The Perfect Ending

Chapter 24: The Son's Threat

Paulo was already in the hallway when they stepped out of the apartment, which meant he'd been waiting.

He stood in front of his mother's door with his arms crossed, a set of keys wrapped around his fist. Late thirties, gym shoulders gone soft, a windbreaker that said he came from outside even though they'd seen him slip into the building past midnight with the bag.

"Senhor Duarte. Senhora." He said it like a pharmacist reading a label. "You filmed me."

Duarte shifted the camera bag higher on his shoulder. "We filmed the corridor. You walked into frame."

"On my mother's floor. Going into my mother's apartment."

"At one in the morning. With a bag you kept against the wall so the light wouldn't catch it."

Paulo's jaw worked once. "Delete it."

Ellie put her hand on Duarte's forearm before he could answer. The hallway smelled of cabbage and the bleach the cleaner used on the stairs, and somewhere below a door slammed. "Paulo, we're not trying to—"

"I'm talking to him."

"I'm talking to you." Her voice came out steadier than she expected. "We have footage. That's all it is. Nobody's accused you of anything."

"Yet." Paulo's eyes went back to Duarte. "You're the one who put the neighbors on camera, so people could say things about my mother's building. About the landlord. And now you have me carrying a bag at night, and you'll cut it so it looks like—" He stopped, breathing through his nose. "I know how these things are made. My cousin works in television."

Duarte didn't move. "Then your cousin will tell you that we haven't used it. We haven't even watched it all the way through."

"You were watching it last night. I heard the sound through the wall."

Ellie felt the floor tilt slightly. They had been watching it last night, the three of them hunched over the laptop after Maria left, freezing on a frame where Paulo's face turned toward the stairwell light. Duarte had said, quietly, that this was something. She had said nothing.

"We can't delete something we might need as evidence," Duarte said. "If you've done nothing wrong, the footage protects you."

"If I've done nothing wrong." Paulo laughed, one flat note. "You're a foreigner playing detective in a building where my family has lived for thirty-one years. My mother has neighbors who will watch your little videos and decide things about her son. You think the truth matters to them? They'll decide what they decide."

"That's not our problem."

"Duarte," Ellie said.

"No—this is exactly the problem." He stepped forward, and Paulo's keys tightened. "We've spent two weeks trying to be careful with people, and every time someone tells us to look away. Maria told us to look away. Now—"

"You leave Maria out of this."

The three of them went quiet. Below, the front door opened and shut. Footsteps came up, slow, and stopped a floor down, then turned back.

Paulo unwound the keys from his fist one finger at a time. "Twenty-four hours," he said. "I want the file gone. All copies. Cloud, cards, laptop, whatever. If I see one frame of me on that account, I'll go to a lawyer, and I'll go to the platform you're working with, and I'll take my mother's testimony off the table."

Ellie's stomach dropped. "Your mother hasn't—"

"My mother does what I tell her now. She's seventy-nine. She doesn't understand what you're building." He looked at her properly for the first time. "You think the two of you are the first ones who came here with a camera and a story about this building? You're just the first ones who stayed."

He unlocked his mother's door and went in. The lock turned twice.

Ellie stood there with her hand still on Duarte's arm. The cabbage smell had gone; now it was just bleach and the cold breath of the stairwell.

"We're not deleting it," Duarte said.

"Let's walk."

They went down instead of up, past their own floor, past Maria's door — she'd hear them later, she heard everything — and out into the street. Seven in the morning light, the kiosk opening, a woman hosing the pavement in front of the bakery. They walked to the little square with the dead fountain and sat on the bench that was always cold no matter the hour.

"He's bluffing," Duarte said.

"He's not."

"A lawyer costs money he doesn't have. He works at his uncle's tile shop."

"You know that?"

"I know a lot of things about this building now. It's the problem." He set the camera bag between his feet like a small animal he was guarding. "Ellie, if we delete it, we have nothing. If he did something to Senhora Costa's apartment—"

"We don't know that he did anything."

"We don't know that he didn't."

She looked at the fountain. Dry for years, someone had filled it with geraniums that someone else kept watering. "If he pulls his mother's testimony, we can't finish the documentary. Priya's whole angle is the neighbors. And if he goes to the platform—"

"Then we tell them the truth."

"We can't tell them the truth."

Duarte turned to look at her. He had that expression he'd worn since the bank statement, careful, like he was holding something breakable and hadn't decided yet whether to set it down.

"What truth can't we tell them," he said.

The question sat between them. She could have answered it. She could have said: the deposit, the statement, the deleted comment, the second episode that was built on a lie we agreed to fix and never fixed. Instead she said, "About Paulo. If we tell them we have incriminating footage of a neighbor's son, they'll want it. They'll want it now. And he'll sue, and the building will close to us, and everything Maria said on camera becomes—"

"Maria said what she said. That doesn't become nothing because a lawyer's involved."

"You know what I mean."

He didn't answer. A tram went by at the top of the street, and the bench vibrated with it. Duarte checked his phone, then held it out so she could see. Priya, 6:58 a.m.: Sent the tile angle to the producers. Everyone's in. I need episode three by Friday — the father/son thing if you have it. Do you have it?

Ellie read it twice.

"We don't have it," she said.

"We have something."

"We have a man in a hallway with a bag and a threat to sue us."

Duarte put the phone away. "Then we have twenty-four hours to decide what it is."

She looked at her watch. 7:20. The hostel visit was at seven, gone already, missed — she'd have to message them. Silva at ten. Maria at noon.

"Silva first," she said.

"Silva first." He stood and shouldered the bag. "And Paulo's deadline is tomorrow morning. So whatever we do, we do it before then."

They walked back up toward the building. In the window on the second floor, a curtain moved and settled. Ellie didn't say anything, and neither did Duarte, but they both walked a little faster.

At the front door, Duarte stopped with his hand on the buzzer, then didn't press it.

"If we go to Silva and he knows about Paulo already," he said, "then we're not the only ones counting down."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 24: The Son's Threat · The Perfect Ending · Lumen Reads