The office address the note gave them was in Arroios, up a side street off the main drag where the tram wires crossed overhead like a cat's cradle. Number 12 had a blue door and a buzzer panel with six names, none of which read anything close to *Silva Management*.
"Maybe it's the fifth floor," Duarte said, pressing the button anyway.
Nothing buzzed back. Ellie leaned in, squinting at the panel. There was a laminated card taped at eye level, sun-bleached and curling at the corners: *Espaço Coletivo — Entrada Livre*. Free entry.
"That's not an office," she said. "That's a co-working space."
"Then our landlord has a desk here."
"Or our landlord gave us a fake address."
Duarte pushed the door. It opened. They climbed two floors of tiled stairs that smelled like coffee and old paper, and came out into a long room with mismatched chairs, standing desks, and a wall of windows that faced a construction crane. A handful of people were working. Nobody looked up.
A receptionist sat behind a counter that was really just a door laid across two filing cabinets. She had a septum ring and a laptop covered in stickers. Her name tag said *Béatrice*.
"Olá," Duarte said, switching to Portuguese, which Ellie was starting to notice he did when he wanted to sound official. "We're looking for a man who rents a desk here. Goes by Silva. Older, maybe sixties, likes to say he's in property management."
Béatrice's face did something complicated. "Sr. Silva." She said the name like it tasted bad. "He doesn't rent a desk. He used to. Until two months ago."
"Used to," Ellie repeated, in English, because she needed the phrase to land exactly.
"He left owing us three months of fees. And he took the good chair." Béatrice looked between them. "You're not the first people who've come looking for him."
Duarte's hand went to his shirt pocket. Ellie saw it. The note. He hadn't shown it to her since the police station, and she hadn't asked, which was its own kind of standoff.
"How many?" Duarte said.
"Since January? Six. Maybe seven." Béatrice pulled a battered notebook from under the counter and flipped through it. "I started keeping track. They always come in pairs, or alone, and they always ask the same thing. *Where's my deposit.*"
Ellie felt the floor tilt. Not literally. But something in her chest did, the same drop she'd felt in the meeting where the studio head had said *strategic realignment* and everyone had nodded like it meant anything.
"We paid him," she said. "Both of us. Two months upfront."
"He's good at that." Béatrice closed the notebook. "He does the tour in person, takes cash or transfer, then the flat is double-booked or the flat doesn't exist, and he's gone. Different phone every time."
"The flat exists," Duarte said. "We're living in it."
"Then you got further than most." Béatrice shrugged. "That's not a good thing. It means he's still using it. He'll come back for the key eventually."
Duarte was quiet for a second. Then: "Did he leave anything here? Papers, a box?"
"Landlord cleared the desk when the fees stopped." Béatrice paused. "There was one thing. The cleaning staff found it glued to the underside of the desk drawer. We couldn't get it off, so we just left the drawer."
"What thing?"
She disappeared into a back room and came back holding a small wooden drawer, the kind that slides into a cheap desk. On the underside, pressed into a smear of dried glue, was a single blue tile. Ceramic, hand-painted, a little chipped at one corner. A pattern of white waves on deep blue.
Ellie took it. Turned it over. Nothing on the back. It was the kind of souvenir you'd buy for two euros in a tourist town and forget in a drawer.
"Nazaré," Duarte said, without being asked. "That's a Nazaré tile. The waves."
"You've seen it before?"
"Everyone's seen it. It's the most common souvenir in Portugal." But he was frowning at it, and Ellie could tell the frown wasn't about the tile.
Béatrice was watching them. "He left it glued there like he wanted someone to find it. Or like he didn't want it to fall and break." She pulled a face. "I don't know. He was strange."
They thanked her and stepped back onto the stairs, and the door clicked behind them, and for a second neither of them said anything.
"So," Ellie said finally. "We've been scammed."
"We've been scammed," Duarte agreed.
"And we have no address, no real name, no phone that works, and a tile."
"We have the tile."
She laughed, which surprised her. It was a dry laugh, more air than sound, but it was a laugh, and Duarte looked at her like he was trying to decide whether to be offended.
"Sorry," she said. "It's just. In a game, if I wrote this, the player would be furious. They'd want the tile to mean something."
"Maybe it does."
"Maybe it's a two-euro souvenir from a town neither of us has been to."
"Maybe those aren't different things." He started down the stairs. "Come on. I need coffee before I think about this."
They found a pastelaria two blocks down, all azulejo walls and a television in the corner playing football with the sound off. Duarte ordered two *bicas* without asking her. Ellie didn't correct him. She was learning that in Lisbon, you drank what you were handed.
"So the plan," she said, wrapping her hands around the tiny cup. "We go to the police. Again."
"We already did. They filed it and told us to wait."
"Then we go back with more information. The co-working space. The other victims. Béatrice has a notebook with names."
"Béatrice has a notebook," Duarte said, "and no legal obligation to share it with us. And the police will take one look at us and see two people who signed a lease off a phone call."
Ellie put down the cup. "Then we do it ourselves."
He looked up at her.
"Not—" she said, "not vigilante stuff. I mean we find the other victims. The ones Béatrice mentioned. Six or seven people who got scammed by the same guy. If we can get even three of them to file together, it's not a roommate dispute, it's a pattern. That's a real case."
Duarte was quiet. He turned his cup in its saucer, once, twice.
"That's a lot of work," he said, "for money that maybe we never see again."
"It's not about the money." Ellie heard her own voice go sharp and pulled it back. "Okay, it's partly about the money. I have savings, but not Lisbon-rent-for-a-year savings. But it's also—he *did* this. He sat in that apartment and told both of us it was ours. He took my deposit transfer on his phone and smiled at me. I want him to know that someone remembered his face."
Duarte looked at her for a long moment. Then he pulled the note out of his shirt pocket and laid it flat on the table between them. The first time she'd seen it up close since the bin.
Rua da Boavista 14. Deliver by Thursday. And the two letters and number on the back, written in the same blocky hand as the front.
"You never asked me for this," he said.
"You never offered."
"I didn't offer because it's the only thing that connects him to something real. If I give it to you, we're two people with a piece of paper. If I keep it, I'm the one holding it." He tapped the note once. "That's not fair to you. I know that."
Ellie didn't say *no, it isn't*. She let it sit.
"Rua da Boavista 14," she said. "We still haven't been."
"No. And the note says deliver by Thursday. It's Tuesday."
"Then Thursday we go. Unless we have a better lead first." She nodded at the tile in her pocket. "Béatrice said he did the tour in person. The landlord. He showed up at our apartment. Mine first, then yours. He had keys. He knew the building."
"Or he knew the previous tenant."
"The previous tenant would know him." Ellie pulled out her phone and started typing. "There's a building group chat. The landlord set it up. I got added the day I signed."
Duarte leaned over to see her screen. The chat was seven people, mostly in Portuguese, mostly about the broken elevator. But there, in the members list, was a profile with a generic grey avatar and the name *Sr. Silva*.
"He's still in the chat," Ellie said.
"Ellie."
"He's still. In the chat." She looked up. "He didn't leave. Which means he's watching. Which means he doesn't know yet that we found each other."
Duarte sat back. A slow grin spread across his face, the first real one she'd seen from him, and it changed his whole face.
"Then we don't tell him," he said.
"We don't tell him. We don't tell *anyone* in the chat. We work quiet."
"On one condition." He held up a finger. "We clear the tape."
Ellie blinked. "The tape on the floor?"
"The living room tape. The dividing line. It's stupid. We have one scammer, one note, one tile, and I'm stepping over a strip of masking tape to get to the kettle." He held out his hand across the table. "Deal?"
Ellie looked at his hand. Then at the note. Then at the small blue tile, which was still cold in her pocket, and which meant nothing except that a man had glued it somewhere and left.
She took his hand.
"Deal," she said. "But I'm keeping my half of the fridge."
"Obviously. I'm not a monster."
They sat back. Outside, the tram rattled past and the television flickered a red card nobody in the café reacted to. Across the table, the note sat between them, both of them now looking at it, both of them now on the same side of it. Thursday was two days away. Somewhere in this city, a man with a grey avatar and a suitcase full of other people's deposits was going about his day, not yet knowing that two strangers had just stopped being strangers.
Ellie picked up her coffee, and it had gone cold, and she drank it anyway.