The tripod was still warm from the balcony shoot, and Duarte had it planted at the exact angle of their first standoff — the doorway, hers, half open, the corridor light bleeding through.
"Stand there," he said. "The way you stood when you thought I was robbing the place."
"I didn't think you were robbing the place."
"You had a corkscrew in your hand."
"I had a corkscrew because I was opening wine, which is how I celebrate being robbed." She crossed her arms anyway, shifted her weight onto one hip. The pose felt like a pose. That was the problem.
Duarte had his eye to the camera. "Good. Now say the line."
Ellie said the line. She'd written it the night before, three drafts, trying to make it sound like something a person might actually say: *I don't care who you are — you're not staying here.* It came out flattened, like a tourist reading a menu phonetically.
"Again," Duarte said.
She said it again. Worse.
"Again."
"The words are fine," she said, breaking character. "The words are *fine*. You're not giving me anything to react to. You're just standing behind the camera being a wall."
"That's because I'm supposed to be the landlord. Move left, so you're yelling past me."
She moved left. She said the line a fourth time. She heard how it landed — thin, rehearsed, the cadence of a woman who had once written fourteen variations of *I'll always find my way back to you* and believed none of them. Duarte lowered the camera. His mouth had done the thing it did, the flat line that wasn't quite a frown.
"It's shit," he said.
"It's a first pass."
"It's shit, Ellie."
"Then direct me instead of just stating the obvious."
"I *am* directing you. I'm telling you to stop performing." He set the camera down on the coffee table, which, she noticed, meant he was committing to the argument. "We have—" he checked his watch, "—four days until Thursday. And what we have, right now, is a woman saying words at a lens."
"We have a script. Scripts are how you make people watch something."
"People watch things that are true."
"People watch things that *feel* true, which is different, and you get there with structure." She was pacing now, which was her tell, and she hated that he could see it. "You can't just point a camera at a room and hope meaning falls into it. The first twenty seconds decide everything. We open on the mailbox, the name that isn't yours—"
"We don't have footage of the mailbox."
"Then we shoot the mailbox."
"We shoot the mailbox," he repeated, slow, like he was translating her. "Ellie. What do you remember about the day I opened that door?"
"Everything. I wrote it down."
"No." He picked the camera back up, turned it on, kept it at his hip, angled up. "Say the first thing you actually remember."
"That's not—"
"First thing."
She exhaled through her nose. "The smell."
"Of what?"
"Of the hallway. Wet stone. It's always wet in that hallway. And the lock made a sound like it was full of sand, and I thought — for half a second — I thought, *if this is another showing, I'm going to say something I regret to the agent.*" She stopped. She'd forgotten she'd thought that. She hadn't put it in the script. "And then the door opened and you were standing there in a towel."
"I was not in a towel."
"You were *near* a towel."
"The towel was on the floor."
"Because you dropped it when you saw me." She was smiling without deciding to. "You have a very specific expression when you panic. Like a man who's been caught doing taxes."
Duarte was still filming. "Keep going."
"There's nothing to keep—"
"How did I look."
"You looked—" She looked at him, at the actual him, standing in her actual living room with his actual camera at his hip, and the word arrived before she could vet it. "You looked caught. Not guilty-caught. Just — caught off guard. Like nobody had told you anyone was coming." She blinked. "I remember thinking it was strange that you were angrier than I was."
"I wasn't angry."
"You were extremely angry."
"I was *frightened*, which looks similar, and I'm not putting that in your movie."
"It's not *my* movie." But she was laughing now, and the laugh was real, and the camera was still on.
They reshot the confrontation. Twice. Both times, she hit her marks, said the words cleanly, and both times it died on the screen. Duarte would play it back with his jaw set tight and say nothing, and the nothing was worse than the shit.
"Let me try it as myself," she said finally. "Not as the version who wrote it."
"That's all I've been asking for."
"It's not the same thing and you know it isn't."
She stood in the doorway. Duarte stood where the landlord would stand, and by his body alone — the slight forward lean, the chin down — he became a stranger who had no right to be in her hallway. She found herself getting angry. Actually angry. Not at Sr. Silva, exactly. At the whole architecture of it: the deposit, the emails signed *warm regards*, the seven months of being handled, the fact that she'd been made a fool of so gently she hadn't noticed.
"I paid you," she said. "On the fourteenth. I sent the transfer from a café with bad WiFi and I sat there for two hours because I didn't want to send it wrong." Her voice climbed and she let it. "I don't care who you are, you're not staying here."
"That's it," Duarte said quietly.
"It's not a line anymore."
"No. Good. Now ask me what I'm doing here."
She asked. He answered as himself — that he'd paid, that he'd been told the flat was empty, that he had receipts, that he was not leaving and she could call whoever she liked. She told him to call whoever *he* liked. They overlapped, talked over each other, and it was ten minutes before either of them heard the small recording light and remembered.
"That was good," Duarte said.
"That was an argument."
"That was *good*." He pulled the card out and handed it to her like it was something fragile. "That's the first honest thing we've shot."
Ellie looked at the card. Forty minutes of footage and maybe ninety real seconds in it, all of it accidental. Which was the whole problem, wasn't it — she'd spent her career building endings, and endings required control, and control was the thing the camera kept dissolving the moment she reached for it. She could feel the script in her hand, the three clean pages she'd written, and she knew with a particular dull nausea that the footage was going to be better than the script and that she would have to admit it.
She put the card on the table between them.
"Fine," she said. "But we need a shape. Real moments don't mean anything if you don't choose which ones."
"Agreed."
"I mean it. I'm not letting this become one of those videos where a man films his own reflection for nine minutes and calls it a portrait of the city."
Duarte let out a short breath through his nose. "You have very strong feelings about my profession."
"You *have* a profession?"
He laughed — actually laughed, head back, and she caught herself watching his throat like an idiot, and looked away fast, and the tape on the floor was still there, still dividing the room in half, and neither of them mentioned it.
"One more thing," she said. "Ana. The other victim."
Duarte's laugh faded. "You said you'd tell me what she wrote."
"I did tell you what she wrote."
"You told me the part about Thursday." He picked up the camera, checked the exposure out of habit. "You didn't tell me the whole thing."
Ellie opened her mouth to answer — and the phone on the table lit up, screen down, buzzing once against the wood. She reached for it and turned it over.
**ANA:** *I can see your lights are on. I'm downstairs. I don't want to come up — can you come down alone?*
Duarte read it upside down from where he stood. Neither of them said anything for a second. Then, from three floors below, thin and warped by the stairwell, the street door buzzed.