The Proof of the Pudding

Chapter 27: The Fight That Confesses Everything

Bertrand's coffee cup was still on her counter, a ring of moisture bleeding into the wood grain. Mathilde picked it up, poured the cold remains down the sink, and set the cup in the drying rack like she could organize the morning into a shape she understood.

Gabriel was in the hallway with his coat still on, reading the ownership chain for the third time, as if the fourth reading would change the number at the bottom. He'd come straight from the printer, the pages warm, and she'd heard him take the stairs two at a time.

"You were listening at the door," she said.

"I was listening from the stairwell. There's a difference." He folded the pages along their existing creases. "You told me to let him talk. You didn't say I couldn't hear."

"I told you to hold the chain." She leaned against the counter. "You came up early."

"He said something to you." Gabriel didn't look at her. He looked at the cup on the rack. "Before I knocked. I heard the tone, not the words."

Mathilde's arms crossed before she decided to cross them. "You've been circling this since the sampling. Since before that." She could feel the precision coming into her voice, the same measured register she used for a broken ganache, and she hated it. "So ask me plainly."

Gabriel set the papers on the table, on top of the evidence file, which was its own kind of statement. "What did he offer you."

"To make the complaint disappear if I signed at a lower price."

"That's not what I asked."

She stared at him. He was standing very still, the way he stood when a sauce was about to break and he'd already decided he couldn't save it.

"You want to know what I said," she said. "I said nothing. I let him talk. That was the plan you and I made last night in this room."

"And before I knocked, what did you say."

"I said I'd think about it."

Gabriel's jaw shifted. He picked the papers back up, then put them down again, then picked them up, and Mathilde watched him do it and felt something come loose in her chest, a screw that had been holding a rack in place for years.

"For the staff," she said. "He put the staff in my mouth and I didn't have an answer ready. That's what he does. That's the entire technique."

"He didn't put them in your mouth. He put them in the room." Gabriel's voice was climbing, which was rare, and she heard the accent get thicker with it. "You signed a lease. You signed payroll. You put them in the room yourself, every month, and he just walked into it."

"What is that supposed to mean."

"It means I've been standing in your kitchen for six months watching you do arithmetic you never let anyone help with. You told me about the loan defaults — his, not yours, I know. You told the staff they're paid through Friday before you told me. Before you told anyone."

"Someone had to tell them."

"Someone always has to, and it's always you."

Mathilde's hands were flat on the counter now. "Say the actual thing, Gabriel."

The actual thing landed between them and sat there.

He said it without preparation, which is the only way it could have come out honest. "I stayed because you're the best baker I've ever worked beside. Better than Bertrand's kitchen. Better than the three-Michelin place in Paris I walked out of. Better than my own name on a menu. I said what I said publicly because I was afraid to say that, and if you think for one second I'd have given up my—" He stopped. Started again. "My loan, my installments, my entire ridiculous schedule of debt, to stand in a padlocked bakery with someone I didn't—"

He didn't finish it.

Mathilde crossed the kitchen. She didn't decide to. Her body made the decision while the rest of her was still arguing about it, and she stopped one step short of him because she was thirty-four years old and there was still a table with forged statements on it between them and she was not going to be a woman who fell into anything.

"What," she said. Quiet. Almost French-quiet, the kind that ends arguments in her family.

Gabriel looked at her. Whatever she was bracing for — a retreat, a joke, the public voice he used for cameras — didn't come. He just looked at her, tired, and she saw the last six months arranged in his face like a mise en place, every item labeled.

She closed the last step.

The kiss was bad at first. They came in at the wrong angle and her nose caught his cheekbone, and she laughed once, or breathed something that could be mistaken for it, and then his hand was at the back of her neck and it was not bad at all. He smelled like the outside, like November in Lyon and printer toner, and tasted like the terrible coffee from the machine in the copy shop, and her back hit the cold proofer with a dull metal thud that she felt in her spine.

The proofer was off. It had been off for two weeks. The steel was cold against her shoulder blades through her sweater and she pressed into it anyway, and Gabriel's other hand was flat on the door beside her head, and for eleven seconds — she would not have claimed to count, but the clock on the wall was digital — the whole situation was simply not her problem.

Then the clock on the wall was still digital, and the evidence file was still on the table, and she pulled back.

She put a hand flat on his chest, not pushing, just holding the distance where it was.

"That's not," she said. Stopped. Started over. "Today is not the day for this."

"I know."

"There is a padlock on my front door. There is a complaint with a forged signature on my table. I've got five employees I can pay for two more days." She heard her own voice going precise again and let it. "And Bertrand is somewhere in this city right now deciding his next move, and you're the thing that would make me stupid."

"I know," Gabriel said. He hadn't moved. His hand was still up near her head, curled now, not touching anything. "I've been the thing that would make you stupid for about four months."

"Since the sampling."

"Since your lemon tart in October." He stepped back. One step, then another, and the cold of the proofer moved into the space where he'd been. "The one with the burnt butter. I ate it standing up in your back room and thought, that's it, that's the whole problem."

Mathilde smoothed her sweater. She straightened a towel on the rail, then straightened it again.

"We don't talk about it," she said.

"We don't talk about it."

"Not until this is finished."

"Not until this is finished," he agreed.

They stood there in her kitchen like two people who had just signed a contract neither had read.

Then Mathilde went to the table and sat down in front of the evidence file, and Gabriel stayed by the counter and picked up the ownership chain, and they both looked at their separate documents with the intense, devoted attention of people who had decided, separately, that eye contact was now an operational hazard. The rain started again outside, working at the window. Neither of them said anything about the cold proofer, or about what her back had felt pressed against it, or about the fact that Gabriel Delacroix — the man whose public quote about her tarts was still pinned to her wall under a magnet — had just said something with his whole chest and no camera anywhere in the room.

Mathilde turned a page she had already read three times.

The buzzer on the wall went off. They both jumped.

It wasn't the door — the intercom was dead, padlocked along with everything else. It was her phone, face-down on the evidence file, vibrating its way across the forged statement in a slow crawl toward the edge of the table.

The screen said: UNKNOWN PARIS NUMBER.

She looked at Gabriel. He was already looking at her.

She picked it up.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 27: The Fight That Confesses Everything · The Proof of the Pudding · Lumen Reads