who had money from a dead uncle in Lucca. Before that he was a clerk's son from Prato with a gift for imitation—hands, seals, cadences. The Signoria used him for three years. He forged safe-conducts, letters of credit, a papal brief in 'forty-nine that got a Florentine agent out of Ferrara alive. He was very good. He was paid very well. And then they asked him to forge a letter in my hand, accusing me of corresponding with the Duke of Milan, so that they could seize my houses, and he refused."
"Why?"
"Because by then he was mine," she said simply. "He had been mine for a year. The Signoria do not forgive a refusal of that kind, so he ran, and I have kept him at arm's length ever since, because the farther from me he stands the less use he is to them as a knife against my throat. He has been a hunted man for eleven years, Michele. That part of what he told you was the truth."
Michele sat with his hands in his lap—the two ruined fingers stiff and useless, the rest of him perfectly still.
"Why did he tell me he was a spy?" he said. "Why did he tell me I was the spy?"
"Because when you are hunted, the safest lie is one that puts the danger on the other man's side of the room. If he had told you, I refused to forge a letter for the Signoria, you would have asked why, and the why was me, and to explain the why he would have had to give you my name and his name in the same breath to a painter he had known six weeks." She lifted one shoulder. "So he gave you the version where he was the honest broker and you were the suspected traitor. It kept you angry at him and it kept my name out of your mouth. It worked. You have been very angry at him."
"You knew that too."
"I know everything about Lorenzo," said Beatrice, "which is precisely what he has spent eleven years running from."
Michele closed his eyes. The carriage rattled on. He saw the studio in the Via dei Servi, Lorenzo holding up the gesso panel to the light, Lorenzo saying *I was told you were the one who could be trusted with the painting and the letter both.* He saw the careful way Lorenzo had always told him the truth about everything except the one thing, and he understood, all at once and entirely, why a man who had refused to forge a letter to save his own life would lie to a stranger to protect the woman that refusal had been for.
"Did he ever say anything about me," he said. "In his letters. To you."
"Once." Beatrice watched him. "He wrote that the painter was better than the commission deserved, and that he was sorry."
"Sorry for what?"
"For the lie. He wrote that too." She took a folded paper from inside her mantle and held it out. "This is not the letter. This is a copy of the safe-conduct he forged in 'forty-nine. It is the only thing I have ever held over him, and he does not know I have it. If you find him, and you get out, and I get my letter—you may give it back to him. Tell him the debt is cancelled." She tucked it away again before Michele could reach for it. "Not before. After. I am not sentimental."
The carriage slowed. Ahead, the road narrowed into the hills and the sea showed as a black band under a blacker sky.
"Now," she said. "The ferryman. His name, his village, and the exact hour he changes his net." She made him say it back three times. "And the debt in Sarzanello. There is a sergeant there, Bellone—a Sienese, missing two front teeth. Two years ago his brother was taken for debt in Florence, and I had him released. Bellone will deny it. Remind him of the day, the street, and the girl he was with when they came for his brother. He will hate you for it. He will help you."
"And if he doesn't?"
"Then you have a knife," said Beatrice, "and two fingers that don't work, and a great deal of rage. I would not put money on anything else but I would put money on the rage."
She rapped the roof. The carriage stopped. Below them, through the trees, a fishing light swung on the water.
"Lavagna is four hours' walk that way," she said. "Go, and remember: whatever Lorenzo did to you, he did it to keep me safe, and whatever I have done to you, I have done to keep myself safe, and both of us used you. If that makes you want to leave us both to Ricci—" she shrugged— "then leave. I would. But I don't think you will."
Michele climbed down into the cold. He looked back once, and the lanthorn was already turning away, and the carriage was already moving, and the contessa was already, he understood, no longer thinking about him at all.
He turned toward the sea.
Lorenzo had lied to him about being a spy. Lorenzo had never lied to him about anything else. Below, the fishing light swung, on, off, on—and Michele set off down the road toward it, holding his ruined hand against his chest, doing the arithmetic of the coast road in his head, and arriving—somewhere between one step and the next, cold and certain—at the thing that had been standing in front of him all night.
If Tommaso took Lorenzo out the western gate and rode for Sarzanello, he passed through Florence. And a man in a covered cart who passes through Florence is a man who has been *seen* passing through Florence—which meant the Signoria knew, which meant Ricci knew, which meant Sarzanello was not a hiding place.
It was a stage.
And Michele was the only actor they had not yet costumed.