The Perfect Ending

Chapter 42: The Memory Project

The camera was a problem before they even turned it on.

Tiago laid down the rules in the kitchen at dawn, hands flat on the table, as if the table might otherwise float away. "No faces unless I say so. No names unless I say so. You show me everything first. I watch it, I decide, it stays or it goes. And nobody outside that door sees a second of it." He looked at Ellie. "You hold the camera. Not him."

Duarte laughed, but there was no ease in it. "Why not me?"

"Because you look at me like I'm a hospital bed," Tiago said. "And I can't work with that."

The farm had a spare room off the kitchen, whitewashed walls, a single bulb, a window that looked straight into the vineyard rows. Joaquim cleared the table, stacked crates against one wall so the light fell soft and sideways. Tiago sat with his back to the window and his hands around a coffee he didn't drink.

Ellie set the tripod low, so it caught him at eye level from a little below, which made him look less like something being examined. She'd done this a thousand times in a previous life, but always otherwise: an actor waiting to be prompted, a motion-capture volume with dots on a face. Never a man trying to find his own lines.

"Start wherever you want," she said. "You don't have to make sense."

The first hour, nothing did.

He described the road. Six weeks of it, maybe more, walking with a plastic bag of bread and a towel that had dried stiff as a board. Sleeping under the arches of the river bridge in Régua until a guard moved him along with a broom. He didn't know his age. He didn't know whether he'd ever been to Lisbon, though he said the word "Lisbon" tasted normal in his mouth, which he offered as evidence, then withdrew.

Duarte sat on the far side of the room, out of frame, and did not manage to be quiet about it. When Tiago said he once ate olives off the ground outside a bar for two days, Duarte made a small sound and stood up and went to the window and stood there with his back turned. When Tiago said, without any weight at all, that he'd thought for a while about lying down in the river and letting it decide, Duarte said, "That's enough," and reached for the camera.

"It's not your camera," Ellie said.

She hadn't meant to say it hard. But he stopped with his hand over the lens anyway, and she saw it land, the way it always landed with Duarte — he heard everything at double volume.

"Sorry," he said. He went back to the window.

Ellie kept filming. She had the discipline for it; more than she'd expected. She'd spent years writing endings for other people, and there was a certain relief in just holding a frame and letting something be unresolved. She got the shaft of light off the dust. She got the moment his thumb worried the edge of the cup. She didn't cut. In games, she'd have written him a quest line already — three objectives, a reward, a resolved arc. Here she just let him sit.

Joaquim brought in lunch at one and put it on the table and took the plates away at two. In between, Tiago said, "Can I see the notebook?"

Duarte had been carrying it in his jacket for a week. He took it out and held it a moment — the green cover soft with wear, the corners curled — and then gave it up, and the way he did it, gripping before releasing, made Ellie's chest hurt.

Tiago turned the pages slowly. He read them like a man checking another person's homework. Every few pages he'd stop and frown and flip back.

"That's my handwriting," he said once, and it wasn't a question.

"Yours," Duarte said.

"It's neat. I'm surprised."

He found a page of numbers — a till count, probably, from some bar he'd worked — and another of Portuguese words in a column beside English ones, with tick marks next to some. He touched the tick next to "amanhã" and didn't say anything.

The afternoon went slower. Fatigue got into him; he kept losing the thread of a sentence and starting it three ways. Ellie suggested stopping. He wouldn't. He said, "If I stop I forget that I remembered," which made no sense, and made total sense, and she let it into the tape.

It was past six, the light gone gold and long, when he started to hum.

Ellie almost missed it. A soft thing, under his breath, three or four notes climbing and dropping and climbing again. He stopped, looked startled, hummed it again, more deliberately. Then he sang it — two lines only, in Portuguese, cracked in places, the voice of someone eleven or twelve and sitting on a step.

His face did something she had never seen it do. It opened.

He said, "My mother."

Nobody moved.

"She'd sing that when it rained. There was — there was a"—his hands made a shape, a small rectangle, held up in front of his chest, wet cloth dripping—"she'd hang the washing up in the kitchen when it rained. So it wouldn't—" and then his mouth went on working and no sound came out, and he sat there in the ruined middle of the sentence with his own voice still hanging in the room.

Ellie did not move the camera. Not an inch. Her arms ached. She breathed through her mouth so the mic wouldn't pick her up.

When she finally looked over, Duarte had his fist pressed against his teeth and tears coming down his face without any noise at all. He was looking at Tiago, not at her — at this man who had been a stranger at breakfast and was now, at six in the evening, a person with a mother who sang about rain. Two months of Duarte holding himself rigid against the worst, and here it was cracked open by eight bars of a children's song, and he had nowhere to put it.

"Duarte," Tiago said, and it was the first time he'd used the name without hesitation. Then, "Sorry. I don't know why that did it."

"Because it's a start," Duarte said. "It's a start." His voice was wrecked. He didn't try to fix it.

Tiago wiped his face roughly with the heel of his hand and drank the cold coffee at last. "So there's a mother," he said. "Somewhere. Maybe." He looked up at the lens, a question in it, and Ellie felt the whole weight of the thing settle on her. "Will you write this down?"

On the screen, in the small viewfinder, she watched the scene sit still and breathe. Somewhere under it the farm's broken tower clock hung silent against the sky, and somewhere north a phone was ringing unanswered, and none of that was in this room. This room held one man, three rules, and eight notes.

She stopped the recording.

"I'll do more than write it down," she said. "I'll cut it so you can hear him the way he sounded, Tiago — before we knew anything about him."

He nodded, slow. "Good."

Duarte came over at last and stood behind her chair and looked at the frozen last frame, Tiago with his face open and his hand still damp with his own tears, and he said, very quietly, "You're better at this than me."

"I'm not in it," Ellie said.

He didn't argue. He put his hand on her shoulder, light, and they both looked at the frame a while longer, as though the man in it were already further away than the man on the chair.

Then her phone lit up on the table, face-down, buzzing itself in a slow circle. Soraia. The screen glowed through the case. Five seconds. Ten.

She turned the phone over and let it ring out, and this time she didn't feel the old pull to explain herself — only a flat, unfamiliar certainty that the call was about the old ending, and she was busy with a new one.

"I need to call the producer back in the morning," she said. "There's something about the Lisbon thing I've been avoiding."

Duarte looked at the phone, then at the frozen frame, and said, "Then call and tell them we're not coming."

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 42: The Memory Project · The Perfect Ending · Lumen Reads