The Proof of the Pudding

Chapter 37: The Cake That Wasn't Fun

The Fournil's kitchen was forty-one degrees and Mathilde had stopped feeling her fingertips an hour ago, which was fine, because the genoise did not care about her fingertips. It cared about air. It cared about the whip, the wrist, the exact second the batter turned from loose gold to a ribbon that held its shape for three slow counts.

Gabriel stood at the far end of the steel counter with his sleeves rolled past his elbows, weighing sugar.

"You're hovering," she said.

"I'm weighing."

"Thirty grams over the line."

He looked down. Adjusted. Said nothing.

Twelve days to the tasting and they had a church hall, a registered association, a poster with a threat photographed beside it and no cake. Anouk had been immovable on the point: one centerpiece, *le gâteau qui a fait ses preuves*. A cake that had proven itself. Mathilde had spent four nights arguing with her own notebook about what that could possibly mean—a cake that proved something, or a cake already proven. In the end the answer was boring and French and correct. A fraisier. Strawberries in June were obscene and expensive and exactly what you made when you wanted a room full of people to remember your grandmother's name.

The trouble was the genoise. Fraisiers were built on architecture, and the architecture was failing.

She folded the batter with the flat of her hand—down the side, across the bottom, up, a movement as old as her wrists—and it deflated slightly under her palm, sighing the way batter does when you've been too confident.

"Over-folded," Gabriel said.

"I know."

"Third one."

"I *know*."

He set the whisk down. The kitchen's two working rings, salvaged from the back pantry on an extension cord Léa had run through the window, threw a thin orange light across the wall. No heat. They'd been baking by candlelight and headlamp since the suspension and everything took three times as long, and everything tasted like the inside of a cold room.

"Let it come to room temperature before you fold," he said. "Your butter's too cold. It's seizing."

"Thank you, Chef."

"It's not an insult."

"Everything you say sounds like an insult. It's the accent."

He laughed—one short breath through the nose, which from Gabriel was practically a ballad. She turned to the second bowl, the sponge she'd made at four in the morning when she couldn't sleep, and began the same fold, and her elbow caught the rim of the third bowl, the bowl she'd left balanced on the corner of the counter because the counter was too small for two people and their ambitions, and forty grams of sifted flour went up in a white slow cloud and came down on both of them.

Silence.

Gabriel looked at his forearms. They were dusted white to the elbow, like a man who had lost an argument with a snowstorm.

Mathilde's mouth twitched.

"Don't," he said.

"I didn't say anything."

"Your face is saying it."

She picked up a pinch of flour off the counter and flicked it at his chest. It hit and bloomed. He stared at the mark, then at her, with the disbelief of a man discovering a law of physics he had assumed was theoretical.

"That's the last of the flour," he said.

"I'm aware."

"So you've just cost us a genoise."

"Worth it."

He took flour off his own forearm and threw it back at her. It caught her in the ear. She shrieked—an undignified, high, entirely un-Mathilde sound that she had not made since she was nine and her brother had put a frog in her apron—and then she was laughing, actually laughing, hands on her knees, headlamp swinging, and Gabriel was laughing too, and neither of them could stop, and the kitchen rang with it, that awful cavernous unfurnished laugh of a room that hasn't held anyone happy in months, and it went on longer than the joke deserved because they were both so tired and had been so afraid for so long that joy had nowhere to go but this, a flour fight at two in the morning over a collapsed cake.

Then it stopped.

Not gradually. All at once, the way a door closes.

They were standing close. Closer than the counter allowed, which meant one of them had moved. Mathilde could see the flour on his collarbone and the flour in the creases of his rolled sleeves and the exact place where a laugh had left a line at the corner of his mouth, and she could hear her own breathing, which had not slowed down when the laughing did, and neither had his.

Her hand was on the counter between them. His was four centimeters away. If either of them moved a finger, they would touch.

*Don't*, she thought, and could not have said to whom.

Gabriel took a step back.

The movement was so deliberate, so controlled, that it read like a man stepping away from a hot pan. He picked up a bench scraper. He turned to the sink. He began, methodically, to clean the flour off the steel counter in long grey strokes, starting from the far end, working away from her.

Mathilde turned to the genoise she had not yet poured.

They worked in silence for twenty minutes at opposite ends of the counter. The candles guttered in the window draft. At her end she lined the ring mold with parchment, and at his end he washed and dried the bowls and stacked them in the exact order she liked, which he had learned, which she had never told him. At her end she poured the batter, too-defensive and probably still wrong. At his end he began to pack his knife roll, and she heard the long zipper, and she did not turn around.

At the door he stopped.

"Mathilde."

"Mm."

Air. Candlelight. The smallest sounds in the world.

"I should go," he said. "I have the market shoot in the morning."

"I know. You told me."

"It's at seven."

"I *know*, Gabriel."

Another pause. She had her back to him and could feel him deciding something, and she prayed, in a way that was not quite prayer, that he would decide it and leave it and go.

"Right," he said. The door opened. The cold came in at her ankles. "The fraisier. Test the second sponge in the morning, the one you made at four. It'll be better. You bake angry."

The door closed.

She listened to his motorcycle start, all the way down the alley, all the way out of the Croix-Rousse, all the way gone. Then she set both hands flat on the counter and leaned on them and let her shoulders drop and stayed there for a long moment in the dark of her cold kitchen with flour in her hair.

On the counter, beside the mold, sat her phone. She looked at it and picked it up and opened the thread of photographs—the poster, the window, the soaped letters spelling POISONER, all of it, the file she'd built so carefully—and scrolled past them to the bottom, to a message she hadn't answered.

*Friday*, Manon had written. *I'll tell you Friday.*

Today was Thursday. The tasting was Saturday. Friday was tomorrow, and tomorrow Manon would decide or she wouldn't, and everything Mathilde had built for eleven days would either stand or not, and she had just spent her last cup of flour throwing it at Gabriel Christophe.

She should have been furious at herself.

Instead, standing in the dark with the flour settling slowly on the floor around her, she found she could still feel the four centimeters of counter between her hand and his, and she knew, with a clarity that had nothing to do with the evidence file, that she would have to build something stronger than a cake or a case, because the case was not the only thing in this room that could still fall.

Her phone buzzed.

Léa.

*Check your email. Something's happened with the hall.*

Mathilde opened it. Read it twice. Then a third time, standing very still at the cold end of the counter with flour in her ear, while the Franche-Comté butter she had bought with her own money softened slowly into uselessness beside her.

The email was from the parish council. Eight lines. Formal. Regretful. It informed her that, following correspondence from a party with standing, the association's booking of the church hall for Saturday the fourteenth had been cancelled, effective immediately, on the grounds that the event might constitute a resumption of suspended commercial activity under an alternate name.

A motion had been filed. This afternoon.

Bertrand Dufaure had struck before the cake existed.

Back to book

Sign in or create an account

Sign in with Google to keep your library and reading progress on every device.

Continue with Google

By continuing you agree to our Terms and Privacy.

Chapter 37: The Cake That Wasn't Fun · The Proof of the Pudding · Lumen Reads