The Painted Lie

Chapter 70: The Return

The light came off the Arno at dusk like beaten copper, and Michele stood at the middle of the Ponte Santa Trinita and let it fall on his face.

Behind him, toward the Oltrarno, were the workshops of his first apprenticeship, the smell of linseed and rabbit-skin glue, the taproom where he had gone hungry. Ahead were the crenellations of the Palazzo Vecchio, lit gold at the top, and somewhere beyond it the piazza with its stone floor where he had stood and said a thing that could have killed him.

"Look at it," Lorenzo said, hands on the parapet, watching the water and not the city. "You always look first at the tower. Every time we cross a bridge in any city, you look for the tower."

"I look to see if anyone has burned it down yet."

Lorenzo laughed, low, and knocked his shoulder into Michele's. They had come in that afternoon by the Porta Romana, dusty and unhurried, leading a single mule with their paint boxes and two changes of clothes. Four days on the road from Chioggia, up through the pass, and no banner, no patrol, no clerk of the Council with a paper in his hand asking to see their names. It had taken Michele until Pistoia to believe it.

"We eat first or we walk first?" Lorenzo said.

"Walk."

The streets were narrower than he remembered. That was the trick of a place you lost — it shrank in you, and when you came back it had the insolence to be exactly its own size. Michele had been twenty-two when he ran. He was thirty now, and the corner of the via dei Tavolini still turned where it had always turned, and the cloth-seller still had his awning out at the same slant.

Lorenzo walked half a step behind, letting him lead, which was a gift he did not name.

They came onto the piazza with the evening on it. The loggia was full of men arguing, and a boy was selling roasted chestnuts from a brazier, and there was a scaffolding on the Palazzo's flank where they had put up new stone. Michele stopped at the edge of the paving and could not immediately make his feet move.

"You want me to hold your arm?" Lorenzo said quietly.

"No." Michele took a breath and went on. "I want to feel it standing up."

The place had no memory of him. He understood that, and it humbled him to understand it. He had come back expecting the stone to know. There was a bench where the notary had stood with his fair copy, and there was the step where he had climbed to a pillared portico, and there — a window on the second floor, wooden shutters open, a clerk moving papers inside — was where the judges had sat. He went and stood where he had stood.

He could still hear his own voice. That was the thing no one told you about courage: you carried the sound of it in your ears for the rest of your life, thin and frightened and pitched too high, and you had to decide, each day, whether to be ashamed of that or proud of it. He had said the truth in front of men who could have had him killed, and he had said it badly, and it had been enough.

A girl walking past with a basket looked at him, a stranger standing alone in the middle of the square, and then looked away.

"Good evening," Michele said to no one, and it came out almost a laugh.

Lorenzo read him well enough not to ask what he was doing or what he felt. He came and stood in the same patch of paving, facing the Palazzo, and put his hands behind his back like a man inspecting a building.

"Would you do it again?" he said at last.

"Say the same words?"

"Any words. Stand there. Risk everything at twenty-two for a man you barely knew."

Michele considered the window, the clerk, the new stone on the flank of the tower. "I did not do it for you," he said. "I did it because Maestro Paolo told me my hands were mine and not the man's who pays for them. I was proud after. That is what I remember most, Lorenzo. Not the fear. The pride. I have never once been as proud of anything I have painted."

"Then this was a good city to you once."

"It was."

They ate at a trattoria off the Mercato Vecchio, and the wine came sour and green the way Florentine wine always did in the autumn, and Lorenzo drank it anyway and made a face and said it was like drinking a hedge. Two graying men at the next table were arguing about the war in the Romagna and whether the French would ever be trusted again, and no one in the room looked at them twice. Michele found himself eating slowly, watching the doorway out of a habit he had built in Venice, and made himself stop.

"Tomorrow," he said, "I want to go to Paolo. The churchyard is behind Santa Croce."

"Tomorrow." Lorenzo wiped his mouth. "You should send word to Costa, if he is still alive. He wrote three letters a year for six years. He will be wounded if he hears of us after we have gone."

"I will write in the morning."

They walked back through the dark, and on the Ponte Vecchio Michele bought a strand of tiny coral beads from a man closing his stall for three quattrini, because the price was ridiculous and because he wanted something in his pocket from the city that had made him.

Santa Croce in the morning was cold and gray and had more pigeons than people. The priest at the sacristy door blinked at Michele's Florentine accent and Venetian coat and pointed them down the side path to the frati's burial ground with the indifferent kindness of a man who had done this nine hundred times.

Paolo's stone was low and plain and set along the wall with eleven others of his order. It said only his name and the year. Someone had put a faded sprig of rosemary in a cup at the base, long dead, the water evaporated to a brown ring.

Michele knelt down and pulled the dead sprig out and set it aside, and then did not know what to do with his hands.

"I never wrote to him," he said, and was annoyed to find his voice going. "Not once, in eight years. I told myself it was dangerous for him. That is true. But I could have sent a picture. A card. Something a courier could not read."

Lorenzo stood behind him and said nothing, which was what Michele needed.

"He sold his silver to get me a boat," Michele said. "He was not a rich man. He had a pewter chalice and a small silver paten that his mother had left the parish, and he pledged them at a Jew's house on the Rialto, and they were never redeemed. I know because the priest at San Zanipolo told me years later. Paolo never mentioned it. He did not mention it when he was arrested, or when he was released, or any time in between."

"Then he did not do it for the thanks."

"No." Michele laid his hand flat on the stone, which was colder than the morning. "He did it because he was one of the people who believe that the truth weighs more than the man who says it. I paint for money, Lorenzo. I paint beautiful things for rich men who want beautiful things, and there is no crime in it, but I am not Paolo. I am trying to be."

He stayed on his knees a while longer, then got up, brushed his knees, and put his hand out for Lorenzo's arm, which Lorenzo gave him without comment.

They went out into the sunlight of the piazza in front of the basilica. The bells had finished; the pigeons walked on the warm stone as if nothing had ever happened anywhere. Michele stood there and felt something settle in him, a weight that had been hanging for a decade and now rested on the ground.

"Here is what I want," he said. "Both cities."

Lorenzo raised an eyebrow. "Both."

"The workshop in Venice stays. It is Tommaso's and Chiara's as much as mine now; they paint better than I did at their age, and the whole point of the place was that it should not depend on one man's hand. We keep the rooms, and Maestro Corbo's house is big, and we will pay the lease even in the years we are not there, and that will be an act of stupidity that I intend to commit." He looked at the stone tower of the Palazzo Vecchio, visible over the roofs. "And here I take a workshop. Not for a visit. For a life. Small, near the Carmine, not too bright, a place with a big north window, and a wall for the apprentices, and a door that locks properly. I want to paint the Arno from memory in one city and from the window in the other. I want to be the painter of no city at all."

Lorenzo was quiet a moment. Then: "Two households means two sets of servants. Two sets of accounts. Two sets of people to bribe, and two sets of people to avoid, and there will be a day when somebody in one of these cities wants to know where Signor Lorenzo is, and the honest answer will be that he is two hundred miles south in a house that is not on any register."

"Then we will be thieves of our own time." Michele turned to him. "You built the better part of this out of nothing, my love. You bought a palazzo's worth of art in a city that had a warrant with your name on it. Do not tell me you cannot keep two doors closed at once."

Lorenzo looked at him for a long moment, and then laughed, and there was no argument in it. "The Carmine," he said. "Cheaper than San Marco and full of the Mazzolino set, who will despise you until the day you die. Fine. I will find a house. But I want a garden. A real one. I am not spending my old age on a balcony with a pot of basil on it."

"A garden," Michele agreed.

They walked back across the city, unhurried, one of them talking about where a house with a garden might be found, the other not answering, only listening to the sound of his own city after ten years and finding, to his surprise, that it had become his city again, in the way old rooms become yours again once you have lived somewhere else long enough to know what you have.

That evening Michele bought a young cypress in a clay pot from a nurseryman outside the Porta San Frediano and set it on the sill of the room where they were staying, as a marking of the place, and slept better than he had in weeks.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 70: The Return · The Painted Lie · Lumen Reads