The workshop smelled of linseed and turpentine, and under that, faintly, of the canal. Dawn light came in sideways through the high window and lay across the floor like something spilled. Michele had been standing at the easel since before the bells, and his back ached in a way he had stopped noticing hours ago.
Lorenzo came in with bread and two cups of watered wine and set them on the bench without a word. He had learned, in the months since Venice, not to talk to Michele while the work was going well.
"Hold still," Michele said.
"I haven't moved."
"You moved yesterday."
"I was asleep yesterday."
"You breathe loudly when you sleep."
Lorenzo sat. The chair was the good one, the one with the carved back that had come from the old palazzo before they sold everything that wouldn't fit in a barge. He folded his hands and looked at the wall, which was what Michele had asked him to look at, because a man cannot look at his own portrait while it is being painted without becoming a liar.
The canvas was tall, taller than Michele had planned when he stretched it. He had meant to do something small. A study. A quick thing to keep his hand in during the weeks when his commissions were drying up and the Contessa's letter sat folded on the shelf like a promise he was not yet ready to answer. But the small canvas had become a large one somewhere in the second week, and the large one had become this, and this was not what he had told himself he was painting.
It was the two of them. Not in a garden, not at an altar, not in any of the settings the Florentine workshops used when they painted a pair of men and wanted you to believe the two men were brothers. They were in the workshop, in the light of the high window, standing close. Lorenzo was behind him, one hand resting flat against Michele's chest, the hand with the carnelian ring on it—Michele had put the ring in the painting, small but unmistakable, because a symbol that cannot be seen is not a symbol. Michele himself was in the front, turned three-quarters, looking out. Not at the viewer. Past the viewer. The way you look when you are trying to remember a face you love.
Michele stepped back. The bread sat untouched.
"You've stopped," Lorenzo said.
"I've finished."
Lorenzo turned. Michele watched him look at the painting the way he watched everyone look—the quick scan, the pause, the lean, the long silence. People who did not know how to look at paintings made noise while they looked, little noises of approval or confusion. Lorenzo made none. He got up and walked to the easel and stood there for a long time.
"It isn't a wedding portrait," he said at last.
"No."
"We have a wedding portrait. It's in the box under the bed with the letters."
"I know where it is."
Lorenzo's hand went to his own chest, unconsciously, mirroring the painted hand. "The ring," he said.
"Whoever looks at this will know exactly what we are."
"Yes."
"That was the point."
Lorenzo turned his head. He had the expression he wore when he was doing arithmetic—the narrowed eyes, the small downward pull at the mouth. Michele had learned that this expression did not mean he was unhappy. It meant he was counting consequences.
"The Giannetti commission comes Tuesday," Lorenzo said.
"It does."
"And the Veronese wants his son's portrait the week after."
"Three sitters. Likely a fourth, if the Veronese brings his nephew the way he did last time."
"If they see this hanging in the workshop while they sit."
"Then they see it."
Lorenzo looked back at the canvas. In the painting, Michele's hand rested over Lorenzo's hand on his chest. They had never stood like that for this long in life—Michele had made it up, and then, after he made it up, Lorenzo had come over and stood that way for a full hour while Michele worked, so it was true now. That was how a painting became true. Not by copying, but by insisting.
"It will cost us," Lorenzo said.
"It might."
"Ulivieri's warrant is still somewhere in a clerk's drawer. We have been free for six months and that drawer is still shut."
"So?"
"So I am tired of flinching in rooms I've paid for," Michele said. He wiped his brush and set it down. "I painted your brother the way the world wanted him painted. I painted the Contessa's sons and their hunting dogs and their roses because she paid me three hundred florins and I needed three hundred florins. I painted a diplomat's wedding portrait and I put a lie in it so fine that nobody could see it, and the lie nearly ate me alive. I want one painting in this room that doesn't lie."
He heard his own voice go strange and stopped.
Lorenzo crossed the room and put both hands on Michele's shoulders. The bread was getting stale on the bench.
"Then it hangs where you can see it," Lorenzo said.
"Where?"
"The east wall. Where I can see it from the bed."
"You'll see it from the bed at night."
"I'll see it from the bed at night."
Michele laughed, once, short, and then he was working again with both hands—gesso, frame, nails, level—like a man who had decided something and was astonished at his own speed, and Lorenzo did not help, because he knew that helping would ruin it. Lorenzo sat on the floor with his back against the bench and ate the bread, and after a while Marco came up from the barge with the rest of the paint he'd been sent for and stood at the door with his mouth open.
"You finished it," Marco said.
"I finished it."
"That's—" Marco squinted. "That's Lorenzo."
"Sharper than you look."
"With your hand on him."
"Yes."
Marco came in and put the paint down and stood in front of the easel with his arms crossed, and he had the look of a man doing sums about the size of the lie you can tell when the truth is standing in the middle of the room. Then he said, "Good," and turned around and went back down, and they heard him on the stairs singing something off-key in the dialect of the lagoon.
By noon the painting was on the east wall, and the room looked different. Michele kept walking to the window and then back, pretending he was checking the gesso on another board. He was not checking the gesso on another board. Lorenzo knew it. Lorenzo did not say so.
They ate late. Beans and oil and the rest of the bread, and a piece of salted fish Lorenzo had bought in the market that morning while Michele was sleeping off the night. Michele had gone on so long the past three days about the blue in the shadow under Lorenzo's jaw—a blue he said was neither ultramarine nor azzurrite but some third thing that did not exist in any shop in Venice—that Lorenzo had stopped arguing about it. It existed in the painting. That would have to do.
"Paolo will want to see it," Lorenzo said.
"Paolo sees everything."
"He'll bless it."
"He'll tell me the drapery on the far side is weak."
"It is weak."
"It's the linen, and linen is weak. It's the point."
Lorenzo grinned and shook his head, and Michele looked at him, and for a moment that was the whole painting, the two of them at a scarred table with the afternoon light coming in and the east wall holding them forever in a way the afternoon could not. Then Lorenzo pushed back from the table and went to the shelf and took down the letter with the Gonzaga seal.
"Mantua," he said.
"The letter's been open for a month."
"We've owed her an answer for one."
"I know."
"We stay."
"We stay."
Lorenzo turned the letter over in his fingers. "She warned us about the warrant. She stood in our doorway at midnight and told us to our faces. A woman like that doesn't get an answer from you a month later in a clerk's hand. You write to her yourself. Properly. Tonight."
"I'll write to her."
"Say we'll come in the spring if the roads are open."
"Say we'll come in the spring if the roads are open," Michele repeated, and then he took the letter and put it back on the shelf, and did not go to the table to write it, because it was late and the light was going and there was, right then, a better use for the day's last hour.
He took up the brush again.
"Not tonight," Lorenzo said.
"Not the portrait. A small thing. For the corner of it—" Michele was already mixing, one hand, a green so dark it read as black in the wrong light.
"Come to bed."
"In a moment."
"You said that three hours ago."
"I did."
Lorenzo got up and came to stand behind him, hand on his chest, exactly as in the painting, and said nothing more, because he had spent his whole life in rooms where saying everything had been a means of saying nothing, and he knew now what silence was for. Michele worked. The light dropped. Somewhere across the canal a shopkeeper was closing up, and somewhere out in the lagoon a barge was late coming home, and on the east wall two men stood in the light of a high window, watching a face they loved walk back toward them out of the dark.